Intrigued by the semantic differences between the nouns āprophetā and āoracleā, as I am writing a short story about cats and struggling with my word choice.
Both can mean an individual person gifted with foresight. A person who is an oracle can prophesize and make a prophecy, but is an oracle a prophet? Why or why not?
Conventional definitions are pretty much the same: both are people gifted with foresight and looked to as the mediums through which divinity communicates with humanity. But would you call the Pythia a prophet? Would you call Moses an oracle?
It seems wrong, somehow, and Iām not sure where that bias is coming from. Perhaps itās an association between oracles and polytheism vs prophets and monotheism. I imagine an oracle as someone you could go to to ask when you should plant your crops and a prophet as someone you should ask about the trolley problem.
Maybe an oracle is someone you pay to talk to and a prophet is someone you bribe to shut up.
An oracle is someone you get put on a waitlist to see and a prophet is someone you have to remove from your yard by pushing them into a wheelbarrow and carting them over the property line.Ā
I guess in my head I always figured the difference was that an oracle could do it at will or at least had some control over it and a prophet was beholden to whenever the god(s) chose to speak through them.
Plus the aesthetic difference. An oracle is respected, part of the establishment, has an attending set of priests. A prophet shows up at your coronation looking like a shepherd who spent the last 40 years in a cave to tell you youāre a little bitch.
[opens door to see a haggard-looking wanderer dressed in shabby clothes with the light of divine inspiration burning in their eyes and important words at the tip of their tongue]
[points to sign on door that says āNO PROPHESIZINGā]
[closes door quickly]
Oracles ask and then receive. They may not like the answer, but they usually have to prompt prophecy into occurring.
A PROPHET however? (The) God(s) kiss a brick all real nice, haul back, then YEET that sucker at some poor bastards head. Then we ALL get to live with what happens next.
@englandsgirl18181234 (Responding to tags) (Cause also, hey same!)
Youāre not wrong? Oracles def have some degree of control that prophets do NOT. I think itās a difference in compulsion/duty/domain? Like the difference between a new anchor and a mail carrier. Both bring āthe newsā but one is just commenting on what IS and the other is bring TO YOU what was sent.
A prophet is a messenger. Fate/Judgment is coming. Better watch out! Maybe you can change it, maybe this is only the kindness of letting you get your affairs in order. But they have come to deliver the Prophecy Mail⢠and we all gotta live with that.
ORACLES? Commenting on the weather. Rome will fall. A mountain is gonna explode somewhere. Oh, neat, something called an āairplaneā will someday exsist. We eat our bread, sip our tea, and try not to go insane. They get Spoilers. All the time, ALL THE TIME. But, hey! Some times itās good news!
Stop ASKING them about shit you donāt actually want the answer too.
You keep asking āoh, oracle, how will I die?ā And then getting all suprise pikachu face WHEN THEY TELL YOU! Youāre NOT GONNA BE ABLE TO AVOID THAT! In fact, youāll actively MAKE IT WORSE TRYING! Theyād warn you if this was one of that āhey, maybe bring an umbrellaā moments!
Being an Oracle is sucks. But at least youāre not a prophet!
The REALLY unlucky guys are the ones with just āvisionsā. At least Oracles n Prophets get fuckin CONTEXT. Visions are just-> *violent sensory confetti sand blasting you in the brain* Make SENSE OF THIS, FUCKER!!! *throws more*
Oracles are also practical.
Like yeah, SOME people get the āyour destiny is yo kill your father and marry your motherā but like. Most people arenāt asking about that. The dramatic ones are for stories. Most people are going to be like āmy crops havenāt been doing great for a few years how do I secure a good harvest this year?ā Or āmy son is going to war what can I do to make sure he comes back?ā Or if you got an auger thereās āhow to win this battle?ā
And the Oracle accepts your offerings and asks the question and says āmake an offering for this god in this way.ā (My autocorrect automatically capitalized god and doesnāt that say something.)
Oracles, like I believe many religions, operate on an exchange. You bring them a question and some thing fir the service and you get advice back.
Prophets are here with a message and you WILL hear it whether we like it or not.























