#mhaanalysis

In-Depth Analysis of the Nomu Species, Prototypes, and Gigantomachia

Introduction

The Nomu, also known as Artificial Humans, are a pivotal antagonistic force in the My Hero Academia franchise. Created by Dr. Kyudai Garaki and All For One, these bio-engineered beings are deceased humans modified to possess multiple Quirks, rendering them powerful, mindless super-soldiers for the League of Villains and later the Paranormal Liberation Front. This analysis explores the Nomu species, their various tiers, prototypes, and the unique case of Gigantomachia, a kaiju-like villain with distinct characteristics.

Nomu Species Overview

Nomu are created from human corpses, subjected to extensive genetic modification to enhance physical capabilities and implant multiple Quirks. The process erases higher brain functions, leaving most Nomu as obedient, mindless entities that require direct orders to act. Their grotesque appearance, often featuring exposed brains and unnatural skin colors (e.g., blue, yellow, black), reflects their transformation into something barely human. The Nomu serve various roles, from expendable foot soldiers to strategic game-changers in battles, with their power scaling based on their tier and Quirks.

Creation Process

Source Material: Nomu are derived from deceased humans, with some cases (e.g., Kurogiri) indicating that corpses are as viable as living subjects.

Quirk Implantation: All For One provides multiple Quirks, which are surgically integrated by Dr. Garaki. Without All For One, Garaki can still extract and duplicate Quirks, though the process is less efficient and may yield weaker results.

Modification: The transformation involves drastic physical alterations, resulting in exposed brains, jumbled internal structures, and enhanced physical attributes. The process is shrouded in mystery, with the gruesome details left ambiguous, enhancing their horror.

Purpose: Nomu are designed as tools for the League’s goals, ranging from mass destruction to targeted missions. High-End Nomu retain some personality and intelligence, tailored for specific violent tasks.

Tiers of Nomu

Nomu are categorized into five tiers based on their strength, Quirk count, and intelligence:

Lower-Tier Nomu:

Characteristics: Light-colored skin, minimal Quirks (1-2), and enhanced physical strength. They require voice commands to act and are the weakest tier, yet capable of overpowering minor Pro Heroes.

Role: Expendable foot soldiers used for overwhelming numbers or distraction.

Example Quirks: Absorption and Release, Tongue Web, Muscle Augmentation.

Notable Instances: The white-skinned Hosu Nomu with four eyes, used during the Vs. Hero Killer Arc to wreak havoc in Hosu City.

Middle-Tier Nomu:

Characteristics: More vibrant skin colors, increased power, and additional Quirks compared to Lower-Tier. They still lack significant intelligence.

Role: Stronger support units, capable of more complex tasks but still reliant on orders.

Example Quirks: Unnamed Flying Quirk, Tool Arms.

Notable Instances: The winged Hosu Nomu with a mask-like face, involved in capturing Izuku before being killed by Stain.

Upper-Tier Nomu:

Characteristics: Black skin, Super Regeneration Quirk, and strength equivalent to ten average humans. They can contend with top Pro Heroes.

Role: Heavy hitters in critical battles, often deployed to counter strong opponents.

Example Quirks: Super Regeneration, Shock Absorption.

Notable Instances: The USJ Nomu, designed to counter All Might, and the black-skinned Hosu Nomu, killed by Endeavor’s fire.

Near High-End Nomu:

Characteristics: Incomplete High-End Nomu with phenomenal strength and speed comparable to High-Ends but lacking intelligence. They were rushed into deployment, limiting their enhancements.

Role: Mass-produced for All For One’s final conquests, overwhelming through numbers and raw power.

Example Quirks: Wing, Burst, Bone Spikes, Super Spit.

Notable Instances: Deployed during the Final War Arc to support Shigaraki, with some escaping to raid Tartarus.

High-End Nomu:

Characteristics: The pinnacle of Nomu creation, with black skin, multiple Quirks (including Super Regeneration), and retained intelligence/personality. They require stabilization time post-activation to reach full potential.

Role: Strategic assets capable of independent thought and devastating combat prowess, used to shift battle tides.

Example Quirks: Super Regeneration, Liquification, Rupture, Spatial Distortion, Muscle Augmentation.

