Cinderella September-through-November: "The Slipper and the Rose" (1976 film)
This lavish live-action musical is surprisingly underrated given its starry array of talents. Besides a cast filled with distinguished names from British film and theatre, it features songs and a screenplay both written by the legendary Sherman Brothers, who provided the music for Mary Poppins, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, The Jungle Book, The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh, and other childhood classics.
The first and foremost way this adaptation stands apart from other Cinderellas is by making co-protagonists of Cinderella and her charming Prince Edward of Euphrania, rather than focusing chiefly on her. (Apparently this explains the film's title: the royal family's crest features the image of a rose, so "the rose" symbolizes the Prince, while of course "the slipper" represents Cinderella.) From the beginning, the film alternates between scenes of the royal court, where Edward chafes against his lack of freedom and resists his parents' attempts to foist a loveless political marriage on him, and scenes of Cinderella's hardships in her stepfamily's home... which are soon alleviated when she kindly lets a road-weary woman rest by her kitchen fire, and the woman turns out to be an unusually human, quirky Fairy Godmother.
This version's other distinguishing feature is its emphasis on realistic socio-political concerns. The royal court scenes constantly emphasize – in a satirical way – the importance of tradition, protocol and duty, while a minor subplot involving the Prince's valet John's love for a lady above his station highlights the rigidity of social class. All of this foreshadows the story's final act, which continues after the traditional fairy tale ends. The King is reluctant to let his son marry a commoner and thus lose the chance to protect his kingdom from war with a marriage alliance, so he and his Lord Chamberlain secretly send Cinderella into exile. It takes more intervention from the Fairy Godmother to save Edward from an unwanted wedding and reunite him with his true love.
All of the above details, plus the Sherman Brothers' love of long, sophisticated words in their lyrics, make this more of a grownup Cinderella than a children's version. (There's even a dark comedy song in the royal crypt, where the Prince and John sing about terrible past kings while literally dancing on their tombs!) But that's not to say there's any lack of magic or charm. The elegant settings and the luxurious 18th century costumes are gorgeous, and as a whole, the film strikes an excellent balance between comic satire and dreamy fairy tale romance. And while the Shermans' score might not quite be as memorable as their famous work for Disney, their array of songs ("Why Can't I Be Two People?" "What Has Love Got to Do With Getting Married?" "Once I Was Loved," "What A Comforting Thing to Know," "Protocoligorically Correct," "A Bride-Finding Ball," "Suddenly It Happens," "Secret Kingdom," "When He/She Danced With Me," "Position and Positioning," "Tell Him Anything" and "I Can't Forget the Melody") are still appropriately tuneful and winning.
The filmmakers chose to pair an unknown Cinderella with an established star as her Prince, yet they both give appealing performances. Gemma Craven's lovely Cinderella blends classic fairy tale innocence and feeling with inner strength and dignity, as well as a sweet soprano voice. Richard Chamberlain's Prince Edward likewise sings with a handsome burnished tone and strikes the perfect balance between the sarcastic humor with which he voices his frustrations and his romantic tenderness in the love scenes. The leading couple's chemistry and the genuine heartbreak they convey at being separated saves the last-act plot extension from seeming like filler. Annette Crosbie's Fairy Godmother excellently combines warmth, eccentricity and no-nonsense wit, Margaret Lockwood is an appropriately hateful Stepmother, Sir Michael Hordern contributes further humor as the anxious fuddy-duddy King, and the rest of the supporting cast (including Dame Edith Evans as the Prince's senile old grandmother the Dowager Queen, Kenneth More as the Lord Chamberlain, and an adorable little dog who helps the Fairy Godmother to help Cinderella) are excellent all around.
While not the definitive screen Cinderella, the Sherman Brothers unique and colorful spin on the story is still worth seeing, both for fairy tale lovers and for fans of classic, sumptuous movie musicals.
@ariel-seagull-wings, @superkingofpriderock