I have to agree with @aranel-parmadil, that Iād be most uncomfortable with editing an authorās work to the point of abridging it. Ā I canāt think of an author here who would welcome or tolerate that. Ā Hours and hours of work go into most peopleās work here and who am I to go chopping it about? Not an editor, thatās for sure. Ā I have often asked an author if they would mind me Brit-picking their piece (and have been turned down once for that, missing out on a most beautiful piece) and on occasions, I have become involved in the beta process prior to podficcing. Ā Contrary to @bagofthumbsā approach, I will often change words about or constrict words, especially in speech, but this is all to lead to a smoothness in the finished product and to produce a natural flow. Ā It is what I consider to be part of the talent of podficcing (authors would rarely read their work out loud and the very BEST pieces for a podficcer to work on are those where the feeling is that thatās exactly what the author has done!) It is ALWAYS my intention to stay true to what I perceive to be the authorās intended meaning and tone. At the end of the day, I choose to podfic a piece of work because I love it - it is my homage to their writing, my equivalent of hitting the kudos button over and over, why would I want to change it??
I am, at heart a storyteller - I am driven to present my favourite tales in the form of pods. Ā The kind of experimentation Iām actively involved in is whether listeners prefer longer podfics or shorter one-shots, whether they prefer unrated, teen, mature or explicit podfics, and whether they prefer daily postings or weekly ones. Ā My findings, so far, are that there are horses for courses. Ā My most popular podfic to date (The Edinburgh Problem) is one that is over 20 hours long and was presented as a āSunday Specialā, where listeners ātuned inā every week with a cuppa, as if they were listening to a radio play. Ā Conversely, one of the most popular single chapters is 2 hours long (A Brand of Gold). I think, if you do a good job on any kind of podfic, it will be recommended and therefore listened to by more people!
It saddens me that podfic will never be anything like as popular as written work, that, in some circles, it is seen as a second-class of fan fiction because itās not āoriginal workā. Ā In my eyes, it is absolutely original. Ā Every playwright and screen writer needs performers, and while little fan fiction is written expressly for performance, the very best of it is enhanced by the very talented reading of our fandom podficcers. How lucky are we to have a professional audiobook reader in our fandom? Ā (Yay, way to go, aranel!) Seriously, this is awesome, we are truly blessed! Ā I am blown away by the variety of talent and sheer cleverness there is in our fandom. Honestly, itās amazing.
As aranel and bagofthumbs have already pointed out, there is a phenomenal amount of work going on behind the scenes of a podfic. Ā I reckon, as a general rule of thumb, that there is at least three hours of work behind every hour that you hear, and when you get to a complicated presentation with cover art, music, sound effects or new skills to be learned, it can be as much as 8 hours per hour of listening. Ā We podficcers take our hobby very, very seriously. Ā I devote about 30 hours a week to my presentations, with additional time for reading and sourcing material. I kind of treat it like a second job and this is a personal reason why I would not like the additional task of abridgement. Ā Wow, what a whole lot of new work to do!! Please, no!!!
@a-different-equation, you poor thing, you made some lovely suggestions and weāve all jumped on you and said āOh no, please no!!ā Ā The absolute best thing we could ask of you (and anyone who follows us) is to keep recommending us, like and re-blog our podfic postings, keep listening, encourage people to leave kudos when they have enjoyed our work and leave comments to encourage us to do more. Ā In that regard, we are no different from writers - kudos and comments are our hobbyās lifeblood. Ā Without those, itās like performing to an empty theatre and as you can hear from bagofthumbsā comments, that can be so disheartening.
We love what we do and the more you love us for doing it, the more of it weāll do! Seriously. Ā