Poker - My Story (Post 1)
"Poker"
The word seems to make Christians shudder.
Poker player has become synonymous with the term sinner.
Many think it is a game from the devil, and pure evil.
I’ve been doing quite a bit of reflection over the past few years on if I, as a Christian, can play poker. It is something that I love and yet playing has occasionally left me with feelings of guilt, like I'm hiding some dirty dark secret that I would not want anyone to find out.
Can Christians play poker? Can we shuffle up-and-deal and still follow Christ? Is playing disobeying God? Is it a sin? What does the Bible say?
Over the years I have heard many different opinions, with many on both sides presenting arguments that have been devoid of much thought, research, or biblical understanding. I decided I wanted to look into it myself, and I would write about what I found. Over the next few posts I will be looking at the “top arguments” others have given me as to why poker and Christianity are like oil and water; they cannot mix. The three that stand out and come up often are:
1. Poker is gambling and Christians shouldn’t gamble as it is a sin.
2. Poker leads to a love of money and that can become an idol.
3. Poker involves some deception and you are making your money off of someone else.
First, Let me tell you my poker story.
I was first introduced to poker in 2003, learning the game from watching poker on TV. I, like many, was starstruck watching the amateur poker player Chris Moneymaker win the World Series Of Poker. Soon after witnessing Moneymaker take down the WSOP full of pros I started playing online for play money, just to learn the game. My first real poker experience didn’t come until some friends from high school invited me to play in their home game. I easily justified the $10 game as it was cheaper than a movie ticket and my friends and I actually got to spend time together talking. That and there was the chance of winning some money. I knew the odds from playing online and quickly picked up playing in real life with my friends.
I didn’t really play much throughout my first few university years, just the occasional home game with the same high school friends. I was too busy to play regularly as I was on the varsity swimming team. It wasn’t until I attended bible college that I started playing more. Yes, bible college.
Bible College Poker
In the first year of my undergrad I had a friend named Joe. Joe was the rebel in our dorm and he loved to play poker. He would often win our $5 dorm games that we had on the weekends after curfew. During second semester reading week Joe asked me if I would like to go to the casino in Regina with him. I told him I didn’t have any money and I didn’t think I was good enough to play in a real casino. He then clued me in on why he was asking: since he was from France he wasn’t able to drive in Canada, so he needed someone to drive him to the casino or he couldn’t go. He then offered me a deal I couldn’t turn down: he would give me $100 to play, if I lost it was no big deal, but if I won I kept all the profit. Nervous as a virgin on their wedding night, I sat down at that table for the first time dreaming of what playing at a real casino would be like. In my mind I was playing in the world series of poker and this free roll of $100 was a million dollars. I shook with every bet and didn't understand the casino rules, having only played in house games. But I walked away that night with over $600, pocketing $500 after I gave Joe his money back. He asked if I would like to come back the next night. It was reading week and I had nothing else to do, and I had just made an easy $500 in one night, so of course I wanted to return. We drove to Regina every night that week. I made just under $3000, not bad for one week worth of work.
I was hooked. I jumped at any chance to drive Joe to the Casino to play. We would drive the hour trip to Regina talking about poker, play from 7pm-4am, and then discuss poker strategy on the hour trip back. We were honing our skills, constantly learning and expanding our poker experience and knowledge, and I was a quick learner. The best, and probably most addictive part about it was that it was easy money for us. By the end of the semester we had found a few others who wanted to come with us. We now had 5 or 6 of us that would frequent the casino in Regina to play poker; a secret bible college poker team.
That summer I was living in Edmonton and I went to the casino there as often as I could. I was working in a restaurant by day, and then working the tables by night. My $22/hour full time position at the restaurant was still making me less than what I was making playing cards. I had no friends in Edmonton, the people I worked with were heavy into drugs and the party scene which I wanted to avoid, and I didn’t want to sit in my room by myself when I wasn’t working at the restaurant. This lead to a perfect storm where I would fill my hours at the tables in the company of strangers, and I once again was making a lot of money doing it. Soon I became a regular at the casino, and that company of strangers started to become acquaintances and eventually friends as I got to know the players and the staff.
My second year of bible college had much less poker at the casino, with only a couple of visits throughout the year. Joe had moved back to France, I had a much busier semester, and I was starting to wrestle with feelings of guilt for playing poker (even if it was paying my tuition). My love of the game was satisfied by joining a league that was made up of other students, professors, and staff of the college. It was a fun league where we didn’t play for money, just wanting to get together and play for the love of the game. Almost everyone called it “men’s fellowship” as if poker, even poker for fun and not money, was a dirty word. This was my also my first year seriously playing online poker to make some money, turning a $200 online deposit into thousands. It wasn’t that I was playing every night, but I played well and ran even better when I was sitting at the virtual felt. This was my most successful year of poker playing, winning a few big tournaments online, some that carried a few 4 and 5 figure payouts.
