There are multiple things I could (and probably will, unless I forget as I’m typing the preceding thought…) say to this. Because, like… I get it, Anon. Oh fuck do I get it.
The simplest one is cake. And it’s, really, at the core of a lot of lessons about this. You see a prettier cake than you think you could make, and you want to put your baking utensils and ingredients away. But someone else will see two cakes and be excited about the extra cake! Yet some other person might not enjoy the flavor the baker picked for the fancy fancy cake, but hears you made a cherry lemon cake and started drooling like one of Pavlov’s dogs. Your cake is just what they were craving!
I know (this is where I digress into Actual Cake, rather than cake as metaphor, but I think the actual cake still serves the metaphor) some days I have a hankering for American grocery store sheet cake with mediocre frosting. Some nights I want nothing more than a chocolate mug cake even though I know the cake my recipe makes is kinda rubbery. I could get objectively better cake than that. Something that wouldn’t make Mary Berry cry. But right then, I have a specific craving. I can’t do much about wanting grocery store cake, but you better believe I’m going for that mug cake!
So on to some of my personal experiences with this kind of thinking:
I have a kind of love-hate relationship with writing smut. I can’t say I outright hate it, but it is a struggle nearly every time, and tends to slow my progress to a crawl. We’re talking half the word count per hour or less. It’s probably at least in part because I don’t have a lot of practice.
See, my husband @somecrazyskunk (sorry about the random tag, hon, I’m just proud of you) writes great smut. And at some point I slipped into comparing us. Why write this when I know he could do it so much better? Isn’t that just wasting the idea? (I did this with non-smut, too, but it’s stronger with the smut because I’m so unconfident with it.)
But the thing is… I don’t live in his brain. Just because he could write some idea I have better doesn’t mean he has any interest in writing it at all. So if I keep leaving all the good ideas to him, they’ll just… sit in limbo forever. And that’s truly wasting the idea. (Besides, while there’s overlap between us he doesn’t enjoy all the same things I do, and I need my fix of the sort of dead dove fuckery that he’d rather not think about.)
And when I mentioned this feeling of… let’s call it inferiority, though it’s more nuanced than that, to a friend, he made another great point: just because I made cake and hubby-dearest made cake doesn’t mean everyone is going to see both cakes. My friend reads my work, so if I don’t write it he doesn’t get cake at all.
Incidentally, I also happen to think my friend fucking kills it as a writer, so it’s flattering as hell when he says he likes my work. At least twice when he’s beta read stuff for me he’s said something to the effect of “I was sad when I could tell I was coming up to the end” and if that’s not one hell of a compliment and confidence booster I don’t know what is.
It does help to get a little insane about a character (or a set of them). In the last two years and change I’ve been a completely normal (ha!) amount of unhinged about one of my OC’s and one of my friends’. I’ve got like two dozen WIPs with them, I have written and posted a little over another dozen. And, genuinely? In this time, I’ve written at least two fics that I felt were significantly better than anything I’ve written before. Fics I was, like… extra proud of. A few more than that I’ve been satisfied enough with to be chomping at the bit to have them ready to post.
Two major things went into those fics happening, and turning out a step above: practice and obsession. I cannot understate how much being absolutely wormbrained about these guys has done for my writing process.
I’m not saying getting that insane about some guys is something you can force, nor that it’s absolutely necessary, but if you can find something you’re so passionate about that you keep turning it over in your head whenever your brain is otherwise idling, it does help. Might occasionally drive you a little bit crazy, but it does help.
The last thing I want to share about my own experiences is this: For some reason I go into hating practically everything I create and feeling like “what’s the point?” about once a month (yes, it’s a PMS thing). It sucks. But it’s not about my actual skill. I’m pretty sure there’s nothing that could convince my brain that what I create is Good Enough when it gets like that. While that realization doesn’t always get me writing, it has helped me put the feelings into perspective.
Because the doubt doesn’t come from how good or bad I am at it. The doubt comes from somewhere else (in my case my brain chemistry not playing nicely with my hormones). And I think that’s true for a lot of people who think they’re worse at the thing than everyone around them.
So bake that cake. Do it scared if you have to. Find a friend into the same shit you are (same fandom or same tropes or dynamics doesn’t really matter as long as they’re someone you can hype with) and talk to them as you work. Share excerpts that you’re excited about, or passages you’re having trouble with. You don’t have to share the final product with anyone else, but having at least that one friend will help keep you from feeling isolated. Which in my experience kills creativity and drive.
Though if you choose to share, I can almost guarantee someone will be excited to see it. Maybe not today or tomorrow or even a week or month from now. Maybe they won’t comment on your fic. Maybe they won’t even leave a kudos (please leave kudos when you enjoy something, everyone!). But the person who thinks you picked the perfect ingredients for your cake is somewhere out there.
And a lot of people are pretty willing to ignore if your cake has a slightly weird texture or raw spots or is a little charred on the corners. (Though I suspect you’re harder on yourself than you need to be, Anon.) We’re not all going to win the Great British Bake-off. But if only bake-off winners were allowed to bake, there would be hell of a lot less cake in the world.
(Also have a look at Cakewrecks. There’s professional bakers putting out stuff that is pretty embarrassing. And I can promise you that happens in the writing world as well. I can’t be the only one who opened a traditionally published book from a decent-sized publisher and went “what the fuck were they on when they bought this?” But the publisher evidently thought it was good enough to serve to the public, so… 🤷)