Small Study on the Elven Language
For the past few days i have developed a small hyperfixation and I would like to share its results with the world. i have also posed it on ao3 if you'd like to read it there.
This study is trying to approach elven as simultaneously dead and living language that has been used continuously throughout thousands of years. Specifically, in such a way in which a real-life scholar would try to understand and make sense of a real-life dead ancient language. What I would like to stress, however, is that I am no linguist, just a person who is learning ancient languages at his university, and also at times I can and will make up stuff as the language is fictional and wasnât created as a true language (but a cipher).Â
(also I am not a native english speaker, do whatever you want with this information.)
For when the word and/or the sentence seem not to work within the grammatical rules that are set further below, we ought to assume that:
The speaker could be making a mistake because speech often is imperfect and/or it was written down by someone who doesnât have a grasp on elven language.
The phrase is idiomatic and/or an exception to the rules.
There are differences between the ancient elven spoken by the ancient elf characters and the modern elven spoken by the dalish or the city elves, and they stem from the fact that the language evolved and changed over time; modern elven might have a lot of borrowings from the languages spoken in the regions where the modern elves live â modern elven spoken in Antiva will be different than the modern elven spoken in the Denerim alienage.
The language seems to share certain traits with analytical and agglutinative languages; the order in which the words are used suggests the meaning, whoâs the subject and whoâs the object, and words add up together to create more complex meaning.
There seem to exist determinatives, mostly existing as suffixes, that support word formation. However, I would argue that in many cases it is the other way around; the last part of the word is the âcoreâ while the words that come before it exist as modificators â in âbana(l)âvallaslinâ it is the word âbanalâ that is kind of the grammatical agent, the one changing the grammatical patient âvallaslinâ.Â
There is usually no distinction between nouns and verbs; they can be used interchangeably. The grammatically correct sign that the word is used as a verb is the usage of the active pronoun. However, some words have a strong association with action that the passive pronoun is used for.Â
The context of the language is that it was first developed by people who existed as spirits and probably had a very loose concept of time and space; if Love is a person, then loving as an action is acting like Love, the verb to love could originate more as to be as love. Furthermore, one could question how developed was the concept of physicality at the beginning in the language, what does âcloseâ and âfarâ mean to a spirit?
It would make sense for the language to be heavily interpretative and contextual, more idea and concept based than precise and exact â a sentence can be interpreted multiple ways depending on the context within which it is spoken.
I would assume that during The Dales Period and effort would have been made to write down the language itself and its grammatical rules; most of these writing, however, would have been lost to the modern elves, as the flowy shape of the elven alphabet suggest that it was written on organic material like scrolls, leaves or parchment. It would not be far off to assume that the alphabet itself could develop as a magical one, as in possibly written in air, painted on, not carved into anything.
ir â singular first person active; the subject of the verb; âI amâ:Â
ar â singular first person passive; âIâ ĂĄr â possessivus; it would seem to have later changed into mir perhaps as a mix between ir and mar.
ma â singular second person active; the subject of the verb; âYou areâ, you are [x] â âmĂĄ vhenanâ=âyou are (my) heartâ; mĂĄ â possessivus; mĂĄâla â âyou haveâ
mar â singular first second passive; âyouâ. mĂĄr â possessivus; âyourâ
vir â plural first person active; the subject of the verb; we are;Â
var â plural first person passive. vĂĄr â possessivus
na â both plural and singular third person active; is
-an â suffix indicating a place
-ris â suffix indicating a group, all of it ?Â
-al â gathering; a lot of something but not necessarily all?
-ra â suffix indicating person, or used to specify that it is a noun ?
-in â suffix indicating grammatical case locativus, âinâ
-lan / lin / len â indicating kin, a child
(l)a- â prefix indicating grammatical case comitativus, âwithâ
are expressed by tones. (accents on the last syllabe)Â
Absolutus â Ä (flat) â basis
Genetivus â ĂĄ â denotes the âownerâ, a placeÂ
Accusativus â Ă â often denotes the object of the verb, often can be also used instead of preposition âtoâ/âtowardsâ, to recognize the recipient etc.
Dativus â â â denotes the recipient and/or the purpose of the action.Â
The subject of the sentence usually goes first and is followed by the verb; however, it can be skipped, and the first word can be a verb. Inversion happens, however.
There is nothing that indicates the existence of grammatical tenses â it would seem that one must glean them from the context of the sentence. Perhaps it stems from the communal nature of the Dalish society. Or, perhaps, this development dates back to the times of the elven empire when knowledge was freely shared and everyone would have known whether something had already happened or was happening.Â
I spent some time trying to do some guessing and analysing on some of the words known and unknown; some of them were useful for the purpose of translations below, some were kept because I had more extensive reflections.
where â iras; wherever â irassal
sa â full; to fill? join? one more? add?
lasa â give; lasĂĄ â give/given to me/us; lasĂ â give/given to you/them
dinâan â place of death ?Â
malasa â together, linked, bounded, ma.lasa=you are giving yourself to me.Â
heem â a longer "him", not to alter but to shape from scratch, make
malas â ma.las; you grant (yourself)? to find something
sulevin â purpose/need ?Â
san â (guessing) inability; lack of abilityÂ
atishâan â if âanâ denotes a place, literally or metaphorically, then what does âatishâ mean? if living by the âVir Atishâanâ is to avoid fighting, to heal, could âatishâ mean something like restfulness and repose? could âatishâ be a verb that translates to something like âbringing peaceâ or âto calm/tranquiliseâ? which would make peace mean âa tranquilised placeâ or as an action âto tranquilise the placeâ?
atishâall â if âAtish'all Vir Abelasanâ is translated by Solas as "Enter the path of the Well of Sorrowsâ it could be a phrase that does not hold the meaning of necessarily entering a path, but rather preparing oneself for the Well of Sorrows; obviously, it can be idiomatic, but if âalâ could denote âa lot/a gathering of somethingâ and âatishâ would be the grammatical agent, then âatishâallâ could MAYBE mean something along the lines of spreading tranquility, like, ârest, soldierâ.
emmÄ â within, inside; emmĂĄ â from within; emmĂ â into, literally âto insideâÂ
halam â sacrificing/losing but in a neutral/positive way? so halamshir would mean progress (with sacrifice to achieve?); halamshiral would then mean âthe sacrifice of journeyâ?
