Five Billy Joel Songs So Beatley Youâll Want To Sit On a Cornflake
If youâre a fan of Billy Joelâs music, chances are you also enjoy listening to The Beatles. Joel himself is a big Beatles fan, and that Lennon/McCartney influence is prominent in many of his songs, but stylistically, both artists are very different.
You donât see Billy Joel featured in lists of âartists that sound like The Beatlesâ. But sometimes the influence pokes throughâĻand Iâm here to break it down.
Sometimes that Beatles itch needs scratching, and Billy Joel is the way to go.
If you donât know me already, Iâm Angelina â a multi-instrumentalist, music composer, lover of all things retro, and a thriller author. I write posts like this about retro pop culture, so come along for the journey. If youâre into 70s and 80s music, movies and The BeatlesâĻI think youâve found your new favourite writer.
Todayâs hot topic: Billy Joel!
Iâm still a fairly new fan of Billy Joel. I was one of those people who only knew Piano Man and Uptown Girl, but after listening to The Stranger front to back, I fell in love with the Piano Man himself. And as a long-time Beatles fan, it amazed me to discover some of Billyâs tracks have that Lennon and McCartney sound I love.
So here are five Billy Joel songs so Beatley youâll want to sit on a cornflake.
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
#5 â You Can Make Me Free (1972)
I love Cold Spring Harbour. It is an incredible debut album with some amazing hidden gems that tend to get overlooked. The whole album has a distinct McCartney influence thatâs hard not to hear, not only in the lyrics, but the melodies and how theyâre sung.
You Can Make Me Free stands out for its vocals. Not only does Billy sound like Paul McCartney, but the instrumentation is very Beatles-sounding. When I hear this track, I automatically think of Let It Be. Both songs have a similar piano accompaniment, use an organ and have tone-alike guitar solos. And it makes sense. Joel recorded the tracks from Cold Spring Harbour just one year after Let It Be was released.
The melody itself is very McCartney-esque. It reminds me a lot of We Can Work It Out and Pipes Of Peace. And those raspy vocals at the end of the final chorus pay tribute to Oh! Darling and Iâve Got A Feeling. For another example of McCartneyâs raspy vocals, check out Monkberry Moon Delight.
I also hear a Lennon influence, especially with that light rasp; it reminds me of Twist and Shout and You Canât Do That.
The lyrics are optimistic and whimsical, like McCartneyâs ballads, his âgranny musicâ, such as When Iâm Sixty Four and Martha My Dear.
âI can take to the skies, I can soar like a bird,â also rings bells for me. The mention of birds is not exclusive to The Beatles, but it reminds me of Blackbird and Bluebird.
So if youâre looking for a piano-driven, mellow vocal, optimistic track that sounds like Paul McCartney abandoned his bass for the piano, You Can Make Me Free is the way to go!
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
#4 â Scandinavian Skies (1982)
Ah, The Nylon CurtainâĻwhere to start? I love this album, but it doesnât get the love it deserves. Scandinavian Skies is so Beatles-sounding it could pass on The White Album or Magical Mystery Tour.
This is a fairly popular observation, especially when you consider the context. Joel recorded this album between 1981 and 1982, and Lennon was assassinated in late 1980. While working on The Nylon Curtain, Joel was in the Beatles zone:
âI was thinking about the great Beatles albums, especially Sgt. Pepperâs. I had those kinds of aspirations for this.â
And he drew inspiration from their unique recording techniques.
âI want to make a good headphones album and use exotic instrumentation and layering the way The Beatles did.â
So itâs no surprise that Scandinavian Skies sounds like that.
The track begins with a mellow, experimental soundscape and voiceover. It is familiar to any Beatles fan, featured in tracks like You Never Give Me Your Money and Rain. As well as those consistent quarter-note piano chords familiar to Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields Forever.
Scandinavian Skies is melancholic, like many tracks from The White Album tracks such as Dear Prudence, Happiness is a Warm Gun and Iâm So Tired. As for the orchestral instrumentation, this track resonates with The Long and Winding Road and A Day In The Life.
Instead of sounding like McCartney, Joel sounds like Lennon, especially the part: âI could play the blues all nightâĻâ where the ahhs are a signature of many Beatles tracks. And the solid beat in the chorus sounds like Iâm So Tired: âYouâd say Iâm putting you onâĻâ
The lyrics have political undertones. The Nylon Curtain leans into state-of-the-nation themes, especially tracks like Allentown and Goodnight Saigon. And any Beatles fan is familiar with political music, for example, Give Peace A Chance and Revolution.
Many believe Billy Joel is a pop artist who makes easily-digestible songs for the mainstream audience, but Scandinavian Skies shows that he can make complex, experimental music too. These songs tend to be appreciated more by musicians, so for my fellow musicians, this song features around twenty-two chords. Most songs feature four.
Above all, this track sounds like I Am The Walrus. When the staccato strings come in, when the drums accent them, when the song picks up, the resemblance is uncanny. It mirrors the part: âSitting in an English gardenâĻâ Especially how it descends, like in Blue Jay Way.
I can also hear Lennonâs solo music, specifically from Double Fantasy, like Iâm Losing You.
The setting itself is no stranger to The Beatles. Think about songs like Back in the USSR and Norwegian Wood. Even the way this song is written. It sounds like Lennon lyrics: âWho could say what was left and where was right?â
Can you tell who Billy Joelâs favourite Beatle is?
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
#3 â Sheâs Always a Woman (1977)
I love this song. I have a feeling I may start every section like this, but I really do. Sheâs Always A Woman is the perfect combination of Beatles â the lyrics are very Lennon and the instrumentation is very McCartney.