Notable Instances: Hood, Woman, Eleph, Robot, Chubs, and Ribby, deployed during the Jaku Hospital raid and Pro Hero Arc.

Powers and Abilities

Nomu exhibit a range of abilities, primarily derived from their implanted Quirks and enhanced physicality:

Common Quirks:

Super Regeneration: Allows rapid healing, even from near-total destruction, though it fails if the brain is incinerated (e.g., by Endeavor’s Hellfire).

Muscle Augmentation: Enhances physical strength, seen in Nomu like Hood and the Four-Eyed Hosu Nomu.

Shock Absorption: Absorbs impact up to a limit, as seen in the USJ Nomu.

Warping: Enables teleportation, used by utility Nomu like Johnny and Kurogiri.

Physical Enhancements: Immense strength, durability, speed, reflexes, stamina, and endurance make Nomu formidable. High-End Nomu like Hood combine these with tactical intelligence.

Weaknesses:

Brain Vulnerability: Destroying the brain is the only reliable way to kill a Nomu, as their regeneration cannot recover from this.

Command Dependency: Lower and Middle-Tier Nomu require orders, rendering them catatonic without guidance.

Stabilization Time: High-End Nomu are weaker if deployed prematurely, as seen during the Jaku Hospital raid.

Fire-Based Attacks: Endeavor’s Hellfire can overcome regeneration by reducing Nomu to ashes.

Prototypes and Key Individuals

Kurogiri

Background: Created from the corpse of Oboro Shirakumo, a former U.A. student and friend of Aizawa and Yamada. His Cloud Quirk was combined with others to form the Warp Gate Quirk.

Role: A unique Nomu designed as a loyal caretaker for Tomura Shigaraki, capable of speech and limited free thought. Unlike other Nomu, he retains personality traits (e.g., caring nature) from his human life.

Quirk: Warp Gate allows him to create portals from his foggy body, crucial for League logistics. It’s more versatile than All For One’s Glop Warp but requires his physical presence and knowledge of locations.

Key Moments:

Acts as Shigaraki’s guardian, managing his needs and preventing capture.

Defies All For One’s orders during the Final War Arc to protect Shigaraki, teleporting heroes to aid Deku and sacrificing himself to intercept an attack.

His brief re-emergence as Oboro during interrogation provides critical information about Garaki’s hospital.

Significance: Kurogiri is a prototype for intelligent Nomu, showcasing Garaki’s early success in retaining personality while programming loyalty. His eventual rebellion highlights the limits of Nomu programming when loyalty conflicts with core directives.

USJ Nomu

Background: The first Nomu introduced, designed to counter All Might as the “Anti-Symbol of Peace.” Originally a petty thug, he was modified with four extra Quirks.

Quirks: Shock Absorption, Super Regeneration, and immense physical strength.

Role: A brute force weapon, deployed during the USJ Arc to attack Class 1-A and All Might.

Key Moments:

Nearly kills Aizawa and overpowers students, showcasing its threat level.

Defeated by All Might overloading its Shock Absorption with rapid punches, leading to its arrest.

Significance: A prototype for raw power, the USJ Nomu’s limitations (e.g., inability to act without orders) informed later Nomu designs, reducing excessive modifications to preserve functionality.

Hood

Background: One of the earliest High-End Nomu, formerly a cage fighter, retaining bloodthirsty tendencies and intelligence.

Quirks: Super Regeneration, Muscle Augmentation, Shapeshifting Arm, Shoulder Jet, Storage.

Role: A test subject for Dabi during the Pro Hero Arc, deployed to fight Endeavor and Hawks in Fukuoka.

Key Moments:

Overpowers Endeavor, causing significant destruction and scarring the hero.

Uses Storage Quirk to deploy nine weaker Nomu, showcasing tactical versatility.

Killed by Endeavor’s Hellfire after Hawks’ assistance, highlighting the brain destruction weakness.

Significance: Hood represents a successful High-End prototype, balancing intelligence with overwhelming power. His rushed deployment revealed stabilization issues, a flaw addressed in later High-Ends.

Johnny and Mocha

Background: Small, utility-focused Nomu with minimal combat ability, designed for support roles.

