tin man is super interesting to me from a game design perspective because like... yeah his story arc is super interesting but... the actual realtionship between him as a GAMEPIECE and him as a CHARACTER shifted so dramatically in unrealized realities
because the thing about arknights is that there isn't a HARD RULE about who can become an operator. there is necessarily a constant economic and social push and pull between the company and the players. "alter" in arknights didn't really have a predetermined definition even with assumptions from other gacha games. lava showed her after character development in a flashforward and was well recieved, ch'en was shown in a new outfit with a new weapon without development and was lambasted, skadi was depicted in an alternate timeline to mixed responses. looking back on it from the y7 perspective, it SEEMS like the consensus became that alternate timelines and swimsuits alike would be relegated to skins, while alters would be purely for showing a character either after a timeskip or representing a new role they were taking on. whatever. weird tangent. regardless, the point was that CANONICITY and STORY RELEVANCE were established as necessities for an alter to be released.
but that's just for people who were already established as operators. what does it MEAN to be a rhodes island operator? it's never been about being a direct employee OF rhodes island; only the operators with the actual faction of Rhodes Island seem to be employees rather than contractors. it's not about just working WITH rhodes island either; we don't have a playable Wei Yenwu or Clovisia. so like to some degree it's pretty arbitrary.
eblana being announced as an operator came as a shock to a lot of people i knew, because... well, to put it bluntly, she is a literal monster (dragon). she's an abuser, a necromancer, and utterly unconcerned with civilian casualties. she wasn't necessarily UNIQUELY evil, but her relationship with Reed ended up being fairly distinct given the amount of focus it got. and the thing is, people had been complaining about how Virtuosa had gotten toned down from her appearances as an NPC to become more palatable. so there was kind of this question - are we getting the woobified Eblana? are her crimes going to be brushed off so she can become another playable unit? even after recruiting her, seeing a version of her that has fixated on the Doctor... she joins Platinum, Passenger, Ho'olheyak, and Virtuosa in a nebulous middle ground of characters who seem to have run out of STEAM for those actions that defined them as NPCs and/or antagonists. saluzzo pulls her Joker bullshit in Portatori but ultimately concedes rather than pushing it, Virtuosa breaks out of jail in MT but is nonetheless constantly working as an ally for the heroes. Eblana's future remains uncertain through this. there is a lingering undercurrent of tension as we wait to see who the banner unit for the upcoming ursus event on CN is; a sigh of relief is breathed when it's Zima and we don't have to worry about Koshelna flopping over the Doctor's desk with come hither eyes.
and then Tin Man does 9/11.
suddenly, being an operator doesn't mean you stay allied with Rhodes Island, doesn't mean your antagonism is limited to playful banter and empty threats. despite the brief tension at the end of lone trail over what to do with Friston's core, tin man never became a full antagonist; he was an ally through Lone Trail and portrayed as an outright vigilante HERO in Records of Originium: Rhine Lab. and yet, here he is having performed a false flag attack to reignite american militarism, directly in opposition to the desires of Babel and Rhodes Island.
a playable unit in arknights can now become a full-blown antagonist. not only is being playable no longer a guarantee of moral conduct, it no longer even guarantees ALLEGIANCE. it opens up huge possibilities; Arturia's playable status no longer guarantees that she'll return to RI, that she's been convinced of the error of her ways. Puzzle's employment by Caster is now considerably more threatening, knowing he COULD launch a black-ops mission to assassinate Reed in the night. Ulpianus could once again stand against the Abyssal Hunters, siding with Horatia in her desire for Aegirian domination. Skybox could commit some more police brutality.
so what is a rhodes island operator?