having been derailed by life and all of it's whims, i am relaunching the pasta revolution resolution! you'll be happy to know that altho i've failed you all by not posting pasta since... january???... i have actually kept up with a roughly one (1) pasta shape per week eating habit! so i have a backlog of scoring and notes to post. speaking of scoring...
with the help of my many Pasta EAs (Eating Assistants), i have overhauled the scoring rules, and because of the new Bonus Points opportunities, pasta shapes have ALL YEAR to rack up points, so we might have some late-breaking upsets.
Scoring Rules
First Take Points (0-5): How well did the pasta shape perform in whatever dish I used it in first? Hopefully I'm smart enough to choose a dish that complements the shape, but I have a feeling some of these shapes have some surprises in store.
Remix Bonus Points (no limit! available all year!): These are discretionary points that can be awarded if I like a pasta shape enough to put it in a different dish. This category also accepts "ghost points", because my EAs have already suggested amazing dishes that I really love in theory but in reality might never get around to making.
Amusement Points (0-5): How much fun is the pasta shape? Is the name fun to say? Is it cute? Does it resemble an animal or a replacement k'nex piece? Would it be fun at a party?
Annoyance Deductions (0-5): Does it stick to itself - or the spoon - or the pot - unnecessarily? Does it shatter into pieces that skitter under my oven where they will fossilize because nobody ever cleans under the oven? Does it require more than one utensil to ferry it to my mouth? Does it stick out of the pot because why would I have a pot that is the diameter of spaghetti?
Alternative Uses: Crowd sourced!! It's not just what I can dream up, it's about what YOU can imagine!!! My EAs have already proven to be wonderfully wild dreamers of pasta shape dreams, so I can't wait to see what's to come. There's no official scoring for this category; it will be used as a tie-break if needed.
New shapes will be posted with their temporary scores, but as noted, I (you, we!) have ALL YEAR to uncover the TRUE POTENTIAL of each pasta shape. May the best bizzarely shaped dried extrusion of dough win!
shoutout to my stellar EAs: @sideguitars @cinnis @waytooinvested-main @makicarn
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
fyi the point of fucking up your data patterns isnt to avoid suspicion. itâs to make EVERYONE suspicious. same logic as the bloc, pals. protect your comrades, be suspicious. ESPECIALLY if you arenât doing anything likely to get you arrested.
the state is less omniscient and significantly more incompetent than youâd think. overextend their resources at every possible opportunity. make them cry wolf repeatedly. run their data analysis agents fucking ragged. and strike. attack.
YES
iâm a postgrad statistics researcher and i can tell you that the state honestly has NO IDEA what to do with the data it collects, it has an obsession with big data but itâs almost impossible to work with in practice. the traditional statistical approaches that are used canât be scaled up, the adapted approaches are substantially weakened, and the machine learning approaches have the same problems and often tell them nothing. data scientists are only just coming around to these issues too, most still just push on with it anyway - incompetence is the word.
above all this though, like you say, the biggest issue for the state is at the point of data collection. they will NEVER get anything useful if theyâre collecting shitty messy data. they will eventually figure out that the real solution is working how to collect accurate and meaningful data, we should make it as difficult as possible for them to do that
Ad Nauseum is an adblocker that stores the ads it blocks and continuously generates fake clicks, fucking with analytics and costing the ad companies money
TrackMeNot automatically does randomly generated searches on a variety of search engines to obscure your real searches and fuck with analytics, and you can set it up to work with anything that has a search bar (including facebook, twitter, amazon, youtube, etc)
WhatCampaign replaces analytics parameters in links with the string âFuckOffâ. I thought there was a similar extension that used random strings, but I canât seem to find it
Privacy Possum is a fork of Privacy Badger with a focus on costing tracking companies as much money as possible, and idk if my limited tech knowledge is enough to understand what it does but the description does say it falsifies some data so thatâs good enough for me
All it means when people say âyouâre speaking from a place of privilegeâ is that youâre likely to underestimate how bad the problem is by default because you are never personally exposed to that problem. Itâs not a moral judgement of how difficult your life is.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
The closest experience I've ever had to discovering "the vitamin" was buying a 100% wool outfit and wearing it in the winter.