Below are translations I have done for the purpose of figuring out the language and how it could work within the rules I have set. Some of the phrases have been translated by the games, some donât have official translations.Â
Emmasalin var suledin evanura = emmĂĄâsalin vĂĄr suledin evanura = from within comes our endurance, leader
Mas enasalin lasa revĂ s evanura = shall* victory give you freedom, leaderÂ
*i have no fucking clue what âmasâ means and itâs my guess. Mas could alas be as well reconstructed as ma â âyou be victorious and given freedom, leaderâ â or perhaps mas(al) so a plural second person pronoun akin to âyallâ or âyousâ, perhaps a borrowing from the common tongue.
emma salin â âI want you within meâ=âCome to inside (me)â â emmĂ âsalin
emmasalin â emmĂĄâsalin â from inside/within (it) comes
Masal din'an â youACTIVEÂ all death â every of you (will) die
Sylaise enaste var aravel. Lama, ara las mir lath. Bellanaris. = Sylaise enaste vĂĄr aravèl. L(a)âa.ma, arâ(r)a las(Ă ) mir lĂ th. Bellanaris. = Sylaise blesses our aravel. And (when) with you, I* (shall) give to you my love. All eternity.
*with ra being used after the pronoun ar the whole phrase could mean something along the lines of âmy whole beingâ or âThe whole of meâ.
TelVERBÂ banalOBJECTÂ ar a.ma. Vir shiral malasa, bellanaris. = Wonât be terrible (as itâs) me with you. We will journey together, all eternity.Â
Ar lasa mala revas = ArSUBJECTÂ lasĂ VERBÂ mĂĄâla revĂ sOBJECTÂ = I grant (it so) that you have freedom.
Var lath vir suledin! = VĂĄr lath virVERB MODIFIERâsuledinVERB! = our love will* persist!
*vir, as will be also mentioned later, can mean both âweâ and âthe wayâ (as in, the custom, the tradition); here, it perhaps functions as an expression of certainty in the future â just as we, as the people, are continuous and persisting, so will be our love.
Mala shivanas ar athim = MĂĄâla shivanasSUBJECTÂ Ă rOBJECTÂ athimVERBÂ = That you have such dedication to duty* humiliates me.
*If we assume that MĂĄâla means âyou haveâ and shivanas mean âdedication to dutyâ, the phrase seems to mean having dedication to duty by the person addressed (Davrin). Because it stands at the beginning of the sentence it is the subject and what is stressed by the speaker.Â
Dirth ma, harel.lan. Ma banalâenasalin. MĂĄr solas ena mĂĄr dĂŹn = You are speaking*, kindred of lies, (but) you win/achieve nothing, your pride forms your end.
*Although the subject should be at the beginning of the sentence, positioning the verb ahead of the active pronoun can be emphasizing the continuous action of telling and speaking.Â
OG world of thedas text
Telâenara bellana banaâvhenadahl,
Sethenâa ir sanâshiral, mala telâhalani
Ir saâvir teâsuledin var banaâvallaslin,
Voraânadas san banalâhim emma abel revas.
OG world of thedas poetic inaccurate translation
We/it lost eternity or the ruined tree of the People
Time wonât help when the land of dreams is no longer our journey
We try to lead despite the eventual failing of our markings.
To the inevitable and troubling freedom we are committed.
my analysis
TelNEG.ena.ra bellanĂĄGENÂ bana(l)âvhenadĂĄhlGEN
Sethen(er)ĂĄ(n) ir sanâshiral, m(e)la(na) telNEGâhalani
Ir sa(n)âvir te(l)NEGâsuledin vĂĄr bana(l)âvallaslin,
Voraânadas san banalOBJECTâhimVERBÂ emma abel(Ă s) revĂĄsGEN
my translation
No form of eternity*, nothing of the tree of the people.
Land of waking dreams (that) I cannot journey, time will not help,
I canât persist**, our nothing of markings will not endure,Â
the ceaseless*** inevitability cannot make nothing of the sorrow within that comes from freedomÂ
*ena.ra could mean a person, then telâenara could mean no one, which in turn also could translate into âno one of eternityâ=âno one is eternalâ/âno one belongs to eternityâ
**vir â can mean âweâ or âthe wayâ as in the custom, the tradition, so unless itâs idiomatic, it could mean something like âcannot be the way we areâ?Â
***vora â (i am guessing) continous, ceaseless, eager, something energetic etc. so the voraâshivan (âhumming birdâ) can mean along the lines of eagerly, energetic, dutiful, committed etc
To conclude, I want to stress that there could be mistakes or things you donât agree with. It is possible this study could have been more polished. But I want to also stress the fact that this is something done for my own enjoyment, and I unfortunately do not plan to commit to studying and creating elven language full time. I will probably revisit this study and perhaps work more on my own interpretation of the elven language but it is one of many projects I have on my desk and I am just a single person. For everyone who read all of this, thank you for your time, and I hope you enjoyed my personal venture of curiosity.Â