Alina's power is really nothing special. She cannot bend reality, cannot manipulate time, cannot raise the dead, cannot even control minds. She is a flashlight. Not even a good one. And what really weirds me out is that the whole premise is built on presumptuous entitlement, and we are supposed to feel bad for her because she was given privileges she never deserved.
"She is the only one whose power can rival the Darkling's!"
Alina presumably requires three amplifiers to unlock her potential.
An average Grisha requires one.
The Darkling requires zero.
This premise itself already tells you that in terms of power she is further removed from the Darkling than any other Grisha. She is not his "natural balance"; she is a desperate wannabe who tries to artificially compensate for what mother nature didn't give her.
"I'm the Sun Summoner, it gets dark when I say it does!"
Don't get me wrong, light powers CAN be interesting. It's just that the narrative is dull and unimaginative and makes Alina's power as unimpressive as possible. She cannot summon underground; she gets weaker during the solar eclipse. She doesn't get to decide when it gets dark, she is a tool, not a source, basically a sun battery rendered useless on a rainy day. It's especially hilarious if we remember that Os Alta, with its white nights and opulent palaces, is obviously based on Saint Petersburg. If Alina needs a clear sunny day for her powers to work properly, there would be no use for her in Saint Petersburg for about 300 days a year.
"The Darkling only needs her power to rule the world!"
Pray tell, how does one go about ruling the world by owning one faulty lightbulb? I have about ten in my house, can I apply for the Galaxy Emperor or something?
"She didn't want to be a saint!"
She shouldn't have been. You are telling me that people who historically persecuted and annihilated anyone with weird magical power worship Alina… because she has weird magical powers? Riiight. Especially considering that she was already proclaimed a saint before she even did anything. She didn't heal the sick, didn't feed a starving village, and didn't even turn any water into wine, for god's sake. If sainthood in their religion comes so easily, it is just an empty title not worth a sparrow's fart, and acting all impressed about her "struggling with unwanted sainthood" is laughable.
"She didn't want to be queen!"
Once again, she shouldn't even be presented with such an option. A lowly orphan is entitled to the throne because light shines out of her ass? Don't make me laugh. She would be considered a weapon at best and maybe given a nice pension after she was relieved of her duties. Maybe.
"She didn't want to be a general, but she knew she had to do it!"
Nope, she did not in fact have to do it. Even if she were a decent Sun Summoner and could plausibly take down the Darkling, that still wouldn't make her suitable for a leadership position. It's an absolutely different set of skills, and she doesn't possess a single one of them. She could be a useful asset at best under someone else's command. To make it even more absurd, when she tries to hijack the second, Grisha plainly tell her they don't want her as their leader. Any person who truly doesn't want power would immediately use that as their way out of unwanted responsibilities, but no, the bitch had to threaten them and violently force them to accept her appointment. There was literally no reason for her not to provide her services under someone's more reasonable command. But then she wouldn't have that little power trip to stroke her bruised ego.
There is nothing special about her, except maybe for her glaring, mind-numbing, shocking stupidity. She was given everything on a silver platter and still managed to fail.