Not only was I not freezing anymore, I was not sweating and overheating either. The horrible sensory nightmare of winter clothes disappeared.
In particular, I bought a pair of wool pants. They were a thrifted pair of fancy dress pants like you would wear at an important office job, and they were easily the most comfortable pair of winter-appropriate pants i'd ever worn. I wore them Every Single Day.
From that point on I realized a lot of my clothes were making me feel bad, and the common thread was polyester. Especially polyester blends.
It's a trap because the polyester clothes are the ones that always feel sooooo silky soft when they are in the store, whereas cotton, linen and wool can feel comparatively rough and scratchy. But when actually wearing them for hours throughout the day, it's the natural fibers that feel more comfortable.
Maybe the secret to sensory comfort is not about the presence of softness, but the absence of overloading sensations. Or maybe the sensory stress and agony is not triggered by texture of the fabric, but by how it breathes and regulates temperature.
Then there's the problem of clothing life span: polyester blends, no matter how soft they seem at first, become rough and scratchy and covered in hard, itchy pills after wearing them 10 or 20 times, whether or not they have been tumble-dried or even washed at all. (I tested it!) Linen and cotton become softer and more comfy the more you wear them, polyester but ESPECIALLY polyester blends become a constant stressor. Polyester blend t-shirts I used to love for their softness now feel bristly and irritating.
So now I'm trying to change my wardrobe to as many natural fibers as possible, and the more natural fiber clothes i have the more I realize that the plastic fibers stress me out. It's so easy to overheat or freeze in them and they're always degrading and becoming less comfortable and it sucks.
So this was mentioned in the notes (and I mentioned it there, too), but I know that sometimes those just don't get read. So here I will mention other natural fabrics.
Alpaca- my all time favorite. It is both warmer and lighter than wool, and if you have allergic reactions to wool, as I do, this is a great substitute. Alpaca socks are so great.
Cotton- the common fabric. Good for shirts, underthings, socks, pants, you name it. Good at wicking moisture and letting skin breathe, but can also be woven into warmer items such as sweaters. Good all around fabric. Can be strong and used for heavy duty clothing as well as delicate clothes.
Linen- the original warm weather fabric. The more it is washed, the softer it gets. Fabulous in the heat. Use it for bed sheets in the summer and you will never be hot in bed again. It can be used to make shirts, pants, shorts, and underthings.
Silk- great for warm and cool weather. Cool in the heat, warm in the cold, and beautiful no matter what. Can be made as a washable fabric, but usually hand wash or dry clean. Will wear like iron. If you treat it right, you can have silk for 20 years or more. Gloves, socks, underthings, shirts, pants, dresses, jackets, you name it.
Hemp- less well known but a great fabric. Resists mold like you would not believe! Used to make sails for sailing ships, as well as ropes during the age of sail. It was stronger than cotton when wet and would last longer due to the no molding thing. Less water intensive to grow than cotton, with many of the same properties of both linen and cotton. Can be used to make bed sheets, bath towels, shirts, underthings, pants, socks, pretty much anything.
Cashmere- Super luxurious! It is the shed hair of the Cashmere and pashmina goats. Usually made into sweaters, scarves, hats, gloves , and shawls. Super warm and soft. Hand wash or dry clean.
Angora- Also super luxurious. The shed fur of the angora rabbit. Can be used to make sweaters, hats, gloves, shawls, socks, and shawls. Warm, soft, and fluffy.
Mohair- The fur/hair from angora or mohair goats. Used to make sweaters, socks, gloves, hats, scarves, and shawls. Soft and warm.
There are also natural blends. These include (but are not limited to, and are not a complete list): cotton/wool, cotton/linen, cotton/silk, linen/silk, wool/silk, alpaca/wool, cashmere/wool, mohair/wool, etc.
Other natural fibers can include camel, yak, and other animal hair that is shed or clipped and then spun into yarn. Some are more available in certain areas of the world than others. I did not include bamboo due to the massive amount of chemical processing that it takes to extract the fibers. I also did not include lotus silk, byssus silk (sea silk), or any other experimental animal silk (such as the golden orb weaver spider silk) that has been made/created.
