Why I may be the most unusual Potterhead ever to walk the face of the earth
I think I've finally realised something after more than twenty years as a Potterhead: I'm a very unusual Harry Potter fan.
First of all, I'm a book fan rather than a film fan. I enjoy the films, but apart from Prisoner of Azkaban, there isn't a single one that I absolutely adore.
In fact, here's a terribly controversial opinion: the only adaptation I actually prefer to the book is Deathly Hallows (Part 2). I really dislike the final novel, but I think the final film works surprisingly well.
Secondly, let's compare Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings, because I do believe they excel at completely different things.
Harry Potter has far more complex and human characters.
The Lord of the Rings has a stronger story, a more coherent mythology, and a much more satisfying ending. And that brings me to my biggest revelation.
After all these years, I've realised that I love Harry Potter but I don't love plot. Wait, don't throw stones at me yet. Let me explain:
I've never particularly enjoyed war stories;
I've never been interested in competitions;
Teenage drama has never been my thing (not even when I was a child or a teen myself);
the Horcrux hunt never fascinated me.
What I love is... everything around the plot.
I love the characters, I love Hogwarts, I love the houses (well, I love my house - Hufflepuff pride!), I love the humour, I love the magic, I love magical creatures, I love the feeling that anything extraordinary could happen, I love the friendships, the found family moments, the cups of tea, the late-night conversations and the sense of belonging.
If I'm honest, I'd much rather watch everyone sit around the kitchen table at the Burrow drinking tea, chatting and eating Molly Weasley's cooking than spend another chapter hunting Horcruxes.
I don't read fantasy to feel anxious. I read fantasy to dream. To feel comfort. To feel better.
That's probably why some of my favourite films are The NeverEnding Story and Back to the Future. And let's not start on old Brazilian soap operas by Aguinaldo Silva (with a lot of humour and what they used to call "fantastic realism"). I love stories that fill me with wonder, hope and possibility.
And somehow, despite not loving the central plot of Harry Potter, I still adore the Wizarding World (and that's why I like the first Fantastic Beasts film so much). Which, if anything, proves just how special it is.
Because if a series can make someone fall in love with its world, its characters, its humour, its magic and its atmosphere even while not particularly caring about the main storyline and hating the ending...
Then it must have done something right.











