Like I get how people might see HRT or blockers for children as critical, there's an entire ethical problem about testing drugs' interactions with children's bodies so the child's body in general isn't as well understood as we'd like it to be. Hormones, as an entire thing, aren't as well understood as we'd like them to be either. So, I get wanting to be cautious there, I get the opinion that letting even children that know they are trans go through the wrong puberty first to medically transition later, because at least we feel like we're knowledgeable enough to get them through it healthily, and only throw the HRT at their bodies once they are "settled" and "done developing". I also get the opposing opinion, focusing on the mind being part of the body, the psychological torture that is going through the wrong puberty and the irreversible physical effects of letting that happen.
This is the medical side of the discussion, and I very much support this discussion being held. We need to, scientifically, get to the bottom of this.
However, medical is far from being the only way to transition.
And every transphobic shit going beyond "I'd rather see more research here and am voicing my criticism of the lack of research, maybe hoping for people to be more thorough in their own research after reading my critical opinion, individual people's decisions are none of my business though" is just that.
It's shit, rooted about everywhere.
The belief that sick people (these people consider being trans a kind of sickness, usually just like being disabled) are lesser people in some way, that need to be managed by healthy/abled/normal people, to be cured of everything that makes them nonconforming, or disposed of. Not necessarily in the nazi way mind you, just cut out from regular society.
The belief that gender norms are laws of nature instead of weirdly specific rules we as a society made up over the centuries, for many different reasons. A lot of them being misogyny, but not all.
And of course overwhelm. Humans like rules, they like putting things in boxes, they like simplifying their world. After all we're still running on MonkeyOS, even if there's a fuckton of processing power behind it now. Rules and boxes make us feel safe, and reduce the mental load that is just perceiving and processing the world around us. And let's be honest here, the world is getting more overwhelming every day. So what those people feel is us evil trans people trying to rip their safe little box from them, that's protecting them from the storm that is the world, at least a little. It's both a lack of proper education and a lack of community that's at fault here, that is my belief at least, a lack of healthy coping methods that leads to people building dream castles out of rules and pretending that's how the world looks like, clinging to their belief even when faced with solid evidence that they are wrong, because it was never about being right, it was about living in denial of being a miserable little animal all alone in a cruel world.
In the end, in kinda all boils down to a system that is designed to keep us isolated and overwhelmed, so we don't band together and fight for change, but remain bound, through our energy being barely sufficient for our own survival. It really is all the same fight. Climate action, disability rights, trans rights, women's rights, worker's rights, etc. We're all fighting the exact same system of oppression.
So can we please stop the infighting our collective enemies love to see in our ranks?
Signed, a tired, disabled transmasc nonbinary person, that needs to struggle through the hostile job market and the catastrophic medical system simultaneously right now, but would rather be on the streets fighting.