ok i have twelve kingdoms thoughts. spoilers for most recent books (Hills of Silver Ruins) ahead.
i just finished Hills of Silver Ruins, a Pitch Black Moon (newest taiki/gyousou story) and i think that while it definitely got too bogged down in geography, politics, etc., i LOVED it. i read all four books in under a week and would have gone faster had i not had to work and live.
i'm so glad risai survived. i loved that it ended on her and kyoshi and kouryou, right where it started. i love that enki and youko argued shoryuu to a standstill about helping tai. so fab.
i love that taiki took 1 look at gyousou and fucking turned right back into a kirin. whoever said afterward that "oh he hid from us that he'd recovered! how smart"---i FULLY believe he didn't realize he could do that lol. it probably surprised him too. his bond with gyousou is just that powerful.
on a serious note...it's been a long time since i read most of the other books. I did reread the risai-goes-to-kei book this week as well, but the rest are more than 10 years into the fog of memory for me, if not 15-20. That said--I was surprised to see raisai and shikirei talking about sexism in the army, as my understanding of the universe was kind of that sexism wasn't really a thing (idk, due to the riboku thing?). in retrospect, i also noted the multiple implications of rape (ukou..... do not rip) that were discussed when villages got ransacked, always to the women. so CLEARLY there is violence and sexism directed at women in this universe. bc i haven't read the other books in so long, i wonder if i just missed it before? or whether this is a product of the author writing over the course of so many years and changing her mind about what should be mentioned?
i was also very surprised by the inclusion of the queen mother of the west, ie a literal god, when to my memory we'd never seen that before? there was a lot of talking-up of gyokuyou as ~oooh the closest we get to heaven, who knows who's pulling the strings~ and then WHAM later in the book (1 book later? idr) risai (who has, mind you, spent an entire book saying that god doesn't exist) is confronted with a goddess. that was all very strange.
i am fascinated by both rousan and taiki. i don't understand rousan. i appreciate her and also hate her, and her motivations were never entirely clear. like, taiki at the end was certain she had protected him, but unequivocally, she was the one who gave asen the jisen???? and the other youma??? SHE enabled him to do all of this. what does taiki mean she's not against them!!! sure, she talked a big talk the whole time about a sort of neutrality, and was clearly judgmental of asen, but...she did that. like, come on. 1 yari does not a coup solve.
on taiki's count...like, it is incredible that he could push through and bow his head to asen. i LOVE that for his character. he IS a monster. and there's been hints here and there that black kirin/kokki DO have extra special abilities, so why not that? (the tears of blood....BABE....) and yet at the same time i feel that that has gone against a completely concrete piece of worldbuilding: namely, kirin cannot bow to anyone but their emperor. it is literally a plot point in taiki's first book.
so, on the one hand, i love the story this tells about him and his desperation and how fucked-up he is. and he DID get hit with the esui after killing that guard! so there's some kind of consequence. but....he shouldn't have been able to bow at all. i suppose it's just an unwritten, nobody-tried-that-hard-before sort of rule, but it does slightly rub me the wrong way.
back to risai. love love love. (except for that bit where she was railing against the universe, that got really old quick???) i love that none of this could have happened without her. SHE is the reason tai can be saved. she went to kei fully intending to trick youko to her death, almost immediately pulled back, and made the rescue happen anyway.
all of the backstories about the different temples, regiments, retainers, etc. i ended up soooort of skimming (i guess i read it without comprehension, which is nearly the same thing) so i really think that could have used some editing. FASCINATING how they kept going toward and away from kan'you mountain.
FASCINATING how gyousou fucking got himself free right as everyone starting looking for him. what he said about heavenly providence giving him the black suugu has to be the case.
someone's post i read the other day theorized that heaven itself had made asen start a coup because gyousou was running damn close to losing the Way (and so quickly), so i went into the last few books with that in mind, and i am not opposed to that reading of the situation. i mean, asen obviously had his weird complex about it all and fully could have intended on the coup anyway--and had access to merceneries and rousan etc--but the writing of it DOES seem to indicate that gyousou was going too hard, too fast, AND he was described post-mountain to have found some sort of inner peace. soooo. (also, like. how did that father know to send offerings into the mountain....)
anyway. i will be thinking about these books for a while. i wish there was more fic for 12k (hoping that the seven seas translations drum up more of a fandom!). i really think that taiki and gyousou have a fascinating relationship and that deserves to be explored. taiki is surely both standoffish and codependent simultaneously. gyousou knows intimately, has always known, that taiki is what makes him emperor. he owes everything to taiki. the people of tai may be his reason for living but taiki is the reason he's alive (in more ways than one). he knows how to lead, but taiki has a better grasp on the politics at this point. taiki is unhinged and recovering and monstrous, he killed a man, all for gyousou, and yet if gyousou died taiki would have to shift right on to a new emperor and devote himself fully to them. gyousou needs taiki much more deeply than taiki needs him. they are each other's reason for existence and yet they've spent 6 months together ever and taiki was a child at the time.