People love to talk about the cheap labor in China, and âoutsourcingâ to foreign countries in general for the massive savings to the business. But what is truly the cheapest labor of all?
Imagine a group of people who are willing â excited, even â to work for free, do anything you ask, and have no laws or regulations to protect them from complications resulting from their employment.
It isnât far different from, say, Chinese workers piecing together our smartphones, but there is a key distinction. They get paid. Barring some horrifying circumstance that eludes exposure, those workers receive compensation for the time and energy expended toward their employerâs benefit. They may not have any other rights or protection from abuse, but at least they receive money for their efforts. Their employer is not able to extract value from their workers, and advance the interests of their business, without due compensation.
So where does this group of unpaid, neglected, and misfortunate individuals live? Theyâre right here in these United States, and their numbers are multiplying. Not only that, but once youâre a part of that group, it will follow you for the rest of your lifeâŚ
It all started for Susan (not her real name) with a chance meeting on the street. A friendly face with a clipboard asked if she might have a few minutes to answer some questions. Susan, not in a rush, agreed and was ushered into the nearby restaurant to sit down and for the interview. A series of demographic questions ensued about age, marital status, children, etc. Then some specific questions:
> Have you renovated or remodeled in the past 5 years?
No, but we sure could use it!
> Have you ever been on television?
> Is that an idea that appeals to you?
Susan was then given a short stack of forms to fill out, with all kinds of questions related to her personal life, background, and family history. There were plenty of left-field queries like, âHave you ever sued someone, or been sued in a court of law?â Hmm.
Then there were the waivers, about 22 pages worth. Even without any legal experience, it was clear to Susan that she was pretty much âsigning her life away,â as they say. She waived every conceivable right you could imagine, including the perpetual use of her name and image, and those of her family. She gave up any right to pursue legal remedy of any kind, resulting from her participation, even though she still had no idea what she might be participating in.
Once complete, the interviewer congratulated her for being selected to move on to the second round.
âGreat! Second round of what, exactly?â
They went on to explain that they were casting for a reality show, and there was a grand prize worth âa lot of money.â At the mention of money, and the chance to win some, Susanâs mind jumped to all the pressing financial obligations their family was up against, most of them currently unresolved. Any chance to pull her family out of their financial quagmire was a shining beacon she would instinctively follow, no matter what the circumstances... Perfect.
Itâs fair to say that Susanâs experience was pretty typical for any eventual contestant/participant of a reality show. There are interviews, odd questions, vagary and secrecy around the details of the show. The promise of a prize or prizes is continually dangled, particularly when approaching some of the more uncomfortable aspects of the casting process. Casting agents behave sort of like an Ari Gold-type character, but much gentler. Itâs all ego-stroking and wishful language, and endless reasons why participation in the show will be such an amazing experience. The unspoken incentive is âfameâ â youâll be famous!
They handle every step of the way as if the potential cast member is one step closer to the valuable prize. Cameras might show up at your house â Ed McMahon-style â and cause a big fuss in your neighborhood.
âOooh, whatâs going on at Susanâs house? Are those TV cameras?â
Youâre awarded with your spot on the show as though you have already won, and that itâs all just fun and games from there. They usually fly you somewhere, maybe even an exotic, tropical locale, and put you up in a hotel. Then in most cases you move into a âmansionâ where you're forced to share space with X number of total strangers, who may or may not share your reasons for being there.
What, I assume, must go unnoticed is that they pack the Production staff of any major reality show with smart people who are quite skilled at what they do. They are master manipulators â not necessarily in a negative sense, to be fair â and much of their role is to cast (and direct) the show in a way that will deliver the drama and intrigue that their viewers will want and expect. If itâs a dating show, there will be a person well-suited to you, but there might be some fatal flaw that youâll only discover later in the timeline of the show â cue the drama.
Susan was cast for a specific reason, though she definitely didnât know it at the time. She was representing the âMomâ-like character in the shared house where they filmed the show. She was on the older end of the age range, she had kids and a house and a dog. She was a perfect match for the âAll American Momâ figure that they had written into the intended trajectory of the story that the Producers had plotted.
As the first episode aired, it was immediately clear: Susan was the old lady of the cast. There were competitions unsuited to her body type and physical abilities. The younger cast members treated her like an outsider, and this fed right into the plot line of the show⌠Which by the way, is âcompletely unscripted, and realâ according to the network.
Susanâs example is one of the tamest I could find. Many of the examples involve an almost identical story, but post-show the cast member experienced a backlash in their personal life that will haunt them forever. Think âTeen Momâ on MTV. While not a competition, it illustrates my point. They joined the show to âbe famous,â without any thought of what the exposure of the gritty details of their lives might produce. And we can be pretty sure that the Producers werenât helping her to think ahead, or examine all the potential consequences that might come from letting America into your home, and your daily life. What seemed at first glamorous, immediately becomes embarrassing, or worse, once the show starts airing.
So the promise of a chance at a valuable prize, and the unspoken promise of âfameâ seems to be more than enough to attract all manner of people to apply for, and take part in, reality shows. If you already have any modicum of fame or popularity, then you see the show as âgreat exposureâ for whatever product or service you might be hawking in your personal life.
Of course there are reality shows that compensate the participants, but they only offer that to cast members who can demand payment due to existing fame or popularity (or niche audience) that they already have.
During filming, usually there are ârulesâ to the game, but almost every detail from start to finish can be, and often is, changed by the Producers without any notice or justification. For example, in Big Brother. If one player has somehow gained an advantage, and seems like they might cruise to an easy win, the Producers will stage and target a competition toward that personâs biggest weakness.
Of course they know everything about you, based on the infinitely detailed casting process, so they know exactly how to push your buttons in a very real sense. So letâs say the player is big, strong, and handsome. The competition to try to bring balance back to the competition (and thus be more entertaining) would likely be puzzle- or trivia-based. One of the underdog-types (e.g. the "nerd") wins. Now power shifts in the house and, Voila! Drama, the lifeblood of any reality show, whether admitted or not.
In the end, someone will win the prize⌠or not. There are some shows that donât even award the prize at the end, due to no competitors meeting the requirements established for winning. Sometimes there might even be a much smaller second prize, but the vast majority of the cast â each of whom withstood the same level of pressure and consequences from being on the show â walk away empty-handed.
At best, they end up having a positive image and light shone on them as a result of the final edit of the show. At worst, for the rest of your life youâre known as the guy who ate a bucket full of bull penises, for nothing. Or worse still, some occurrence on the show ends up portraying you in a negative light â due to something you said or did, or even to no fault of your own â and youâre forever known for that mistake.
So each contestant does in fact:
Tell the Producers anything and everything about their personal lives.
Sign away all their rights and protections from potential negative consequences of their participation.
Do anything and everything the Producers tell them to do during filming.
On average probably 99% end up totally uncompensated. They did all that for free. Zero tangible benefit, and higher odds of negative than positive perception as a result of their appearance on the show.
Could there be any cheaper labor than this? Even owners of indentured servants compensated them in some way. Dare I say it? â Not since slavery has there existed such an imbalance of invested value vs. compensation. Well, maybe interns, but at least theyâre getting job training.Â