Victoria is explicitly spiteful. Victoria has explicitly said that she wants to hurt her enemies, to make them suffer as she has suffered. This impulse is tempered by her better nature, by her commitment to rationality and mercy and de-escalation. Because Victoria has the awareness to think about how her actions will effect not just herself and her enemies, but also the “big picture”.
In contrast, Amy isn’t spiteful at all. Amy doesn’t hurt people out of spite, and she doesn’t want to take revenge on the people who have harmed her. Rather, Amy makes people suffer because it simply doesn’t seem to occur to her that it’s even possible for her actions to cause suffering in others.
I agree, re Victoria being spiteful, but Amy does hurt people out of spite. In her first appearance, she messes with a guy’s head by telling him she gave him erectile dysfunction.
You are correct about that. She also “messes” with Taylor’s head after the Leviathan fight. But she doesn’t actually follow through on any of her implied threats, and these things (a) happen relatively early in the story, and (b) are very quickly dwarfed by the many, many non-spite motivated horrifying actions that she does. (Like, for example, messing with people’s heads in the literal, not-in-quotations sense.)
So yes, she does have some capacity for spitefulness, particularly early in the story. But even from the begining, she is still primarily driven not by spite, but rather by her desire to “help” others. She’s just disasterously bad at it.
Also, she compares Jessica Yamada to herself as a kind of “take that”, which I definitely interpreted as motivated by spite. This happened later in the story - post Gold Morning.