Quirks:

Johnny: Warping, identical to All For One’s teleportation Quirk.

Mocha: Double, sampled from Twice, used to create duplicates.

Role: Facilitate League operations, with Johnny transporting members and Mocha aiding Garaki’s subterfuge.

Key Moments:

Johnny is crushed by Mirko during the Jaku Hospital raid.

Mocha sacrifices itself to protect Garaki, demonstrating unexpected initiative for a Lower-Tier Nomu.

Significance: These Nomu highlight Garaki’s versatility in creating specialized, non-combat variants, serving as early experiments in Quirk utility.

Gigantomachia

Overview

Gigantomachia is a unique entity within the League, distinct from typical Nomu due to his size, intelligence, and loyalty-driven Quirks. A kaiju-like villain, he served as All For One’s bodyguard before being assigned to Shigaraki.

Characteristics

Appearance: A gargantuan humanoid with rocky skin, spikes, and a lantern jaw, resembling a mythical giant or kaiju.

Quirks:

Endurance: Converts morale into physical power, amplifying strength when loyal to his master.

Gigantification: Allows size increase during battle.

Pain Blocker: Nullifies pain, enhancing durability.

Fierce Gains, Dog, Mole, Energy Saver: Enhance strength, tracking, burrowing, and stamina, respectively.

Intelligence: Limited (1/6 per Ultra Analysis Book), akin to a “dim-witted beast,” but capable of speech and basic reasoning. He recognizes betrayal, as seen in his rage against All For One’s abandonment.

Loyalty: Initially exhibits blind obedience to All For One, later transferring to Shigaraki after proving worthiness. His loyalty wanes after being abandoned, leading to rebellion.

Role and Key Moments

Bodyguard: Protected All For One until reassigned as a secret weapon for Shigaraki.

Meta Liberation Army Arc: Turns a losing battle into a massacre, decimating the enemy but endangering the League due to his indiscriminate destruction.

Paranormal Liberation War Arc: Bulldozes through 20 cities to reach Shigaraki, showcasing his unstoppable nature. Sedatives only work when he lacks active orders, highlighting his command dependency.

Final War Arc: Controlled by Shinso’s Quirk to fight for the heroes, leveraging his obedience to voice commands. His rage against All For One’s betrayal persists post-brainwashing, leading to his attack on his former master. Killed by All For One’s lightning attack, splitting him in half.

Impact: His destructive rampages (e.g., terrifying Mina, overwhelming Class 1-A) cement him as “pure dread” incarnate, a physical reminder of the war’s toll.

Significance

Prototype Influence: Gigantomachia’s genome informs Nomu subservience, making him a foundational prototype for their obedience programming. His multiple Quirks and physical enhancements prefigure High-End Nomu designs.

Weaknesses:

Blind Obedience: His need for commands makes him vulnerable to Shinso’s Quirk and containment when orders are absent.

Intelligence: His limited intellect allows manipulation (e.g., by Ashido) and prevents independent strategy.

Betrayal: His loyalty, while immense, has limits, as seen in his turn against All For One.

Comparison to Nomu: Unlike mindless Nomu, Gigantomachia retains some autonomy and emotional capacity (e.g., crying over Shigaraki’s weakness). His kaiju-like scale and unique Quirks set him apart, but his command-driven nature aligns with Lower-Tier Nomu.

Analysis

Evolution of Nomu Design

Early Prototypes: Kurogiri and the USJ Nomu represent initial experiments. Kurogiri prioritizes utility and intelligence, while the USJ Nomu focuses on raw power, revealing flaws like over-modification and command dependency.

Refinement: Hood and later High-Ends address these issues by balancing intelligence with power, though stabilization time remains a hurdle. Near High-Ends sacrifice intelligence for mass production, reflecting strategic shifts in All For One’s plans.

Garaki’s Role: His ability to duplicate Quirks and tweak them (e.g., enhancing Overhaul into Decay) showcases his genius, though limitations without All For One’s direct involvement highlight their partnership’s synergy.

Strategic Importance

Battlefield Impact: Nomu, especially High-End and Gigantomachia, are game-changers. Kurogiri’s Warp Gate shifts battle dynamics, while Gigantomachia’s rampages and High-Ends’ tactical prowess overwhelm heroes.