Natural fibers cost more to harvest, process, spin, and weave. They can be more difficult to color evenly, because like any natural material they have flaws and variations. This makes them more expensive to work with, which makes the clothing more expensive to produce and sell. But the items produced will last longer (theoretically), will feel better against the skin, and will be better for you in the long run for both you and the planet than clothing yourself in plastic. Microplastics will rub off on your skin, washing away in the washing machines and getting into the water supply. As the fabrics break down, they will become not only rougher against the skin, but also more difficult to mend and patch, limiting their wear life. But because they are plastics, they won't decompose and break down, continuing to pollute the environment unless they can be recycled.
Natural fabrics, in comparison, will become softer over time. They can be repaired more easily as they get holes or tears because the fabric will not have pieces break off like plastic will. It can be easily recycled, and will eventually decompose (which is why archaeologists rarely find clothing and textiles at dig sites), causing little to no damage to the environment. Rarely will a person be allergic to a natural fabric (WOOL! Argh!!!), and when they are, there is usually a protein, emollient, or fabric composition which can be a factor and can (usually) be mitigated, unlike with a synthetic fiber.
Don't get me wrong, synthetic fibers have their place and they have become very useful for certain things. But, we live in a time of fast fashion and high consumerism fueled by synthetic fabrics and exploited labor. Being conscientious of what your clothing is made of, what natural fabrics can do, how long they can last, and why and when you should wear them is a good way to start cutting down on waste while helping your body feel better. And you may find that by limiting the amount of synthetic materials you put on or near your body, that certain things might start to clear up (acne, rashes, etc.).
I know there is much more about fashion and fabrics out there, and I am 100% certain that there is someone out there MUCH more knowledgeable than me. But this is just some information I had and info dumped.
I'm a fiber nerd for similar reasons to you, headspace. If you'll humor me, I have a few unsolicited suggestions for looking for natural fibers in thrift stores (other than looking at the tags, naturally, but also since I don't always trust the tags, since fabric fraud or mislabeling isn't uncommon, and tags can be missing or hard to find).
Bast fibers like linen and hemp usually have a fair number of slubs and are usually woven for durability, because lightweight knits tend to unravel near the slubs just around the same time that the wear level starts to get Perfect.
If you're running through the racks and find a nice hand, remember that synthetics tend to absorb water poorly. Holding the fabric for just a moment and then rubbing the fingers together usually tells me if the moisture was absorbed, or if my hands are still sticky. Fabric softener and dry cleaning can fool me sometimes.
Same as the above, synthetics tend to reflect heat. If a fabric feels soft to the hand, hold onto it a moment. Silk and wool warm up slowly, but synthetics feel "warm" almost immediately. Plant fibers also warm pretty quickly in the hand, but will still absorb water.
Silk and wool are HEAVY on the thread level. A tightly woven silk jacket is way heavier than a poly or nylon one of similar thread gauge.
And although your assessments are largely excellent, pyroteknich, I have a few nits to pick:
Cotton gets WET and holds 36x its own weight in water, compared to ~6x for bast fibers and a little more for wool and silk. When it's wet, the water clogs the gaps in the clothes and prevents airflow. I mention this because I live in a humid subtropical area and sweat basically doesn't evaporate. Cotton means a swampy underside, or all-over-side if you're working hard enough or get caught in the rain. A notable exception to this is very loose and billowy clothing like gauzy skirts. I generally avoid cotton entirely because of its water-holding capacity.
Silk does wear like iron unless it gets wet, then it's very weak and abrades easily. Normal activities in my area will cause sweat to build up and that moisture will shred silks. Again, the solution is loose and billowy, and being choosy about which fabrics during particular times of year. I tend toward bast fibers in the warmer months and silks in the cooler ones. Reconstituted cellulose fibers like "bamboo", ramie, rayon, and so on have similarly poor durability when wet. Silk also stains very easily and HATES being in the sun to dry or for too long period, as UV light breaks it down, just something to be aware of.
And also unsolicited, I would like to share a few tips I've picked up for keeping natural fibers in good shape so they can get to that delightful broken-in level. We have very, very soft water in my area, so your mileage may vary.
If not handwashing, a top-loading washer, filled up completely with cold water, is pretty close to handwashing, on delicate settings.
