hello non-transfem tumblr user! in this game show, i will be presenting a few scenarios that you may stumble across during your time online (not just on tumblr either). these scenarios pertain to how you should treat transfems online.
in front of you is a trans woman who you just referred to with "they/them" pronouns. she is visibly upset and angry with you, as her pronouns are at the top of her bio and pinned post, and her friends are defensive on her behalf as this is an extremely common occurrence to her. do you:
A) say that you were just using gender neutral pronouns because you can never be sure
B) say that you don't have time to check people's pronouns on a social media platform that has no time limit
C) say she should be grateful that you aren't a terf and therefore you didn't use he/him
D) call her dramatic and tell her she's just cherry-picking your points, and that that she and her friends are just virtue signaling for woke points
E) say "oh i'm sorry," and correct yourself
if you selected any answer besides E, then the floor will promptly open up underneath you and drop you into straight down to the earth's core where you will be burned to a crisp. though you may not have malicious intent in using they/them pronouns to refer to a stranger, this does not mitigate the reality that you degendered a trans woman in a world where even other trans people try to deny them womanhood.
if you DID select e, then congratulations (and i hope you do this in reality, not just when the scenario is presented to you in a neat and organized way)! you can move onto the next scenario!
you are scrolling through your dashboard when you see a blogger you follow (BYF) in a heated argument with a trans girl about whether dogs or cats are better. the trans girl made a post that the BYF interpreted as hating dogs despite it clearly not being intended as such. during this argument, the BYF says, "dude shut the fuck up." the trans girl tells the BYF not to call her "dude" and to leave her alone. you feel the need to chime in on the situation with your two cents. your solution is to:
A) tell the tgirl that "dude" is a gender neutral term
B) ignore the misgendering entirely and just focus on the original argument about dogs and cats
C) ask how the BYF was supposed to know that the tgirl didn't want to be called dude.
D) tell the tgirl to go outside and talk to real people who don't care about this
F) tell the BYF to not misgender her and stop harassing her. if BYF chooses to do any of the above answers, block and report.
if you selected any answer besides F, the floor will now open up! "dude" is not a gender neutral term. it is quite explicitly used to mean "man." the misconception that "dude" is gender neutral comes from the fact that we live in a world centered around manhood.
it is your responsibility to not only avoid growing defensive when you or people you like/admire when trans women point out misgendering/degendering in conversations, but to actively call out and deplatform transmisogyny in your spaces. if you want to be an ally, you need to be able to do this. you need to be able to recognize your own capacity for transmisogyny as well. if it had been you who had said that instead of BYF, you still need to be able to apologize and evaluate the language that you use in your day-to-day life.
you came across a post on your "for you" page that features a trans woman venting about the transmisogyny that she experiences from other trans people. in this post, she mentions that she is tired of tme trans people making excuses for the violence she experience, and says "kill all tmes" in a hyperbolic fashion
A) tell her to stop infighting, that we're all faggots in the eyes of the state, and that she should kiss/fuck the nearest transmasc
B) call it white woman tears
C) make a sideblog to post waterboarded screenshots every time she says something about tme trans people to misconstrue it as her being transphobic to everyone besides transfems
D) reblog her post with a five paragraph rant about how tme/tma are problematic because they ask about your genitals or whatever
E) report her for violent content, and make calls to your followers to mass report her and any new blogs she makes as well
G) recognize that she is a trans girl who has experienced transmisogynistic abuse from people who she should be able to trust. like and reblog the post.
if you picked A, B, C, D, or E, the floor will now open up beneath you. if you picked F, you'll be spared for doing the bare minimum of not harassing or stalking a trans girl, but you will not be allowed to leave the room until you have read and internalized at least 300 pages of transfeminist literature.
if you picked G, then good job on recognizing a trans girl's struggles and uplifting her voice. recognize that even if you did a Good Act Of Allyship in doing so, you are still responsible for unlearning internalized transmisogyny, calling it out in your spaces when you see it, and not expecting transfems to sing your praises in return.
that conclude's this iteration of miss lavender's transmisogyny gameshow! if you didn't get all three answers correct, then spend some time tonight pulling that enormous stick out of your ass and read some transfeminist literature! then come back next time and try again.
and even if you correctly selected all three answers, i want you to go back and read over the other answers i listed. these are just a few of the methods and mantras that non-transmisogynized folks have used to hurt and silence us. it's not just petty online discourse like you might be tempted to dismiss it as. the way you treat trans women online often correlates with how you treat them in real life, or how you would if you don't know any (you should try to fix that if you are in an area that allows for it)!
are you listening to what she has to say? are you boosting her voice? are you recognizing that even if you do do that, she doesn't owe you praise or worship? are you willing to look at your own privilege through the lens of a transfeminist? even if you are a Perfect TME Ally, transfems may be wary of interacting with you. we've had plenty of "allies" treat us as badly as any of the people doing the incorrect answers on this post, we have no way of knowing if you're going to do the same.
keep your eyes, ears, and heart open. watch for transmisogyny and call that shit out. listen to transfems, stand by them even when it gets scary (it's far scarier for them, i promise). and be kind to transfems, always.