lmaooooo that post really got me thinking. because tranquility is the most compelling argument against the circles, dai completely skips over them and paints circle mages as the ones abusing the tranquil which is just⦠so fucking insane
the first tranquil mage you meet is in redcliffe and heāll tell you that the tevinter mages have kicked out the tranquil and asks to go with the inquisition because they can be useful. which makes no sense because literally in the same part of the game you can find a bunch of tranquil skulls in a shed, because the venatori have been killing the tranquil. you get commentary from EVERYONE about how the circle mages abandoned the tranquil. you talk to minaeve in haven and she implies that the mages somehow didnāt see the tranquil as people and thatās a fault of the mages themselves.
like⦠who made the rite of tranquility? who lobotomised them in the first fucking place and then USED THEM to handle lyrium to make money for the circle??? who displays tranquil mages all around the circle to remind mages of what will happen to them if they disobey?? WHO USES THE RITE OF TRANQUILITY AS A PUNITIVE MEASURE AGAINST MAGES??? the chantry and the templars themselves level the tranquil as a threat and use them as things but somehow itās the circle magesā fault that the tranquil were killed off??? whose fault is it that the mages fear and are uncomfortable with the tranquil?? who DESIGNED it that way??? whose purpose does it serve???
and itās literally the stupidest thing anyway. how did tranquil mages END UP in fucking redcliffe in the first place IF THEY WERENāT WITH THE MAGE REBELLION??? like??? hello??? tranquil mages HAD FRIENDS in the circle. they had LOVERS in the circle. they were people before the chantry ripped everything away from them and thereās evidence that MAGES ACTUALLY WENT OUT OF THEIR WAY TO BRING THEM OUT OF THE CIRCLE TOO
thereās NO commentary or dialogue or even shock about avexis being made tranquil in dai even tho cassandra is RIGHT THERE and PERSONALLY KNEW avexis. you can make mage prisoners tranquil as a mage inquisitor which is SO fucked up because itās literally the most horrible thing that could happen to a mage? EVERY SINGLE MAGE, irrespective of personal political beliefs about the circle, fears tranquility??? the only time a mage doesnāt fear it is when they genuinely think the templars will otherwise kill them??? wouldnāt it make more sense for a templar spec inquisitor or an andrastian inquisitor specifically to have that option?? why make it so MAGE inquisitors can do it, like they didnāt grow up with the threat hanging over their heads the entire time they were in the circle AS CHILDREN??
cassā quest where you find out they always knew how to reverse it and simply ⦠didnāt, essentially permanently lobotomising millions of mages for a thousand years, is less impactful when you donāt understand how horrific tranquility is. finding out theyāve essentially abused the rite to abuse mages and then telling cassandra that actually no, the seekers dont deserve to be rebuilt, the chantry deserves to crumble, generates disapproval! she DISAPPROVES of you disapproving of their abuse of power! and you canāt do ANYTHING about it afterwards! cass just decides to keep it a secret until they can find out more about it⦠when? how will you find out more if no one else knows the reversal exists? thereās NOTHING about helping the tranquil even as a throwaway line in the epilogue slides! thereās no tranquil walking around discussing it, making note that cassandra approached them or anything like that at all!
thereās just NO real exploration in dai of what the tranquil are ā why the rite of tranquility is used (other than theĀ āclaimsā of it being to āhelp save magesā who otherwise canāt control their magic), what function the tranquil have in the circle (thereās literally an economic motivation for the chantry and the templars to keep making mages tranquil bc tranquil mages can manipulate lyrium for enchantments), and thereās NO conflicting opinions on the necessity of the rite in the first place and NO REAL TRANQUIL VOICES. the one person who DID have the rite of tranquility used against them punitively in kirkwall ends up working for one of the antagonists!
considering people went into dai for the first time and didnāt have the bg knowledge of tranquility from dao and da2, itās just so deliberate. the problem, suddenly, isnāt that tranquil mages are made by the chantry and the templars, itās not even that the rite is used punitively irrespective of whether it should exist or be used at all. the problem, dai argues, is that mages treat tranquil mages badly. that without the circle, the tranquil mages are killed and abused bc theyāre vulnerable. as tho tranquil mages are just naturally occurring in nature and not a horrific abuse resulting from the circle in the first place.