Psychological Warfare: Their grotesque appearance and relentless nature instill fear, as seen with Mina’s trauma and Class 1-A’s realization of their vulnerability post-USJ.

Countermeasures: Heroes exploit Nomu weaknesses (e.g., brain destruction, command reliance) and develop strategies like Shinso’s brainwashing to turn assets like Gigantomachia against villains.

Ethical and Narrative Implications

Moral Horror: The Nomu’s creation from human corpses, including recognizable individuals like Oboro, underscores All For One’s and Garaki’s amorality. The use of Tsubasa (potentially Garaki’s grandson) adds a personal layer of cruelty.

Redemption Potential: Kurogiri’s partial re-emergence as Oboro and Spinner’s restoration suggest that Nomu programming can be reversed, offering hope for victims but highlighting the tragedy of their transformation.

Narrative Role: Nomu escalate the series’ stakes, transitioning from school-based conflicts to existential threats. Gigantomachia’s dread and the Nomu’s relentless power embody the villains’ growing menace, pushing heroes to their limits.

Conclusion

Fates of the Nomu

The document lists specific Nomu and their statuses:

Kurogiri: Deceased, but with Oboro Shirakumo’s personality briefly re-emerging, leading to restorative research at Central Hospital to potentially reverse the Nomu process.

U.S.J. Nomu: Arrested and imprisoned, later moved to Central Hospital for restorative research.

Winged Nomu, Eyeless Nomu, Hood, Robot, Chubs, Woman, Elep, Ribby, Johnny, Mocha: Deceased.

4-Eyes Nomu, Chainsaw Nomu: Arrested.

Near High-Ends: Mixed fates, with some deceased, some arrested, and others of unknown status. Seven Near High-Ends escaped during the Paranormal Liberation War Arc and aided All For One’s Tartarus breakout, but three were later taken down, leaving four potentially active by the Final War Arc.

High-Ends: Most (e.g., Hood, Robot, Chubs, Woman, Elep, Ribby) were destroyed during the Paranormal Liberation War Arc or earlier. Five High-Ends were activated during the Jaku Hospital Raid, but all were either destroyed or neutralized.

The document also notes that with Doctor Garaki imprisoned and All For One dead, no new Nomu can be engineered. Additionally, restorative research at Central Hospital was used to save Spinner’s mind from deteriorating due to extra Quirks, suggesting a shift toward reversing or mitigating the Nomu process.

Speculation on the Nomu’s Fates

Arrested Nomu (e.g., U.S.J. Nomu, 4-Eyes Nomu, Chainsaw Nomu):

These Nomu, already in custody, are likely subjects of ongoing restorative research at Central Hospital, as mentioned in the Dark Hero Arc. The goal is to understand and potentially reverse the Nomu process, as seen with attempts to free Oboro Shirakumo from Kurogiri. By the series’ end, these Nomu may remain in secure facilities, either as research subjects or in containment if restoration fails. Given the series’ emphasis on redemption and societal rebuilding, scientists and heroes might prioritize restoring their humanity, though success is uncertain due to the complexity of the bio-engineering process. Some, like the U.S.J. Nomu, who were compliant when not under orders, might be kept in stasis or rehabilitated if their original personalities can be recovered.

Speculative Outcome: Partial success in restoring some Nomu’s cognitive functions or personalities, particularly for lower-tier Nomu with less extensive modifications. Those beyond saving would likely remain imprisoned or humanely decommissioned to prevent suffering.

Near High-Ends (Unknown Status):

The four Near High-Ends that escaped during the Tartarus breakout and survived the Final War Arc pose a significant question. The document states that all High-Ends were brought down across the battlefields, but the Near High-Ends’ mixed fates (deceased/arrested/unknown) suggest some may have survived. Without All For One’s Radio Waves Quirk to command them or Garaki to maintain them, these Nomu would likely become directionless. Their lack of independent thought (unlike High-Ends) means they’d either remain dormant, wander aimlessly, or act on residual instincts, potentially causing chaos until neutralized by heroes.

