Why I identify as a "nonbinary (trans) man"
To keep the backstory short; I came out at 15 as a trans guy, very quickly had internal confusion over this because it felt.. complicated? I couldn't relate or fit in with cis guy peers OR online trans guy spaces (they were a bit more..toxic? At the time).
And even after I stopped trying to emulate and started accepting that it was okay to be different, that I didn't have to really fit into traditional masculinity to be a man, I still wasn't satisfied.
Cue multiple years of trying on different labels, researching, reading people's experiences. Nada. At 20/21 I had a light bulb moment. I could just be both a man AND nonbinary, instead of trying to just pick one or the other.
But then that begs the question, why? Why do I feel this way? Am I multigender? Fluid? Flux? Agender? Demiboy?...I don't know. And I probably never will be able to articulate in words how my sense of gender feels.
I can tell you that I know with 100% certainty that I'm a guy, even while I was questioning for those years I still started HRT and got my name and gender legally changed. I still went by he/him pronouns. I can tell you that I know I don't need to be masculine, because honestly I'm not really that traditionally masculine. I can tell you vaguely that I have some sense of androgyny or neutrality, but otherwise it just kind of feels like it's there lol.
And I always fear that people hearing my experiences will think they have to identify as nonbinary purely because they don't fit in with most men. Because you can be a binary man without being anything like most men.
But at the same time, I do think it's valid if one identifies as nonbinary partially because of those reasons. Gender is partially reflected by societal and cultural ideas. Not fitting into those ideas and wanting to use a different label for that reason is valid. Your gender is yours to label, and sometimes people choose a label partially because of how much they relate or don't relate to others. Like when someone who's mostly or fully binary feels more comfortable in nonbinary spaces or vice versa...or even the unknown numbers of people who aren't binary that still choose to identify as cis (*cough* my mom *cough*)
So yeah..I guess it's not really an answer. I'm a nonbinary trans guy because I am. I'm a man, in addition to other complicated and vague feelings. And my internal sense of androgyny does play a role. But nonetheless, I am a man.