A lot has already been said about how Teach manages to beat Rodgers during the keelhauling, but what I noticed this rewatch is that Jack Rackham also manages to beat him.
After Teach survives the first go around the ship, Rodgers says "again" quietly, with self assurance. He's disappointed that teach survived one go, but is clearly not surprised, sending a man under the ship a second time is clearly not uncharted territory for him.
And as he orders this he glances around the ship and is caught and pauses when he sees Jack's look.
This look:
And what catches him completely off guard is that there is no fear here. Jack has clearly figured out what the plan is, he almost certainly knows he is next, as he keeps almost this exact look when he is taken after Teach is assumed dead.
What this look is , is disgust. Jack Rackham, Pirate Captain and enemy to all mankind, is looking down on Woodes Rodger, because this show of force is so grotesque. Rackham meets Rodger's eyes, doesn't break away, and this is what rattles him.
The next time Rodger's orders "again", he shouts it, because being judged by Rackham is getting to him, and this fear is what makes him shoot Blackbeard after the third go. Blackbeard endures this torture and that is impressive to the point of being awe inspiring yes, but it is Rodger's inability to weather the judgement and disdain of a pirate that makes him lose.






















