I'm getting so tired of the way the discourse around "trans representation" throws transmascs who like vaginal penetrationβand even more so trans men who want to get pregnantβunder the bus.
"You're just giving that character a vagina for porn reasons!" Yeah, you know what? Sometimes I am. There's a character I love whom I see as cis, and so the only time I'd write him as trans is if I have a "reason" to do so. And for me, that reason is usually my massive pregnancy kink. Does that mean that when I write him as trans, it automatically doesn't "count" as trans representation because I'm doing it for gross fetish reasons?
And actually, I see this character so strongly as cis that, sometimes, instead of making him trans, I'll make the setting omegaverse and make him an omega. (I write my omega men as bigenital with vaginas and penises.) And I agree that this isn't "trans representation" per se. He isn't trans in these stories. But it is still a trans wish-fulfillment fantasy in the form of, "Wouldn't it be interesting if it were universally societally accepted that some men have vaginas and can get pregnant?" And it does still touch on issues that actual trans men face, like being seen as less of a man due to his genital configuration. But I'm ultimately doing it because I want to see him pregnant, so I guess none of that allegory "counts".
Meanwhile, there's a different character that I do see as trans. I will always write him as a trans man no matter what. Even in omegaverse settings I make him a trans male alpha rather than an omega. Is that "better" trans representation than when I make the other guy trans, because I'm not doing it "just" for porn reasons? Or is it still no good because I write him as a vers-leaning-bottom and get him knocked up all the time?
It's just frustrating because I am a trans man who loves having a vagina and who has seriously considered getting pregnant. So I like any stories where it's treated as normal for men to have vaginas and be pregnant. To me, that's important representation. And I'm so tired of my personal wish-fulfillment stories being seen as illegitimate because obviously no real trans man could want what I want.
And, like, I get it. Believe it or not, I used to be extremely dysphoric about PiV sex and pregnancy too. I understand that this can be a trigger for some people. But I wish people would stop making their own dysphoria everyone else's problem. Or even worse, people who aren't even transmasc taking those trans men's dysphoria and using it to attack other trans men who aren't dysphoric in that way. I wish people would understand that no two trans people have the exact same experience, and that just because someone's fantasies involve something that some trans men don't like, that doesn't mean they're an evil fetishizing fujo victimizing the real trans men.
And frankly? I'm cool with the fetishizing fujos too, as long as they're respectful to actual real-life trans people. Let's hold hands and write FTMpreg together.
Honestly, a lot of people could stand to learn to identify when they're having a mental health crisis instead of assuming it's a typical and proportionate reaction to some random AO3 fic.