Eternally Complaining About Mando'a

Arondir - 5/10. Passable but would be significantly improved with nicer hair

Celebrimbor - 0/10. Looks nearly as old as my grandma and dresses like her too

Elrond - 5/10. Initially had him lower but since he is half-elven I will be lenient. I look at his hair and think of curry puff

Finrod - 0/10. Nóm the Wise more like Brent the Jock

Galadriel - 1/10. Looks like an elf, but not the Tolkien kind more like the little people who live in mushroom rings kind

Gil-Galad - 0/10. Am I looking at the High King of the Noldor or an eccentric Roman Emperor in fancy dress? Hail Caesar!

Like I would have believed "He saw me decapitating an orc and fell in love at first sight." because at least it sounds consistent with what has been shown of her character on screen

Also the whole dancing in a field of flowers, love at first sight thing is pretty obviously ripped from Beren and Lúthien's love story

Knowing that encounter between Beren and Lúthien was based on a real life moment Tolkien had with his wife - one that had a lot of meaning and significance to him - and they literally have Beren and Lúthien carved on their graves