Bob Wachterâs AI hype grand rounds.
Bob Wachter boosting AI hype and the AI bubble via promoting it for healthcare was so not surprising. In light of a new op-ed in The Nation bashing Bob Wachter over his NYTimes piece promoting AI back in January, hereâs what I wrote at the time.
Doctor Bob Wachter, pandemic minimizer, now AI booster doing PR for shoddy tech. Who couldâve predicted this? Doctor Bob Wachter is now going on podcasts promoting AI in healthcare as a way to fix the broken American healthcare system with AI slop. Chloe Humbert Feb 08, 2026
In January, for instance, The New York Times ran an op-ed with the headline âStop Worrying, and Let AI Save Your Life.â The author, Dr. Bob Wachter, is the chair of the department of medicine at the University of CaliforniaâSan Francisco medical school and a proponent of AIâs use in healthcare. In the piece, Wachter touted AI as a way to fix the expensive inefficiencies of the American medical system, which he described as âin desperate need of transformation.â He will not be the last person to make such arguments.
As doctors who care for many people from marginalized communities, we find it difficult to be so bullish on AIâand not just because the quality and safety of AI technology is nowhere near guaranteed. We are worried that magical thinking about AI as a path toward real âtransformationâ in healthcare, as Dr. Wachter suggests, will distract us from the current economic crisis that is crushing our patients. Far from its being a new chapter in how we deliver care, we fear that healthcare will become even more financialized as our systems become more deeply entangled with the AI bubble and the speculative investments that accompany it.
If youâve paid attention to the covid minimizers youâll be very familiar with Bob Wachterâs clownish but dangerous antics in the PR space. But if not, or if you want a walk down memory lane, my piece gives a quick summary of all the stupid things he got up to promoting covid carelessness.
And hereâs an earlier essay on what I think of AI in healthcare:
Hallucinating chatbot healthcare tech tools hopped up on medical conference hype. What could possibly go wrong? AI hype is so normalized that of course tech tycoons and private equity think that healthcare should run on hype filled apps and downsizing staff. Chloe Humbert Aug 04, 2024 It was also noted that unlike IBMâs Watson which was a tool based on curated medical records, that this new AI healthcare worker replacement tool reportedly ânot only pulls from published, peer-reviewed medical journals and textbooks but also will be able to integrate real-time information from global health databases, ongoing clinical trials and medical conferences.â This alone makes this AI in non-compliance with any kind of healthcare regulations anywhere. Using this software in a healthcare setting this way would be a clear cut violation of medical safety regulations of various types. Itâs the very epitome of bad science, using research results or data thatâs not been reproduced or maybe not even yet peer reviewed. Just chucking unverified information into the mix and using it to make life and death critical medical decisions flies in the face of medical ethics. I have a hard time understanding how a medical doctor could've written about this and not pointed that out.
And hereâs podcast (audio with a transcript) where I tell some personal stories including a couple about AI in healthcare.
Probable AI error anecdotes. Donât Wait For Everybody - Episode 039 Chloe Humbert May 22, 2026
One anecdote is where I was told that AI in the Epic system made up a whole doctors appointment that never happened with all the necessary summaries and documentation to have my health insurance pay the bill and I only found out because I was issued a copay and knew the visit never took place. Now imagine if erroneous or incorrect information from that had been used in medical decisions for me, because this isnât just about the economic waste of potential mass health insurance fraud by chatbot, lives are on the line.