Most of the time, "dry clean only" is a bunch of nonsense, except with suits or dresses made with water-soluble interfacing. People washed these pieces for how many centuries before dry cleaning existed? Yeah. Unfortunately, I don't know an easy way to find out if interfacings are water-soluble, except to give the piece a wash. I've restored dozens of stinky natural-fiber pieces that were discarded because the original owner's dry cleaning didn't remove the water-soluble odors, and I "restored" them just by giving them a nice wash. Sometimes a pair of suit pants or a jacket will start poking out the plastic interfacing after the wash, so yknow. Caveat washor.
Even if handwashing, strongly alkaline detergents or high heat will cause protein-based fibers like wools and silks to denature and degrade rapidly during the abrasion of washing. Vinegar will help, and mild curd soaps are best. If only washing wools, a little liquid lanolin mixed well with hot water and curd soap prior to adding to the wash water will help restore the fibers, making the garment more water-repellent, stronger, and more durable. Small amounts of detergents can be used to boost the efficacy of the wash if there is a lot of oil in the laundry soils.
Inversely, plant fibers prefer hot water and can withstand alkaline detergents well, making washing soda and borax viable additions, but hot water will often cause stains to set. I like to help remove the alkalines from the fabric by using vinegar in the rinse. Machine drying, even on "air dry" settings, will still cause static buildup in the fibers, making them slightly water-repellent and for myself, an extremely unpleasant sensory experience. I try to line-dry everything, which is difficult when showers and storms are unpredictable and frequent, and the humidity is 70%+ most days during the hottest part of the day. Still worth it, and indoor line-dry is an option.
Wools and silks are magnets for carpet beetles and clothes moths. When I'm storing clothes for the season, I wash them, gently lanolize the wools, make sure they're 100% dry, then heat up an oven with a baking stone to 200F (90C), line a metal sheet pan with parchment paper, cut the oven, and then leave the clothes in the oven for 30min to kill any eggs. Then I wrap them tightly with plastic bags and put them in plastic bins for storage, and I've never had a problem with insects since. I got the idea from bedbug treatments.
I hope that fellow sufferers from fast fashion and the electrostatic nightmare that is synthetic clothing can get a little something out of the years I've been working on this. I have pieces I've been wearing regularly for 15 years using these techniques.
This Pride Month, weâre celebrating the beauty of diversity above and below the surface. The ocean is full of vibrant life in every color imaginable. It reminds us that nature thrives when everyone has space to belong.
Environmental advocacy and the LGBTQ+ rights movement share a common purpose: protecting vulnerable communities, caring for the spaces we all call home, and creating a world where we all can flourish.
Our world is brightest when people can live authentically, love freely, and be embraced for who they are. From rainbow reefs to shimmering tides, diversity makes our blue planet stronger, healthier, and more inspiring.
Hereâs to protecting our ocean, uplifting every voice, and honoring the colorful communities that make this world so wonderful.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
random PSA, I know a lot of people use duckduckgo as a Google alternative search engine, but it always kind of annoyed me when I was using it because it felt like No Name Brand Google
I have switched to using Startpage.com and vastly prefer it. for one thing, instead of displaying an "AI summary" at the top of the search results (unless you turn it off, yes I know), it displays the first paragraph of the Wikipedia article, with link, whenever it finds one that's relevant.
also a waaayyyyy better sense of design than duckduckgo
also private, European based, least annoying search I've used lately (RIP old "don't be evil" Google)
i have one of those, scraped from multiple different rec posts:
Search Engines
Infinity Search is an alternative search engine with a special focus on privacy
DuckDuckGo is a popular search engine for those who value their privacy and are put off by the thought of their every query being tracked and logged. Uses bangs, ![site] for in-page search (sells your data to microsoft and draws from fucking bing)
WolframAlpha is a privately owned search engine that allows you to âcompute expert-level answers using Wolframâs breakthrough algorithms, knowledgebase, and AI technology.â A data search engine.
Boardreader is a search engine for forums and message boards. It allows you to search forums and then filter down results by date and language.
Based in France, Qwant is a privacy-based search engine that wonât record your searches or use your personal details for advertising. Uses â&â as a bang search.