Speculative Outcome: Heroes, possibly led by figures like Best Jeanist or Lemillion, would track down and subdue these rogue Nomu. Given their strength, some might be destroyed in confrontations, while others could be captured for research or containment. The series’ focus on a hopeful future suggests efforts to prevent further destruction, so these Nomu would likely be secured or decommissioned rather than left unchecked.

High-End Nomu:

The document confirms that all active High-Ends (e.g., Hood, Robot, Chubs, Woman, Elep, Ribby) were destroyed by the end of the Paranormal Liberation War Arc or shortly after. The remaining High-Ends in stasis were likely destroyed when Tomura disintegrated parts of Garaki’s laboratory, or they were rendered non-functional without stabilization. Since no new Nomu can be created, any inactive High-Ends would remain non-operational.

Speculative Outcome: No High-End Nomu remain active post-series. Any undiscovered stasis chambers would likely be found and dismantled by heroes or authorities during cleanup operations, ensuring no future threats.

Kurogiri and Restorative Research:

Kurogiri’s case is unique due to Oboro Shirakumo’s partial re-emergence. The restorative research at Central Hospital, combined with the series’ epilogue emphasizing societal recovery, suggests a strong push to save Nomu with recoverable personalities. Kurogiri, as a High-End with advanced cognitive abilities, is a prime candidate for this. The success with Spinner indicates that medical advancements could partially reverse the mental damage caused by Quirk overloading, potentially allowing some Nomu to regain fragments of their former selves.

Speculative Outcome: Kurogiri might be partially restored to Oboro Shirakumo, though not fully, given the extensive modifications. He could live under supervision, possibly aiding heroes with his Warp Gate Quirk as a form of redemption. Other Nomu with less complex transformations might also benefit, but those with severe brain damage (e.g., Lower-Tier Nomu) may only achieve minimal recovery.

Broader Implications:

The My Hero Academia epilogue emphasizes rebuilding society and addressing the root causes of villainy. The Nomu, as victims of horrific experimentation, would likely be treated with compassion in this new era. Heroes and scientists might view them as tragic figures rather than monsters, focusing on ethical research to undo Garaki’s work. The absence of All For One and Garaki ensures no new Nomu will emerge, allowing resources to focus on containment and rehabilitation.

Public sentiment, shaped by figures like Izuku Midoriya, would likely advocate for humane treatment, especially after revelations about Nomu like Kurogiri/Oboro. This could lead to specialized facilities for Nomu, balancing security with attempts at restoration.

Factors Influencing Speculation

No New Nomu: With Garaki imprisoned and All For One dead, the Nomu production line is permanently shut down, limiting their threat to existing units.

Restorative Research: The success with Spinner and the focus on Kurogiri suggest a scientific push to reverse Nomu transformations, though the complexity of High-End and Near High-End Nomu makes full recovery unlikely.

Hero Society’s Evolution: The series ends with a focus on empathy and rehabilitation, as seen with characters like Spinner and Gentle Criminal. This ethos would extend to the Nomu, prioritizing their containment or restoration over destruction unless necessary.

Remaining Threats: The four Near High-Ends of unknown status are the primary lingering threat, but their lack of independent thought and the heroes’ vigilance make it likely they’d be neutralized post-war.

Final Speculative Scenario

All For One (AFO) sought to create powerful vessels—subordinates molded or engineered to serve as hosts, tools, or possible successors to carry on his ambitions. Both Kai Chisaki (Overhaul) and Toya Todoroki (Dabi) were involved in versions of these plans, but both ultimately became failed vessels. Here’s a focused analysis, drawing directly from the detailed file provided.

All For One’s Vessel Strategies

AFO’s core vessel plan was to ensure his legacy and domination would persist, often by manipulating or “raising” gifted individuals to serve his agenda, or—if their Quirks and bodies were suitable—serve as hosts for his own power. This process included both careful psychological grooming and direct Quirk experimentation.

Overhaul (Kai Chisaki)

Background as a Vessel: Raised in an orphanage owned by Kyudai Garaki (AFO’s chief scientist), Chisaki was among children considered as potential hosts for AFO. His destructive perspective on Quirks (believing them to be a disease) and his Overhaul Quirk’s incredible reconstructive and destructive potential marked him as a prime candidate.

