If we're doing "black people talk about how that complicates gender" then can I just be anonymously angry with this half formed take (because this is a vent not a thesis) about how the way a certain brand of online discourse around men (any of them; even though im cis i see this get targeted at black trans men too) is basically just Reagan-Bush era republican talking points about "urban crime" (read: "it's black people's fault") in the 80s?
Like everything from "one of the good ones" (which i have had applied to me to my face in both racial and gendered contexts, and it feels like just as much a betrayal regardless of which) to the justifications for why every man is suspect including citing crime statistics (alongside a mealy mouthed implication that this is due to a stain on men's souls rather than learned behavior that is changeable if we change the environment), and don't get me started on that racist ass poison skittle analogy.
It's just a pathway to essentialism. It's a smokescreen for not only anti masculinity but also unvarnished transphobia that gets a free pass because it relies on denying that trans men are men. It's conservatism wearing a progressive skin suit.
Yeah, everything about the way people speak about the crime rate of men, especially black men (who are statistically arrested more than any other race [link]) all boils down to gender essentialism.
There is a lot of evidence that woman criminals are underreported because women are supposedly a "pure gender who can do no wrong", and also because it's deemed "shameful" to admit you're the victim of a woman (for people socially imposed as male its because of toxic masculinity and the shame of being "weaker" than a woman, for people socially imposed as female its because of sapphophobia and the unserious way people treat queer SA.)
All of this factors into men - especially black men - having such a high crime rating, because women are allowed to get away with crime far more than men are. (And don't get me started on the statistics of disabled men being arrested.)