Personal revenge vs community justice is the usual tension in revenge stories where a single character chooses to enact revenge for themselves or the people they love and in the process hurt innocent bystanders but that does not work for "sole survivor" or "genocide survivor" stories. There is no such thing as "eye for an eye" revenge, no proportional punitive justice, when it was a wrong done to a community.
The reason why Sasuke's revenge is so justified is that killing one man to avenge an ethnic cleansing is not proportional in the least. There is no getting your enemies to suffer like the Uchiha have suffered. Revenge in this context is a consolation and a bad one at that, but it's all he has. Sasuke has no community to fall back on anymore, no community to hurt in his pursuit of revenge and that tension is lost. Furthermore Sasuke goes out of his way to spare collateral damage, consistently refuses to kill and spares his friend even though killing him promised him the power to kill itachi. There is no collateral damage to Sasuke's revenge, no destroyed community, and that undermines the central tension of morally grey revenge arcs.
The only collateral damage to Sasuke is himself, how he destroys his life in pursuing revenge, but even that is flimsy. His life has already been destroyed by the genocide because, again, this isn't a personal hurt but a whole lifestyle, culture, and people who were eradicated. He's already had his world blown up before so it's not like he's making an uninformed decision. Sasuke chooses to go to Orochimaru because the hurt is really, truly, incomparable to the wrong done to him. Again, a lack of proportionality. Avenging a genocide trumps personal hurt.
Then we get to the "destroy konoha" bit after the reveal that his people's demise was not the work of one man but the actions of military leaders motivated by the bigoted opinions of the even wider community that actively isolated the Uchiha before they were murdered. Now I'm not such a loser to have a bad faith idea of Sasuke thinking "destroy konoha" meant personally targeting konoha babies considering all his actions, but it means killing the individuals responsible as well as the state, the system that did this. It's revenge, sure, but it is also now very much a pursuit of a higher justice and, yes, restorative community justice. He is working to materially improve the condition of the world by, yes, killing a bunch of people who absolutely deserved it. It is revenge and justice rolled into one. He gets to have his cake and eat it too.
There is only ONE moment in the whole of the series where Sasuke ever lets his hatred get the better of him, and again it is the only action he ever truly apologizes for. It's when he stabs karin to get to danzo, hating that man so much and needing to undermine his belief that Sasuke wouldn't do anything to avenge his people. Every other moment his hatred is normal, I'd even go as far to say good.
His revenge quest is good if tragic because it's a poor consolation next to the justice he will never get, and his subsequent revenge against konoha lies within justice, works in tandem with it, and is good.
andulkaphoto
gracieabrams
yousharknotpass
origamiaround
ellievsbear
vaporwave
snowghoul
turnnoffyourmind
romaincrisis