Another privacy-based search engine is Search Encrypt, which uses local encryption to ensure that usersâ identifiable information cannot be tracked. Metasearch across multiple engines.Â
Offering unbiased results from several sources, SearX is a metasearch engine that aims to present a free, decentralized view of the internet. Can be self-hosted.Â
Gibiruâs tagline is âUnfiltered private searchâ and thatâs exactly what it offers. Requires AnonymoX Firefox add-on for privacy.Â
Disconnect allows you to conduct anonymous searches through a search engine of your choice.
Swisscows provides fully encrypted searches to protect your privacy and security. Built-in violence/porn filter cannot be overridden.Â
MetaGer offers âPrivacy Protected Search & Findâ through its anonymised search. A plugin will allow it to be made a default.
Gigablast is a private search engine that indexes millions of websites and servers real-time information without tracking your data, keeping you hidden from marketers and spammers. Variety of filtration and refinement options for searching.Â
Oscobo is a search engine that protects your privacy while you search the web. By not using any third-party tools or scripts, your data is protected from hacking and misuse. Has a Chrome extension to allow use in toolbar.Â
https://search.marginalia.nu/ an independent DIY search engine that focuses on non-commercial content, and attempts to show you sites you perhaps weren't aware of in favor of the sort of sites you probably already knew existed. Use old-school searching rather than query-based for the best results.Â
https://www.mojeek.com/Â
https://wiby.me/ - Itâs goal is to index as many personalized websites as possible, and NOT commercial sites.Â
https://4get.ca/ it works a lot like SearX, but honestly better. It doesnât have its own index, but pulls from many others. I think itâs the best for research, since it allows you to search for answers from different indexes, is easy to configure, add free, and avoids censorship as much as it can.
https://www.searchenginemap.com/ for more on how search engines relate to each other.
https://yep.com/ is a crawler
https://www.etools.ch/ retrieves from Google, Mojeek, Bing, and Yandex, like Searx
https://www.dogpile.com/Â
https://searxng.org/ (next gen Searx)
https://luxxle.com/ - possibly conservative?
https://presearch.com/ - good for academic?
https://kagi.com/smallweb - free/randomised Kagi.
Other Searchers
www.refseek.com - Academic Resource Search. More than a billion sources: encyclopedia, monographies, magazines.
www.worldcat.org - a search for the contents of 20 thousand worldwide libraries. Find out where lies the nearest rare book you need.
https://link.springer.com - access to more than 10 million scientific documents: books, articles, research protocols.
www.bioline.org.br is a library of scientific bioscience journals published in developing countries.
http://repec.org - volunteers from 102 countries have collected almost 4 million publications on economics and related science.
www.science.gov is an American state search engine on 2200+ scientific sites. More than 200 million articles are indexed.
www.base-search.net is one of the most powerful researches on academic studies texts. More than 100 million scientific documents, 70% of them are free.https://cosine.club/ is an electronic music similarity search engine
Apparently my stepdad and I are fucking psychically linked because ?? every single time he makes chili for dinner I get a migraine. Without fail. And it became like a ha ha running joke because it happened so many times but now Iâm living 3 hours away from my parents and I just texted my mom and
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
â Live Streamingâ Interactive Chatâ Private Showsâ HD Quality
Anya is LIVE right now
FREE
Free to watch ⢠No registration required ⢠HD streaming
dude just stopping by to say youâre so right about supercorp shippers denial about kara being a shitty friend?? itâs kinda insane?? i still love fanfic kara and supercorp fanfic but i cant look at one of the many scenes where kara was being awful to lena and think ohh kara loves her sm?? also the way they always say itâs just the writers fault guys kara isnât real ofc everything is the writers âfaultâ itâs called characterization?? and thatâs just karaâs?
anon i have to be honest: iâve been pretty leery of the supercorp fandom for a while now.
(thereâs actually quite a few interesting asks in my inbox that i wanted to write meta for but iâve let that fall by the wayside; these days i mostly share my thoughts with likeminded mutuals via dm and call it quits.)
i think ultimately youâve highlighted the crux of the problem in your ask: kara isnât real. [cwsg] kara is a fictional character written for a tv show by that tv showâs writers room. what the writers wrote is kara.
there is no secret real kara that exists outside of the show except in peopleâs minds, and - while you are absolutely free to do that! - you cannot force other people to accept that this secret real kara is somehow more real and more valid than what was actually put on peopleâs screens.
put another way: you can imagine kara however you want, but to me it is troubling that fandom will actively police references to the canon kara - that existed in the show as a character - using a yardstick based on a fanon kara that was made up by a group of likeminded fans.
and to be clear: you can absolutely like that fanon kara - or any other kara you made up in your head - and write stories and make fanart for her as much as you want!!!
