ftr, i’m sending this in good faith because i respect you and i think you’re very smart. this isn’t an attempt to bait you or anything 😭 but i am really curious about your opinion on suicides “caused” by ai chatbots. i’ve always been skeptical of the framing a lot of people have regarding these cases where they describe them using phrases like “chatgpt murdered this person” and such, but i also have No idea how to logically rebuff this type of hyperbole without coming across like i’m minimizing these really tragic deaths and what that person was going through.
i mean, like. you can look at the chats released in these cases, right. it's never someone going "wow my life is going really well and i'm very happy". i think obviously the way that these chatbots are like... designed to engage with people, and indeed to engage with them in these chats, is extremely irresponsible, it's perhaps the place where the sycophancy built into these models has the absolute worst consequences. but, imo, i think it is trivializing these people, and their autonomy, and the ways in which their lives were genuienly shitty, to attribute their choice to evil robot mind control, especially if you're cynically doing it to win an unrelated argument. like, parents of suicidal teens love to blame chatgpt the way they love to blame phones/the internet/video games/dungeons and dragons/secular rock music, because it's a viewpoint that completely exonerates them, the people with the most outsized and totalizing influence on the actual quality of their kids' lives