bagelbites101

And I have never known defeat

If theres no such thing as thought crime, theres also no such thing as thought benevolence.

If you can't be persecuted for actions not taken from the privacy of your own head, you also can't be rewarded for it. What really matters is what you DO, regardless of how "good" or "bad" your thought patterns are.

You can read all the theory you want and argue on twitter all day, but if you don't actually do anything, you're not doing anything. Someone who buys a muffin at a local fundraiser bakesale does more for directly positive community action than someone who has all the "correct opinions" about political topics while refusing to even vote. An establishment democrat who kicks 20 bucks to a queer youth charity does more for positive community action than a communist who won't do anything that doesn't directly lead to some fantasy revolution

The concept of thought crime, and by extension the proposed “thought benevolence”, refers to things that exist entirely within the mind, the original idea being that you’ll be punished for not “thinking right” as a commentary on the idea that one should have a right to their own thoughts (that’s roughly the idea, at least). Looking at the post’s presented examples of “thought benevolence” we have reading theory, arguing on twitter, and talking. None of these exist within the mind, they all involve direct interaction with the outside world. They aren’t thoughts at all, they’re actions.

People reading this may or may not have noticed, but this is actually very well aligned with the way conservatives use the concept of thought crime. We’ve seen time and time again people loudly call for violence against a marginalized group, receive negative responses, and then claim they’re being persecuted by the “liberal thought police” for their “difference of opinion”. It’s treating action as thought, just like here.

This misuse serves a different purpose though, which you can see by comparing the “thoughts” (reading, talking, arguing) to the “actions” (voting, puchasing, donating). The purpose here is to present some actions as not accomplishing anything and others as making progress. Notice how all of the “actions” here are very polite, follow the status quo, align with neoliberal values, and can be talked about publicly without issue. The idea presented here subtly becomes “if I/polite society don’t approve of the action you’re taking, then you aren’t even taking an action at all, you’re just thinking and doing nothing”. Even the goals of such a person are presented as existing fully in their head (they want a “fantasy revolution”).

i initially only posted this on twitter but why not put it here too. i made an Enemies Meme template, for when you have two characters that just can't stand each other

Download the uBlock Origin extension (it's great). Firefox, Chrome

Then! Right click on the store icon, it'll bring up a menu, go down to 'Block Element'

Once you click that, it'll bring up this menu on the bottom right of your screen, select 'pick'

Then you use the little picker to hover just so over the new flag until it's outlined in red and click it:

Once that's selected, go back down to the box at the bottom right and hit create.

Now do a little dance because it's gone, gone, GONE!

all the trans boys and nb people who are going to get ‘girly’ presents

all the trans girls and nb people who are going to get ‘masculine’ presents

all the lesbians who are going to be asked why they don’t have a boyfriend/husband

all the gay boys who are going to be asked why they don’t have a girlfriend/wife

all the closeted kids who are going to have to listen to their families being homophobic, transphobic, and bigoted 

all the lgbt kids who have to spend time with their abusive family members

all the lgbt kids who are spending christmas alone bc they are unwelcome around family

all the trans boys and nb people who are going to have to dress wrong and will be misgendered

all the trans girls and nb people who are going to have to dress wrong and will be misgendered

“An ear of corn with translucent colourless liquid dripping down it, in a field, at sunset, golden hour, award winning photography”

Sharing is caring!

Substack: dalle.substack.com

Twitter: @Dalle2AI

Crimson Blade of Vengeance ⚔