âŚbut you cannot bend reality to pretend that kara is the neutral truth, or frankly even real.
ultimately, the common baseline of âkaraâ that exists for the cwâs supergirl tv show is what the cw network put on the screen and broadcast into peopleâs homes for six years.
that is the kara that âeveryoneâ watching the show (general audiences, fandom, whatever) has access to and that we all have in common, and it is actually disturbing to me that this is somehow controversial and a âhot takeâ in this fandom (see: this post).
but also, i have to say that i really truly appreciate you sending this.
on a personal note, i think part of the reason the fandom is visibly dying - even more than ai slop, even more than the natural decay over time since the end of the show - is in fact the complete intolerance for any sort of opinion that doesnât adhere strictly to the popular conception of fanon kara; if you donât fall over yourself to disclaim that you donât believe in canon kara and fanon kara is the one true kara, people get upset.
youâre allowed to find canon karaâs behaviour shitty - but you have to then reassert that you donât cosign the existence of canon kara, and the real kara would never do that, and also you love supercorp.
the villain of the day is the writersâ room - but without the writersâ room none of these characters would exist at all.
and i think there comes a point where people just start filtering out of the fandom rather than engaging, and - in my admittedly biased view, because i have quite a few really fun and smart mutuals who have stopped posting for supercorp altogether for these reasons - i think you lose a lot of interesting stories and ideas and analysis when that happens.
also unfortunate is that in a lot of cases this sort of policing and intolerance is directed at people who are in fact actually active and sharing and reblogging and writing meta in a fandom that is already waning - and critically, a fandom that is also often actively upset about the lack of engagement. how many events have occurred to try to revive the ship or reenergise the fandom?
but then youâre yelling at the people who are actively engaging with the fandom if theyâre not engaging the way you want them to???
âŚbut when i think about it, maybe thatâs what this crowd of fanon kara stans ultimately want?
perhaps for many in the fandom thatâs âwinningâ: itâs better to have a quieter fandom filled with only takes that people agree with and find palatable, the ones that are strictly in service of fanon kara and the supercorp ship that happens with that fanon kara đĽ´
iâve put some more personal commentary under the cut, including my thoughts about the tags that appear to have caused the most trouble: my beloved mutual @lifemodeldecoyâs assertion that there are parallels between lex and kara, which i do not think is âjust kara hateâ because honestly i think you can absolutely discuss constructively using the canon. (did i mention: this post?)
personal opinion only, ymmv, etc etc etc
when i first got into this fandom i was constantly told that the place was infested with kara haters, and if iâm honest i kind of thought - well i mean that makes sense, actually??? canon kara⌠isnât great and it seems understandable people are frustrated with her, but people shouldnât be haters, and also that seems counter productive to shipping supercorp?
what iâve discovered since then is if you are willing to or want to engage with the cwsg canon and canon kara in any way shape or form and you donât disclaim that itâs âall the fault of the writersâ that kara behaved however she did - also in doing so you need as well to explicitly and adamantly excuse or defend her behaviour in favour of supporting the ship - then⌠welp: you are a kara hater. đĽ´
(something something hi itâs me iâm the problem itâs me something something)
whatâs more is that the kara defending hivemind part of the fandom will actually swarm to her defense: anons in your inbox, passive aggressive tags and vagueposts, frankly sometimes outright tantrums - any number of claims that god some people just really hate kara.
(it doesnât even matter how small your little corner of tumblr is, or that the vast majority of the fandom is all about fanon kara; instead of Just Blocking Or Unfollowing people will take umbrage and find a way to let you know about it.)
i think whatâs even worse is that a lot of it is policing couched in a sort of particularly toxic faux positivity: let people enjoy themselves; weâre just having fun; well if you donât like it get out; i can do what i want; iâm just playing with my barbies; we can ignore canon if we want⌠etc etc etc. but at the end of the day itâs very much a general sense of weaponising the sentiment of you are ruining our fun and harshing my vibe shut up!!