AFO’s Direct Intervention: AFO duplicated Overhaul’s Quirk (stripped of its restoration aspect) and gave this copy to Tenko Shimura (later Tomura Shigaraki), which would evolve into Decay. Overhaul himself was manipulated but never became a true vessel, instead pursuing his own plans for power via Eri and Quirk-destroying bullets, showing a dangerous independence.

Failure Reasons: Overhaul’s ideology and trauma isolated him, and he was unable to submit to, or be controlled by, AFO. He prioritized his own plan to restore the Yakuza and monopolize the Quirk market rather than work as AFO’s vessel. Eventually, his defeat, the loss of his arms (and Quirk), and complete psychological breakdown rendered him useless to AFO’s original designs.

Dabi (Toya Todoroki)

Background as a Vessel: Toya was “rescued” after his near-death experience by AFO and Kyudai, who rehabilitated and attempted to groom him into a subordinate. Physically rebuilt and emotionally fragile, Dabi was recognized as having extraordinary potential due to his powerful (and unstable) blue flames.

AFO’s Direct Intervention: Kyudai anticipated Toya would not survive long post-coma, but Dabi’s psychological grudge kept him alive. Despite attempts to brainwash and manipulate him as a weapon/subordinate, Toya rejected their control, insisting no one but his father (Endeavor) could be his guide. He fled, and AFO classed him as a failed project.

Failure Reasons: Dabi ultimately became self-directed, fixated on personal vengeance against Endeavor and the hero system rather than serving anybody’s ambition. His instability, obsession, and disregard for AFO’s actual plans made him impossible to control. He did not care for the broader goals of the League or AFO, only for hurting his family.

Pattern of Failure

Autonomy: Both Overhaul and Dabi had strong, trauma-driven personal agendas which prevented complete subjugation or loyalty to AFO.

Lack of Psychological Hold: AFO’s methods failed to instill sufficient mental control; Overhaul’s grandiosity and Dabi’s obsession led both off-script.

Physical Limitations: Overhaul lost his Quirk and arms; Dabi’s body was fatally incompatible with his Quirk, limiting their long-term viability as vessels.

Conclusion

The implication that the Winged Nomu (one of the three Nomu unleashed during the Hosu City incident in the Vs. Hero Killer Arc) is actually Tsubasa—Katsuki Bakugo's childhood friend and bully of Izuku Midoriya—stems from a combination of visual cues, character connections, and creator hints in My Hero Academia. While the series never explicitly states "Tsubasa was turned into the Winged Nomu" in the main storyline, it's heavily implied through subtext, bonus materials, and later revelations about Nomu creation. This has been treated as canon by the fandom and confirmed via author Kohei Horikoshi's extras, with the connection solidified in manga Chapter 259. Below, I'll break it down step by step, including the evidence, how the transformation likely occurred, and a timeline for when it might have happened.

Key Evidence Supporting the Implication

Physical Similarities and Quirk Match:

Tsubasa's Quirk is an unnamed wing ability that grants him red, draconic wings from his back, allowing flight. He's described as a plump child with a rounded face and nearly shaved brown hair.

The Winged Nomu (pale-yellow in color) has bat-like wings for flight, talons on hands and feet, and a gas mask-like covering over its mouth. While the Nomu's appearance is distorted (as all Nomu are grotesque, brain-exposed modifications), the core Quirk is identical: wings enabling aerial mobility. The Nomu's wings are its primary (and only named) Quirk, suggesting it could be the base ability from its original human form.

During the Hosu incident (Manga Chapters 50-59, Anime Episodes 28-33), the Winged Nomu specifically targets Izuku Midoriya, grabbing him and attempting to fly away with him as a hostage. This selective behavior is unusual for Nomu, who are typically mindless destroyers acting on orders. It hints at residual memories from Tsubasa's past, where he frequently bullied Izuku alongside Bakugo.

Family Connection to Nomu Creation:

Tsubasa is the grandson of "Dr. Tsubasa," the kindly doctor who diagnosed young Izuku as Quirkless in Chapter 1 (Anime Episode 1). This doctor is later revealed to be Kyudai Garaki (also known as Daruma Ujiko), All For One's mad scientist ally responsible for engineering all Nomu.

Garaki's reveal in Chapter 259 confirms his alias as Dr. