Okay okay everybodyâs been reblogging That Rich Post From MONTHS AGO that mentions that the theory that PW is the player, going âum actually itâs PRESTON and NOT the PLAYER so RICH must be the playerâ
And unless CH5 has some complete plot twist that Iâll go into later, thereâs one big reason I cannot take âPlayer Richâ theories seriously:
Rich cannot shut up to save his life.
It has been a defining trait since chapter one, it has been established in EVERY TAPE, in chapter two Rich even confirms he talks to himself. He blurts out things he shouldnât say, he hums when things are quiet.
So unless CH5 reveals he had his throat torn out or something, I cannot believe heâd be a Silent Protagonist.
Honestly the only character I can think of is Avery. He gets brought up in CH2, the Employee Handbook, and heâs even in the Fortnite update. For whatever reason, heâs important.
That, and the fact that heâs the one of the first voices we ever hear. The order goes:
Elliot Ludwig - the founder, reason this whole thing happened
Poppy Playtime - the namesake of the game
Leith Pierre - the Head of Innovation, major character
Avery - some guy, followed by Rich.
Him being a foil to Rich by being much quieter is also an intentional element of his character, because in the earlier placeholders for the CH1 tapes, his dialogue is completely different. The rest of the placeholders are rather similar, but Averyâs dialogue went through an overhaul. The devs made a conscious decision to make Avery quieter, a trait more befitting of a silent protagonist.
And hey, it fits more with Sawyerâs dialogue. Harley wouldâve likely recognised a fellow Head, since Rich was Head of Shipping. Avery was just a warehouse worker.