âŚputting aside that you can do what you want applies to everyone, including people who enjoy working in and with the canon - it also doesnât actually matter how much of what you discuss is canon or even in how much good faith or actual interest you do your analysis: if you are not on board with the fact that there is a secret real kara that was done dirty by the evil writersâ room, then you, in fact, are the problem.
(this is why i donât do ask games or post meta anymore, and honestly if the kara stans feel theyâve won by shutting me up - well, congratulations.)
i really do think this is an unconstructive double edged sword: youâre effectively asking anyone who disagrees with you to shut up, but i think one of the other aspects that people maybe donât realise is that now people - who maybe did agree with you even! - are now scared to post lest they arenât showing enough positivity, which is really very counter to a fandom that keeps asking for more engagement.
(i have seen mutuals affected by this who were, in fact, actively shipping supercorp who still got snarked at for the audacity of engaging with the canon. some of those mutuals have left the fandom - itâs just not worth the fuss.)
and i think youâve actually highlighted this perfectly - kara is a piece of fiction. kara doesnât actually exist outside of what writers put pen to paper to write and then what they put on screen. that is canon kara whether you like her or not, whether you like her characterisation or not, whether you agree or not with their decisions: that is the most neutral form of kara that exists, because that is the kara that the cw network put on screen in their supergirl show.
you see as well a lot of comments that thatâs not kara and often defense from the comics, but i think the truth of the matter is that supergirl is not, in fact, a dc character with the consistency of background of some of the bigger ones: batman, superman, even lois lane have long running comics with through lines of characterisation.
when you look at the comics, supergirl has gone from the silver era girl clark kent to an angry teenager and back again; she doesnât actually have the volume of material to support consistent characterisation across her franchises, and some of her characterisations are in direct opposition to each other. amalgamating any two comic runs for any character is always an exercise in frankensteining a character, but larger characters with more consistent storylines tend to at least have recognisable through lines.
i donât think kara has developed that immediate recognisability of personality yet, and i think this is part of her appeal for fanwork - except i think you also see a constant thrum from fandom of no thatâs not right either about every rendition of kara that shows up.
âitâs called characterisation and thatâs just karaâsâ
(anon i laughed when i read that.)
i think part of the umbrage to any engagement with canon kara is the fact that karaâs characterisation in terms of her personality is in fact pretty consistent through the six seasons of cwsg. her behaviour is inconsistent, but there is consistency in that inconsistency - cwsg kara does have a fairly distinct and consistent characterisation, itâs just not one that people really like because unless youâre fully willing to buy into what she says on screen - and ignore what she does on that same screen - she really doesnât look very heroic in many ways.
(thatâs what made her interesting to me.)
there is also, i think, a fragility to the supercorp bubble, because i think the more you revisit or rewatch how kara behaved towards lena without active shipping goggles to filter her behaviour (it was the trauma!!!) the harder it is to justify the ship at all, especially when youâre watching knowing that a lot of the behaviour doesnât get better. it really is a ship that was coasting on chemistry and potential, but it also requires a deep suspension of disbelief, a lot of excusing of karaâs behaviour, and a great deal of softening of her character.
personally - even when i was still willing to ship supercorp - i have never vibed with karaâs behaviour; i have found that when i reread my meta from when i first stepped into fandom, my view of how kara behaves has been pretty consistent - but i am less willing to give her grace now, even though i have always found her interesting and deeply human in her flaws.
as the load bearing interpretation of cwsg kara has shifted into a kara that very much did not exist in canon, for me itâs had the effect of emphasising her flaws more than anything else; i find that because of the unrelenting drumbeat of the fanon kara stans i give her less and less grace even though my interpretation of her has been much the same. for me personally, the insistence that things that happened in canon either didnât happen or didnât count brings more of my attention to canon.
thatâs just me, of course, but honestly iâve found it really offputting how parts of the fandom will defend kara like sheâs a religious icon being persecuted. (there are some disturbing parallels to current events as well that i just canât unsee.)
the lex and kara thing
iâm not going to link the post because itâs clear op is already upset about the tags that turned up, but it does seem that one of the grievances raised was a tag by one of my very favourite people to talk to, @lifemodeldecoy, highlighting that there is in fact a parallel between lex and kara. (and once again - did i mention: this post?)
