About Free Will and the Ineffable Plan
They love humanity precisely because humans have free will, the ability to choose who and what they want to be. Humans had the very thing Aziraphale and Crowley believed they themselves lacked ā free will. But they had it all along. Otherwise, Aziraphale would never have lied to God, never given away his sword, never interfered with the divine plan by saving Jobās children, never made the Arrangement with Crowley, never chosen Crowley over and over again, never agreed to stop Armageddon in the end. Crowley would never have asked questions, never helped Aziraphale save Jobās children, never talked Elspeth out of suicide (which, ironically, he himself ended up committing in the finale), never saved his angel time and time again, never kept choosing Aziraphale, never done good deeds when he was explicitly told to do evil instead, never stood side by side with his angel to stop Armageddon. Free will always existed, absolutely. For angels and demons alike.
And free will doesnāt belong only to them. All angels and demons have it ā itās just that, unlike Aziraphale and Crowley, none of them spent enough time on Earth to become more human and fully realize that free will, enough to stand against the system that kept telling them they didnāt have any in the first place.
To me, Good Omens also reflected our own reality ā how many people in positions of power use God and the ādivine planā as a shield for their terrible actions. I always saw God in Good Omens as something like a bored but merciful being who genuinely loves Her creations ā and thatās exactly why She gave them free will. That was her original plan all along, otherwise, as Crowley himself said at the beginning of season 1, She wouldāve put the Tree of Knowledge on the Moon, on a mountaintop, or simply never created it at all if She didnāt want humans to have free will. That is Her Ineffable Plan ā to give humanity free will. When Aziraphale says in the finale that they want a universe where there is ānothing ineffable,ā he is literally saying āno free will.ā It feels like the people behind the finale heard the phrase āIneffable Planā but never actually understood what it meant.
And when She made the wager with Satan during the Job story, She already knew Crowley wouldnāt destroy the goats or kill the children. She knew Aziraphale wouldnāt allow it to happen either. She knew he would lie in order to do the right thing. Precisely because he has free will. She is omniscient ā She knew everything from the very beginning. She knows what was, what is, and what will be. She is not cruel ā the cruel ones are those who speak in Her name. The Great Plan does not belong to Her; only the Ineffable one does. The āGreat Planā was invented by those claiming to speak for Her.
The original theme, free will as part of the ineffable plan, felt lost and replaced with cheap drama. What began as a comedic story with religious motifs that satirized the idea of total self-sacrifice for a ābetterā world instead of actually trying to fix things, ultimately ended with exactly that kind of sacrifice, along with a strange, inconsistent drama that doesnāt align with established characterizations.
The finale erased all of that, threw it away, and forgot about it.
And I have something to add. At the end of season 1, Aziraphale asks Gabriel and Beelzebub whether they are certain that everything that happenedāthe stopping of Armageddon and so onāwas not actually part of the Ineffable Plan. Beelzebub and Gabriel only talk about the Great Plan, but Aziraphale and Crowley argue that no one can be sure that everything that occurred wasnāt part of the Ineffable Plan, because it is, by definition, unknowable.
God designed it exactly that way from the very beginning. She knew everything in advance. She knew they would stop Armageddon. That was her Ineffable Plan all along.
But in the finale, we see all of this being forgotten, crossed out, and literally erased.
@a-zira-ziraphale-fell I wonder what do you think about it, dear
