So, over the course of the past month I've seen a number of people reading Everyone's Friend and coming away from it with a sentiment like "What am I supposed to do when it isn't all in my head?" or "Telling people that their problems are all in their head kind of sucks", or "What, so my loneliness is all my fault and I'm a bad person for thinking of my friends as bad people?" and I just want to clarify:
My intended message was not "all of these things are 100% made up in Myrrh's head and all of her problems are her fault and anyone who is lonely or scared is a villain who is hurting themselves and others and should feel bad because all of their problems are their own fault"
My intended message was meant to be "all these problems are real and miserable, but sometimes your brain might be exaggerating a little, or sometimes your fear might be holding you back, and you have to get out of your head and figure out what's true and what isn't".
I tried to frame the comic in a way that didn't explicitly place the 'blame' on one party or another -- I think that a lot of the time stuff like this isn't really anyone's fault, so I didn't want it to seem too blame-y or one-sided -- but in hindsight I might not have done the best job. The last thing I wanted was for anyone who feels the same way I feel to read that comic and come away from it thinking I was blaming them for their loneliness or dismissing their problems, so I'm genuinely really sorry that some people read it that way.
Every one of Myrrh's thoughts in the comic is a real thing that has happened to me, or a real thought that I have had about a real thing that has happened to me, sometimes distorted or exaggerated, sometimes not.
These problems weren't meant to be "all in her head"; they're all things that do happen, they're all at least a little bit real, it's just that Myrrh's perception of these events, their severity, and the things that she assumes is causing them, may not always be accurate, because her brain is always telling her that the only possible explanation for everything is the worst-case-scenario.
I was trying to say that the truth is often somewhere in the middle, and that Myrrh has to actually talk to her friends in order to find it. Maybe her friends really don't care about her at all, or maybe they really do but there's something else getting in their way, or maybe they like her, but not quite enough to want to put in any real effort, but whatever the truth is, she has to get out of her head and have the scary conversations in order to find out for sure before she can fix anything.
In the last panel, when it's revealed that we've been looking at Myrrh's thoughts, we see her friends gathered around her. Some of them look worried and sad and confused, some of them look just confused, but, crucially, none of them are reaching out to her or moving to comfort her, they're all just standing there and watching. I'd hoped that this would imply that at least some of Myrrh's perception is real -- her friends, intentionally or not, are neglecting her. None of this is her fault; even if it was all in her head, none of this is her fault. She is, at worst, a victim of her own brain, and, like everyone else in the world, an occasionally-imperfect friend.
I have had friends that genuinely did not care about me. I have had friends that did care at least a little but were unable or unwilling to put in the work. I have had friends that REALLY, REALLY cared about me, but I thought that they didn't because I have a brain that likes to hurt me. I often have a very hard time telling these situations apart.
I wanted to make a comic that could acknowledge these problems and how miserable they are while also giving people -- including myself -- some hope, like "hey it sucks to feel this way, it sucks to be treated this way, it's so miserable it makes me physically ill and I can't stop it and I don't know what to do -- but maybe it's not always as bad as you think, maybe if you can just be brave and communicate with people, things will get better".
But, I was in a very bad place when I wrote this comic, and in hindsight I might have written it sort of clumsily and self-loathingly because of that. Sometimes I have an easier time blaming myself for everything than I do blaming people I care about, and I didn't consider how that bias might bleed into the story a little and make some people think the underlying message was "If you're sad, you're imagining it and it's your fault".
Obviously, I can't know everyone's situation, and I can't control every possible interpretation of my art, and I can't avoid every single misunderstanding or uncharitable read, but this time I feel strongly enough about it that I just want to say: that is not what I was trying to say at all. I'm sorry if my art made you feel worse. Your problems are real -- even when they are "all in your head", they're still real problems and you're not crazy and you deserve to have those problems solved. And sometimes those problems aren't your fault, and sometimes they are, but none of that really matters. This was never about whose 'fault' these things are.
I just wanted to push myself -- and everyone reading -- to have the courage to acknowledge all the unaddressed problems and feelings they're afraid to talk about, so that we can all figure out what's real and what we're imagining, identify the true nature of the problem, and then try and fix things. I wanted to encourage myself, and everyone, to try and do something, anything, instead of just sitting around torturing themselves in their heads for the rest of their lives.
I'll be brave if you will too