iâm going to try to keep this short (AHAHahAHAHAHHAhahaA way too late for that) but this is one of the first things that drew me to writing fic for supercorp: there is, in fact, a parallel, and one of the most damning ones is right there on screen: in season 5, lena tells lex that she has realised non nocere doesnât work, and lex screams in her face. this is what lex says:
How dare you? I gave you the world. Everything. I supported you. I sabotaged nothing, touched nothing. I set aside my own goals for you. Because you needed to see your little project fail with your own eyes. To know the true depravity of humanity. To know that my way was the only way.
in the next episode - after kara has frozen her out despite the fact that lena was the one who returned to the side of good - in one of the most fascinating references to lenaâs trauma, lena says you can scream at me if you like, i know i deserve it.
and then kara does, which is wild enough in and of itself, but in between karaâs reiterations of lenaâs wrongs, this is what kara says:
You have never understood what it means share a secret identity with someone. How much danger that puts them in. You⌠You never even understood that I kept my identity from you because I wanted to protect you.
I made one mistake. One mistake that was only ever meant to protect you. And in return, all you did was hurt me in every way imaginable.
even if you are fully on karaâs side and willing to take all of this at face value, at the very least there is a clear parallel in these appeals to lena: canât you see what iâve been doing for you?
you might be able to argue how much and to what extent the damage was, and you can argue as well about their motivations for doing so, but there are very distinct parallels in how lex and kara âhandleâ lena. in both cases this is someone that they both care deeply about - in whatever fashion - but expect some amount of leniency from and also control over (a more softer phrasing might be to have buy-in from), in the sense that lena is expected to fall in line with what they want.
the degree to which they do this, the intent with which itâs done, and the hurt it causes may not be equal, but the similarities exist even if you wholeheartedly believe kara to have been motivated by trauma and a desire to do good, and lex to have been motivated by his own selfish desires and a penchant for evil.
in its most charitable interpretation kara and lex are flip sides of personality, karaâs flaws on the side of good and lexâs flaws a warped mirror on the side of evil; in an uncharitable interpretation thereâs something interesting about lena in terms of survivors of abuse and returning to the dynamics theyâre accustomed to.
but a few examples from the canon:
s4 eve is a long con by lex, but sheâs installed in proximity to lena to ultimately betray her and provide information on lena back to lex; s3 james isnât a plant and may have opted not to follow through with the kryptonite check, but kara actively instigated the ask and pressured james when he showed reluctance to do a secret kryptonite check on lenaâs lab.
the kryptonite is arguably a fascinating juxtaposition: lex is afraid of the godlike powers of kryptonians and has multiple kryptonite plots in his scheming to maintain control to save humanity; conversely throughout s2 and s3, kara maintains she must be the only person in control of kryptonite because âthe weight of the world rests on her shoulders.â
if you want another analogy to lexâs screaming, the tirade when lena offers up her superpowered kryptonite - later key in making sure no one got killed by reign when alex inadvertently exposes reignâs hiding place - by kara is a trip.
the continuation of the kryptonite issue in the harunel is even more interesting: lex needs it for his godlike powers; kara needs it to save argo. very different positions to be sure, but still a parallel - both need it from lena and both lose their temper with her in its development (kara because lena has it at all and itâs too dangerous for her to have - a mindwiped alex defends her to point out that she saved james with it - and lex because lena is being too safe and following the wikipedia article for lab safety protocol).
and more generally: that specific dynamic of praise and animosity. for supergirl this is most evident in the kryptonite spat in s3; for lex this appears throughout lenaâs history that he was, once, her supportive older brother; even if you see it as a contrast in dynamics, a manipulative lex is willing to tell her she will always fall into the light (youâre good, lena, i believe in you!). both are telling her the same thing: youâre not like the other luthors.
regardless of whether your interpretation of this parallel is juxtaposition in the positive (a redemption: this time lena has someone who actually believes in her in kara, instead of the manipulative brother who told her he believed in her in the past) or whether you see something more disturbing in it (lena keeps falling into validation-seeking dynamics where sheâs praised when she falls in line and punished when she doesnât), this parallel does in fact exist in canon.
anyway, that was very long winded - but thank you anon, i really do appreciate you reaching out.