Something that's always bugged me: in neither the TV series or the movies they make no effort to give Astrid even a temporary love interest. In the TV series Hiccup developed a crush on Heather, yet they seem to be deliberately shying away from giving one to Astrid, at the expense of potential storylines. Even the Eretstrid thing is a matter of fan interpretation than anything else. Why? Why ignore such an obvious source of dramatic tension?
Ohhhhh man. Oh man. I was going to go all in with you on the subject of Astrid getting railroaded for setting her sights on anyone outside of Hiccup (as she was a gift to Hiccup in the first movie and therefore should not stray⦠though the fandom is far, far more guilty of this cowardice, which Iāve ranted about before) but then you said it.
Hiccup developed a crush on Heather
Hiccup did not have a crush on Heather.
Hiccup did not have a crush on Heather.
Hiccup didnāt even need to apologize to Astrid in the aftermathĀ of the Heather Report
Hell, if you want to get historical about it,Ā Hiccup was under obligation to be hospitable.
Heatherās purpose wasnāt even about seducing Hiccup as a distraction to herĀ ādeviousā and pretty altruistic plans.
All theĀ āEwwww, a triangle! Heatherās there to get in between Hiccup and Astrid! Hiccupās thinking with his dick! Astrid baby uwu!ā sorta bullshit all stemmed from a bit of distasteful (if desperate) advertising beforehand. And none of it read in the actual Heather Report episodes. Something that became abundantly clear to me as I had to crawl through them for a scripting project at the time.
Man, sorry, but so much of Heather-hate is literally fostered at the source of that advertising. Theyād rather sell a bad interpretation of aĀ ālove triangleā to get more viewers than let the far superior natural plot speak for itself. They straight up sacrificed their original characterās reputation to garner interest in the episode, which, to me, speaks volumes on how they felt they were doing with the show, and their impression of their audience (not that they were wrong on the audience part, were they? -_-) . You want to talk a matter ofĀ āfan-interpretation?ā. Thatās Heatcup.
And back to my point up above, Astrid has, in fact, been allowed more depth of relationship with others in both the TV show and HTTYD2, than Hiccup has been allowed⦠specifically in the TV show. For that, Hiccupās gained allies and little more. Heās almost the least-touched character of the lot; walled in for fear of messing with a protagonist who really gets to shine in the films alone. Astrid, however, has gone ham with Heather and Eret respectively. Sure, itās notĀ āromanticā, and, thankfully, itās not skewed for, as you put it,Ā ādramatic tensionā. Itās real, and natural--about as natural as things get in the TV show.
And since the TV show is the subject of my mini rant, Iāll say that Heatstrid, on screen, has far more merit in both obvious plot and character interaction, than Heatcup. Astrid gets her extra relationships, at least. And theyāre wholesome.
But I get your initial point, even if one teeny tiny phrase set me off (:D). Somewhere on my blog, or dozens of places in itty bitty fragments, Iāve complained again and again that Astrid, on the whole, by the fans, simply isnāt allowed to have multiple love interests. Thugstrid, Eretstrid, Heatstrid (and not for getting off on āyuriā) Snotstrid, Tuffstird... anything that doesnāt read Hiccstrid is, on the whole, far less acceptable than [insert-name-here]cup. Even most of the yaoi crap would rather vilify or kill off Astrid than have her happy with someone else (or alone!). SO ANNOYING.
Side note: This isnāt dissing the IDEA of Heatcup.Ā Iāve spoken about their potential beforeĀ and there is potential.