Native Appropriations Lecture Summary
On Thursday, September 29, 2016, I went to the Briscoe Western Art Museum for a free lecture by Dr. Adrienne Keene, titled as āCultural Appropriation, Stereotypes, & Native Peoples in Popular Culture.ā Dr. Keene introduced herself as a citizen of the Cherokee Nation. She spoke first in Cherokee and then in English. She said more than her name and nation, but I donāt remember with precision what other items were noted. I follow Dr. Keene on Twitter and have cited her in one of my previous blog posts regarding speculation on Reyās attire in Star Wars being inspired by Navajo design.
The lecture started with her telling us the material she was going to cover overall and then showed us the Google search results for if you type in āNative American,ā noting many of the images are historical, some repeats of the same person photographed by Edward Curtis, and often specifically plains Indians. There are over 566 federally recognized tribes, so that is a limited view on the vastness and diversity of Native American tribes. Keene noted that one result matched with Johnny Deppās costume and her amusement that he grabbed one of the first Google search results as well as that the artist for the original image question being something they simply made up on their own. She shared numerous examples further. Itās common to see T-shirts with a skull and war bonnet. In fact, I saw one the day before I went to this lecture while having dinner with my child at Las Palapas. I do not recall if it was this specific stream of discussion or later when discussing stereotyping but one of the series of images shared with us included āTrail of Tearsā fireworks, extremely upsetting, and the logo for the Washington NFL team that Keene refuses to say because it is a racial slur.
Keene explained she was from California and went to Stanford, then later moved east to go to Harvard. There, she would meet people who would tell her to her face their assumptions and stereotypes about Natives, including the belief that they were all dead. During this time, she went to Urban Outfitters and saw an onslaught of appropriation so started her blog discussing the topic. The Navajo Nation is suing UO over six items, and she stated 3 of them went to UOās favor. Itās a highly contested and important case.
Why does appropriation matter? I donāt recall the exact words she used, but she shared a quote by Buffy Saint-Marie that I could not find by Google alone. I think it had something to do with taking cultures and history that arenāt yours. I do remember her discussing one particular side that had two rectangles listing further points, one for economic, the one easier for people to understand in a capitalistic society with intellectual property laws, and the moral/cultural one. Since IP laws protect individuals rather than a collective such as a tribe, appropriation can be difficult to prevent or protect against. It is largely dependent on the issue of power within colonialism.
Keene shared with us some information about a study done by a friend of hers that showed not only do Native kidsā self-esteem drop when seeing images of Native stereotypes like Disneyās representation of Pocahontas and the Cleveland Indians logo of Chief Wahoo, the self-esteem rises for European American children. She summed it up as the āreification of white supremacy.ā
She suggested we be aware of recognizing of Native appropriation and encouraged us to buy Native with an upcoming Yanagauana Indian Arts Market this weekend. She showed a picture of rug that matched with one even within the room hosting the lecture. She told us about a ring she wore that a friend made for her.
In the later part of the lecture, Keene tied the lecture into the current issue of the Dakota Access Pipeline and #NODAPL hashtag. If you arenāt keeping up, I suggest you go and read about it. Itās a pipeline being built to go through North Dakota down to Illinois. It is intended to specifically go through the Standing Rock reservation in North Dakota and presents a significant threat to their water, as well as the water for everyone further downstream of the Missouri river if that pipeline were to ever leak. Keene had photos to share and tell us about her recent trip to North Dakota this past weekend as well as sharing that ranchers surrounding the area genuinely felt fearful of Natives and believing they planned to do things like burn their hay. This type of reaction results from the constant, surrounding stereotypes and appropriation explained earlier in the lecture. Hence, these images are truly harmful and influence non-Natives to perpetuate this harm.
The lecture concluded with Dr. Keene taking and answering some questions. One question was how to help teach second-graders about the issue, and she told us about her mom, a first grade teacher, symbolically throwing Scholasticās Columbus Day guide in the trash every year and taking a video of the action. She told us about resources for Washington state, and I forget the other one. She referred to Debbie Reese (@debreese) and her work in covering childrenās literature (at which I quietly and emphatically nodded). Another question asked about buying pawned items, and she told us she personally would avoid doing so in case items were pawned in desperation rather than with intention to be pawned. Someone asked about the Oneida tribe in Wisconsin and the loss of language. Keene explained to us that by estimations of current blood quantum requirements for enrollment, the tribe will be gone by 2045. The final question was about media representation, and she told us about a channel in Canada that is all about Native people. All of the actors and people represented are all Natives, and we currently donāt have anything like that in the U.S. Someone else commented on a lack of Native people in New York, and Keene corrected that misconception as several Natives were actually relocated there as well as Los Angeles.
Afterward, I took a browse at the items in the room as recommended earlier in the lecture, such as a squash blossom necklace and a rug. I wanted to at least shake Dr. Keeneās hand and introduce myself, and alas, thatās all I really had a chance to do. Her friend came to help her start to leave, and then another person started to talk to her as well. I thanked her on Twitter too. I want to share my whole life story with her, but I feel I shouldnāt take up too much of her time. Iāve mentioned my heritage several times on this blog in trying to understand my race and my continual conclusion to say mixed. Recently, I had a talk with my mom who seemed unsatisfied with that decision. I challenged her to name my race and she called me Caucasoid. I canāt even begin to explain how wrong that is, but to my readers, do not say Caucasoid or Caucasian to mean White and understand that whiteness is largely based on what you are not so if you tell a person of mixed heritage that they are white, you erase the non-white part out of them as if it doesnāt matter. One of the questions, that Iām only remembering as I type this, was about how many Native people there are in the U.S., and Keene answered that itās very complicated. For instance when Latinx people, such as myself, fill out forms, they often donāt consider themselves white so will mark Native American, skewing the numbers. It could be anywhere from 1-4 million (numbers not guaranteed to be verbatim of what she said). I actually mark White because my dad was, and a lot of my family is, and I always feel a twinge of guilt because I feel like Iām erasing my Native heritage out the way I took offense at my mom doing it to me though that was more of me saying I use mixed because I want to recognize both. As you see, a Native person would consider my choosing the Native American response as skewing the numbers, so, Iāll stick with what Iām doing and acknowledge in posts like this one that I understand these things are complicated.
Please bear in mind as you read this piece that I wrote it from memory so order and precise words are not guaranteed as noted in many places. I did not record or take any pictures because it didnāt occur to me that it would be allowed and because my line of thinking was Iād remember it better with setting aside my phone on silent. If I ever go to another lecture such as this one, perhaps I will ask if recording or photos are allowed and consider taking better notes. I wasnāt sure Iād write a summary at all. Anyway, thatās enough about my method of documentation. You can follow Dr. Adrienne Keene on Twitter, @ NativeApprops and read her blog here, Native Appropriations