I wish this wasn’t a normal thing to say, no sexual content was literally enough :/
[ID: A screenshot that says: 8. Art Fight does not allow certain harmful paraphilias, such as incest, pedophilia, necrophilia, bestiality, etc, to be depicted, discussed, or requested anywhere on site.
a. Depictions of characters younger than 18 years old in sexualized situations are not permitted. This includes characters who are physically and/or psychologically under 18.
b. Depictions of feral (non-anthropomorphized animal) characters in sexualized situations are not permitted, regardless of sapience. /End ID]
This is paramisia and there's so much wrong with it.
1- "Harmful paraphilias" there is no such thing as a paraphilia that is inherently harmful. Thoughts/feelings =/= harmful action.
There are *harm paraphilias* (as in, being attracted to inflicting harm or being harmed), but I know that's not what they're talking about. What they're talking about is paraphilias that they think are "yucky."
There are also paraphilias that cause distress, but again, that's not what they're talking about. Any paraphilia can be disordered, and thus, any paraphilia can cause distress. For example, a foot fetishist could have obsessive compulsive thoughts about feet, and that would make their paraphilia disordered. Does that make podophilia (foot fetishes/kinks), on their own, harmful? No. This same logic applies to literally any other paraphilia, even the ones you find "distasteful."
2- "Bestiality" is not a paraphilia. Zoophilia is a paraphilia. Bestiality is the act of sexually abusing an animal, zoophilia is having attraction/arousal to an animal. Beastiality is a harmful action, zoophilia is thoughts/feelings.
3- I disagree with saying "no sexual content" being enough, because paraphilias can be nonsexual (ie; romantic, queerplatonic, alterous, etc.) Instead, they could have literally just said "we do not allow depictions of ageplay, minor x adult, non-anthro animal x human, corpse desecration, or incest."
By saying you (general you) "don't allow certain paraphilias", you make it unclear if you're saying that you don't want potentially sensitive artwork, or if you're saying "we don't want these paraphiles themselves to be involved."
You sound like you're saying "hey, if you YOURSELF are a pedophile, zoophile, necrophile, or incestophile, we don't want you involved, even if you are drawing things completely unrelated to your attraction/arousal. You don't deserve to be here because you have the Evil Brain and we don't want you around the Pure Brained people."