Graduating year I moved out of dorms into a house with some friends. This gave me a lot more freedom so I didn’t have to “sneak” around as much to the casino. Once again I had a heavy course load, but I found some friends who wanted to visit the casino so I was going every second or third week with them. I also played online here and there, but not very often. Even the day of my graduation, after the celebration with my family and friends, I went to the casino to celebrate and was there from around 11pm until 4am when the casino floor closed.
My Biggest Hand
After graduation I worked at a church in Lethbridge. This was the year of Black Friday: On April 15, Full Tilt Poker, the online site that I used, was shut down with all accounts frozen, effectively killing my online poker activity. I did join a group of men from the local baptist church who liked to play a $20 game, with $10 of it sponsoring a compassion child, and the other $10 going into the prize pot. This is a format that I hope to repeat in the future, hoping that wherever I settle I can find some friends who would like to do this. Back to Lethbridge though...
I didn’t have much time to play poker throughout the year, only playing in Calgary twice throughout my entire time in Alberta. Interesting enough it was there that I played my biggest, and probably one of my most memorable pots. It was right after a Flames game so there were many “loose” players there that night who were just looking for a fun night out. It would be an understatement to say the game wasn’t difficult to crack. I bought in for $200 at a $1/$2 table and built my stack up to about $650 over a few hours. Then THE hand happened. I had QQ, limping in first position. 4th position raised to $12, 4 callers, so I raised to $42 to try to limit who would see a flop. Unfortunately everyone called. I was just hoping to avoid seeing an Ace or King on the flop, but my dream flop hits: Qc, 7s, 3d. I had the nuts and the pot was already over $200! I checked as I was sure the other players who were playing extremely aggressive would do the betting for me. The original raiser in 4th position bets $50. Call. Call. Fold. Raise to $150 by the Big Blind. I didn’t want to scare them out so I just called the $150, but it didn’t matter as 4th position went all in for $300. 5th position called for his remaining $230 and the Big Blind re-shoved for $550. I immediately called, wondering what they could possibly have when I had such a dominant hand. 4th position had Q-10, so he was drawing dead to me. 5th position had 4-6off, drawing to a 5, a 4 outer. The Big Blind had 7c10c, middle pair. I was 82% chance to take down the entire pot of over $2000 and a 96% chance to win a $1500 pot if the 5 did come (and I didn’t hit a redraw to a full house). The turn: Jc. The river: 2c. The 4% hand went runner runner flush on me. I sat back in my chair dumbfounded by what had just happened. It will be a hand that I NEVER forget. I still ended the night walking away with $350 and though $150 profit is great, it’s nothing compared to what could have been!
Toronto
Since moving to Toronto to do my masters I haven’t played much poker. This is simply due to the fact that, surprisingly considering how every city out west has one, there aren’t any casinos in Canada’s largest city. I have visited Casino Niagara, Caesars in Windsor, and OLG in Sarnia, but I can count on my fingers how often I’ve played over the past 3 years.
At this point I’d also like to clarify that I don't win every time I go to the casino, though I have turned a profit more often then not. I play within a system of bringing no more than $400 with me to the casino (2x$150 and 1x$100 buy ins), only ever losing all of that money a couple of times. I also have rules to walk away from the table if I’m ever up too much where it is affecting my playing, or if I lose my edge at the table (other players tighten up, or I start playing poorly from something like sleep exhaustion). It's important to keep to your rules and have a system, whatever it might be, so that you don't have one bad night and blow all the profit from other trips.
I have made quite a bit playing poker throughout the years, even through all the variance that poker has. If I were to sell everything I own and add that to all the money I currently have, and then go out and lose it at the poker table, there’s still no way that I would be in the red. I will never be a losing poker player. That is not an ego trip, but confidence that I have skills in the game (I know I’m nowhere near the best player out there, or even the best player i know), a good system (that took me years to create), and have made and spent much more than I could imagine losing.
Poker is a game I love. It involves some of my favourite things: understanding people, math, game strategy, pattern recognition, and puzzle problem solving. It is a people game more than anything else, and it is also much more of a game of skill than people realize (I will touch on that in another post).
I understand that many who understand the game and who play poker will understand the following posts and my arguments, probably having wrestled with some of this debate themselves. If you love the game I would love to hear from you. If you do not love the game and disagree with all that I will say, I also welcome you into discussion. I know there will be many who won’t even bother to read my thoughts and will choose to remain ignorant, blindly sticking to a traditional mindset that playing cards is evil (you and my grandmother would get along). All I ask if you take this journey with me to look at poker without bias and with an open mind. I’m wrestling through this in search of the truth. I think that simply because something has traditionally been “condemned” by the church, does not mean it is biblical (the fact you can read that bible in English is proof of this as at one point the church fought the bible being translated so the common person could read it). That is where I will be looking for evidence for the truth to the matter: I believe it should be found in the bible, not in people.
Perhaps my argument and line of thought will be 7-2 off-suit and not the pocket aces like I imagine. I am convinced of my stance and comfortable with my thoughts on this, but please know that I do have my hesitations and doubts that I will address. Lets journey this together and play this out, it should be a fun game either way. Shuffle up and deal.