Ever since its formation on May 1st, 1971, Amtrak has been operating much of the nation's passenger trains across the contiguous United States. This was in part due to governmental regulations imposed onto railroads as well as competition with interstate highways and jet airliners. Unfortunately, a little over a month after taking over most passenger rail services, Amtrak would face its first ever fatal accident.
On June 10th, 1971, Amtrak train No. 1 (now No. 59), the southbound City of New Orleans, stands at Chicago's Central Station awaiting departure. Prior to Amtrak's formation, the train was originally operated as a daytime service by the Illinois Central Railroad. All of the equipment being used on the train, from the locomotives to the passenger cars, are still painted in their original Illinois Central liveries.
The locomotives pulling the train are E8A No. 4031, E9B No. 4109, E9B No. 4106, and E10A No. 2024 (Ex-E8A No. 4032), models belonging to EMD's E-Unit series. Unlike most diesel locomotives that normally have one prime mover, E-Units have two prime movers which can have an output rating that ranges from 1,800 HP to 2,400 HP, this depends on the model though. But in the case of the E8 and E9 units, the E8 outputs 2,250 HP while the E9 outputs 2,400 HP. Behind the locomotives are a baggage car, eleven coach cars, a diner-counter car, a lounge car, and combination coach/food service car making up the consist. At 8:00 AM Central Time, the train departs beginning its southbound journey to New Orleans, Louisiana.
The journey however was anything but a smooth ride as the second prime mover on No. 4031 began to malfunction and was unable to be fixed. But following a crew change in Champaign, Illinois, the new crew noticed that the second prime mover had responded to the throttle and believed that it was operational again. Continuing down the ICRR mainline, the train began to approach a crossover south of Champaign and when it started to pass over the crossover, the unthinkable happened.
At 12:30 PM Central Time, the train derails as No. 4031 falls onto its right side and slides 1,031 feet away from where it derailed while No. 4109 caught fire. No. 4106 and No. 2024 remained upright with little damage while the baggage car and first few coaches were destroyed with the remaining cars recieving various levels of damage. Eleven people were killed and 163 were injured as the result of this derailment, six of these fatalities happened when passengers were ejected through large side windows like military pilots escaping from a crashing fighter jet with ejection seats.
During the investigation, the NTSB discovered flat spots on No. 4031's rear truck alongside markings on the tracks between between Tonti and Effingham, Illinois. This further showed that truck's traction motor had seized prior to the derailment and that the wheels had likely locked while at Effingham Station. The locked wheels created a false flange and when the damaged wheel reached the switch at the Tonti crossover, it came off the rail triggering the accident.
Four days prior on June 6th, No. 4031 was running between Chicago and New Orleans when its second prime mover also had problems and had to be shut down in New Orleans while having its reverser locked in neutral for the trip to Chicago. But shutting down the prime mover and locking the reverser in neutral would in turn disable the wheel slip indicator, a device that notifies the engineer that a wheel is slipping or sliding. While No. 4031 was repaired in Chicago, Illinois Central maintenance employees were unaware that the reverser was locked and had no idea that power was not being supplied to the rear truck.
After investigating, the NTSB concluded that mechanical faults in No. 4031 caused the derailment and recommended railroads to improve wheel-slip detection devices for locomotives and for pre-departure testing procedures. They also recommended that the FRA should create safety standards to address the ejection of passengers through windows in the event of accidents. While No. 4031 and 4109 were scrapped due to being severely damaged, No. 4106 and No. 2024 were repaired and returned to service. But they too have been scrapped after being retired in favor of newer locomotives, namely SDP40Fs, P30CHs, and F40PHs. As for the City of New Orleans, the train still runs under Amtrak but is now an overnight service.
More recently in 2025, University of Missouri journalist student Henderick Morton began a goal of identifying the only unidentified decedent of the wreck. When digging up this person's grave, it was revealed through x-ray scans that there were at least two, maybe even three, unidentified victims inside the grave, one of them appeared to be a child. The DNA Doe Project has joined in on this investigation which is still going on as of today. Sadly, this wasn't the last of Amtrak's accidents as many more would occur in the following years since then. But valuable life lessons have been learned from then on.
Models and Route by: Trainz Forge, Auran, and Download Station
Information Sources Cited in Chicago Style:
“Chicago Manual of Style 17th Edition.” Chicago Manual of Style 17th Edition - Purdue OWL® - Purdue University, owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/chicago_manual_17th_edition/cmos_formatting_and_style_guide/chicago_manual_of_style_17th_edition.html. Accessed 8 May 2026.
“EMD ‘E’ Units (Locomotives).” 2024. American-Rails.com. 2024. https://www.american-rails.com/6686.html.
NTSB final report: Pilot error caused crash that killed Nashville family nearly two years ago | local news | thesouthern.com. Accessed May 19, 2026. https://thesouthern.com/news/local/ntsb-final-report-pilot-error-caused-crash-that-killed-nashville-family-nearly-two-years-ago/article_7aa14b54-8bbd-5423-b4b6-d4b1ef210db3.html.
Holden Kurwicki. 2025. “Mystery Deepens: Multiple Remains Found inside Grave Tied to 1971 Train Crash.” Ksdk.com. KSDK. June 18, 2025. https://www.ksdk.com/article/news/local/illinois/mystery-deepens-multiple-remains-found-inside-grave-1971-crash/63-7b79c927-9bdd-4808-9536-c2d8fc4de3c0.
Wells, Mark. 2025. “REMAINS of TWO INDIVIDUALS DISCOVERED in BODY BAG of UNKNOWN TONTI TRAIN CRASH VICTIM.” WFIW FM / WFIW AM / WOKZ-FM. June 14, 2025. https://www.wfiwradio.com/2025/06/14/remains-of-two-individuals-discovered-in-body-bag-of-unknown-tonti-train-crash-victim/.












