Why the heck are the comics like this? I have nothing against Kataang as a fanon shipβitβs cute, fix the things wrong with it in canon and ship the heck out of it! But the way itβs portrayed in canon by Bryke with like zero input from Katara, romanticization of the forced kiss trope, verbal abuse and one-sided emotional support and lack of understanding is likeβ¦ why? Kataang could have been a great ship! It could have been complex with Katara recognizing that she was putting Aang on a pedestal tooΒ byΒ pinning her hopes of saving the world on him while also simultaneously mothering him/treating him like a child. He canβt be both child in need of protection and divine savior and there could have been so much emotional tension between the two of them stemming from this.
Aang could have had amazing character development by calling Katara outΒ (βyou canβt protect me from everything, Kataraβitβs not fairβ) when he realizes the extent to which his inability to control the Avatar state unfairly burdens Katara with the responsibility of making sure he doesnβt hurt the people around him. So he goes to Guru Pathik and lets go of his attachment to Katara. And by this, I mean a nuanced take onΒ βattachmentββitβs notΒ βYou canβt ever love Kataraβ butΒ βMy current attachment to youβin fact, our attachment to each otherβis codependent and selfish and has been ever since you dug me out of the icebergβ¦ I want better for you, for us, so Iβm letting you go. I love you more than I love my attachment to you.β
And this is a much better setup for a poignant, selfless, transcendent romance. It could have actually intertwined their character arcs to grow together instead of the half-assed mother-child-but-you-forcibly-kissed-me-against-my-will-but-I-guess-Iβll-kiss-youβin-the-last-20-seconds dynamic we got in the show.Β
(As an aside, the poignant transcendent symbolism, the selflessness, the growing together is why Zutara remains the vastly more popular ship 15 years after the airing of the show despite not being canon).
Imagine if Katara and Aang actually got to be friends on equal footing after they stop idealizing each other.
Imagine if Aang matured enough to provide emotional support to Katara instead of always the other way around, in aΒ βYouβve always taken care of meβlet me take care of you for onceβ sort of way.
Imagine if Aang was secretly pining for her instead of forcing his feelings on her, conflicted between his duty as the Avatar, upholding his Air Nomad philosophy of detachment, and his growing selfless love for herβthe real Katara with all her flaws and darkness and not the Katara in his head he idealized. Basically going fromΒ βWhy arenβt we together yet?!β toΒ βItβs okay you donβt love me yet or everβI would never expect that from you. I know now that that would be selfishβand I made the mistake of being selfish with you once, and I donβt want to make that mistake again. Love comes in time, in its own way, and it shouldnβt ever be conditional.β
It would have been so great for him as a character.Β
Imagine Katara not holding back with Aang, getting angry at him, telling him exactly what he needed to hear (for e.g., when he runs away and how that affects her abandonment issues) instead of accepting/enabling his selfishness with nary a word of reproach.
Imagine Katara realizing that her need to mother him was wrong and came from a place of trauma stemming from her motherβs death and her fear of losing anyone else close to her because she couldnβt protect them.
Imagine Katara letting that go and eventually, down the line, she develops genuine feelings for Aangβnot the boy she rescued from the iceberg, simultaneously child and savior, but the man who despite everything has matured into a kind, generous, selfless, non-judgmental, and genuinely wise person who always puts other above himself or his selfish desires.
Imagine a relationship that is less about destiny andΒ βbaby, youβre my forever girlβ and more about a mutual βI donβt care about destinyβitβs never been about that. Itβs been about just you and me, and I hope I mean as much to you as you mean to me. I want you to be my forever person, if youβll have me, because what we have is something destiny could never predict.β
Because true love is not blind. It sees all and does not mind.
I want all of this emotional tensionΒ present in this ship. I want it to be resolved. I want the catharsis.Β
THATΒ is the Kataang I want to see.
Goddamit, now I want fanfiction of this. Someone please write this.
Instead, we get a juvenile fifth grade romance that never moves beyond mutual and toxic idealization and actually regresses further in the comics with anti-feminist physical intimidation (throwing lava at the girl you like, anyone?) and emotional abandonment (Aang cavorting with the new Air acolyte girls while Katara is left abandoned and the comics make Aang out to be right wtfβ).
The comics are so so so badly written and OOC and feature plot-driven characters instead of character-driven plot, which, you know, predictably ruins the characters weβve come to know and love from the show because their world views become whatever the plot requires of them at the moment and they become black and white narrative vehicles instead of actual characters with nuanced viewpoints.