The style of piano playing is very resonant of Paulâs music, such as Let It Be and The Long And Winding Road. The fingerstyle acoustic guitar reminds me of Sheâs Leaving Home and Iâve Just Seen a Face, as well as the acoustic version of While My Guitar Gently Weeps, for some Harrison influence.
Letâs take a look at the plethora of chords and how often they change. Sheâs Always A Woman features around twenty chords. That is very Lennon. Think of songs like It Wonât Be Long and I Want You (Sheâs So Heavy). The frequent use of diminished and seventh chords seals the deal. Even that D Major to D Major 7th right before the chorus matches the pre-chorus in This Boy. These chord variations appear everywhere in Sheâs Always a Woman. Thatâs what makes it so Beatles-sounding.
The flute in the chorus reminds me of Fool On The Hill and the way Joelâs voice sounds, smooth and bright like McCartneyâs, makes the resemblance uncanny.
And how about those non-lyric vocals? Specifically the âmmmsâ during the chorus, which sound like Iâve Just Seen a Face and Words of Love. I know this is a common adlib not only used by The Beatles, but it sure does sound familiar.
The lyrics are almost identical to Girl. The only difference is Sheâs Always a Woman is more in denial, disregarding all the wrong his woman does because sheâs only a woman, which makes her perfect. It delivers a powerful message about rose coloured lenses and how personal affiliations can water down facts. Whereas Girl tells a story about being trapped in a relationship but enjoying it too much to leave, so the protagonist is left with conflicting feelings. With both songs aligned like this, the inspiration is clear.
Listening to Sheâs Always A Woman feels like a mellow diss track. And us Beatles fans are familiar with this. Itâs a bit of a stretch, but you could say it resonates with How Do You Sleep? and Too Many People.
And now, another song about relationship struggles. That alone is very Beatles.
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
#2 â Through The Long Night (1980)
If you think Through The Long Night doesnât sound like early-Beatles, youâre simply wrong. Billy Joel heard Yes It Is and wrote this song inspired by it. Once you hear it, you canât unhear it, especially with those multi-layered harmonies, the lyrics about past heartbreak, and the synth.
Many of Joelâs Beatles-sounding songs pay tribute to mid-to-late Beatles, but rarely early Beatles, which is interesting. After all, it was early-Beatles performing on the Ed Sullivan Show in 1964 that first inspired Billy Joel:
âThat one performance changed my life. Up to that moment, Iâd never considered playing rock as a careerâĻThis is what Iâm going to do â play in a rock band.â
Listen to the melody in the verse. It is deliciously simple, like many of McCartneyâs hits, and he even sounds like him, especially in the chorus, âLong, long time ago,â where Joel climbs up the scale. Thatâs where Paulâs vocals sit most comfortable. You could even say the vocal harmonies sound like Girl.
The short lyrical phrases are similar to early-Beatles tracks, which were often written around the title phrase, for example, A Hard Dayâs Night and Canât Buy Me Love.
The themes of sleeping remind me of the niche lullaby-sounding Beatles tracks like Iâm Only Sleeping and Golden Slumbers. Whether or not this is intentional, the influence is clear.
The brass instruments make the song sound like Penny Lane and any track from Sgt. Pepperâs Lonely Hearts Club Band. Or rather, any one of McCartneyâs âgrannyâ songs. Iâm sensing a pattern hereâĻ
And now, the most Lennon-sounding song Iâve ever heard.
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
#1 â Laura (1982)
ManâĻthis sounds so damn Lennon. If you canât hear it, you donât know The Beatles. Laura is conversational, bitter and yearnful. That alone is very Lennon. Think of songs like How Do You Sleep? and Gimme Some Truth. Additionally, the storytelling style reminds me a lot of Being For The Benefit of Mr Kite! and Girl.
Those experimental sounds are incredible, especially the effect-heavy guitar parts, which remind me of Iâm Only Sleeping and Rain. It easily passes as a track off The White Album, along with Scandinavian Skies. Itâs a track that comes from a deep emotional place of frustration, and I love it.
Listen to the part: âLaura loves me even if I donât care (ahh)â and tell me itâs not four Beatles in a trench coat. The backing vocals are very early-Beatles, for example, Twist and Shout, and even late-Beatles, like Because. And the I Am The Walrus influence is obvious here, like in Scandinavian Skies.
Something else Iâd like to point out: John Lennon and Paul McCartney both had trauma related to their mothers, and Laura is about the straining relationship between a mother and son, how someone close to you knows how to push your buttons. The best lyrical examples: âHow can she hold the umbilical cord for so long?â and âSometimes I feel like this Godfather deal is all wrong.â The themes of familial control and longing to get through to somebody are also found in Julia and Dear Prudence.
Even the title has similarities with Beatles tracks. A womanâs name. Other examples to feature a womanâs name: Lovely Rita, Michelle, Sexy Sadie and Mrs. Vandebilt.
Letâs not forget about the chords. The Beatles were known for experimenting heavily with song structure and instrumental composition. So does Laura, which features around twenty chords, and almost none of them are vanilla chords. Thatâs very interesting for any music enthusiast.
âšâËâ§ī¸ĩâŋââąÂˇâļ¡â°ââŋī¸ĩâ§Ëââš
The best thing about music: it is subjective. Thereâs something out there for everybody. Billy Joel is a fan of The Beatles, and so are you, I assume, if youâre reading this. Itâs always a treasure to discover a new favourite song, so I hope I have given you some great new recommendations, or Iâve convinced you to re-listen to these awesome tracks.
If you enjoyed reading this post, please consider leaving a comment or liking it. As always, happy listening and Iâll see you in the next post!













