Thieves Guild Returns spoilers
Spoilers for Quen's personal quest at the end of the story, specifically.
Okay, so. Saroldo. I'm not sure that's a direction I would have gone honestly, and I really didn't like it at first because her story in Thieves Guild was built around his being very dead and her coming to terms with it. I'm still not sure how I feel about him being secretly alive the whole time because it really makes everything that happens in Quen's TG quest chain so much worse. She was left to fend for herself, Lady Sulima was under so much scrutiny from the Iron Wheel that it drained her fortune which drove her to try and steal Quen's inheritance, and all the while he was off doing who knows what, convincing himself that staying away was the correct choice. If he'd just been dead, then there's nothing he could do about those things, but he wasn't. He saved his own skin and left the women who loved him to fend for themselves, one in a city now infested with hostile agents that know she's connected to him, and the other in a land where family is everything, and if you have no family, you're nothing. You can't tell me that the Iron Wheel would have pursued him to Summerset. They were searching Abah's Landing to secure the stolen dowry, why not run back to Summerset and get Quen? Why leave her to his debts and the Iron Wheel?
Honestly it was such an easy choice for me (and Maggie) to tell Quen to tell him to fuck off. Everything Quen went through and he chooses to step back in and save the day once she's built a life for herself and got a good thing going, which is only being spoiled because of him? There were so many other times he could have come back into her life and it's so fucking dodgy that he only does it once the Thieves Guild is not only recovered and stable, but thriving and branching out across Tamriel.
I didn't have loads of thoughts about Saroldo before because his entire narrative purpose was to be a dead parent in the coming of age narrative, but now he's a deadbeat parent instead and... I dunno, I appreciate that the narrative acknowledges that he was a bad parent and that he left Quen to fend for herself and that he fully believes he was correct to do so, it just feels weird to bring him back when he was so firmly dead. He fell from a roof and broke his neck - there's only one person who's supposed to return from lethal falls and that's me! That's my thing Saroldo, back off!
Anyway. Saroldo. What a fucking loser. Tamriel's Worst Dad contender right there.
(And yes I did the same thing with Gerard, I know, but that's different! He got necromanced by the Worm Cult, he didn't magically come back ten years after breaking his neck!)















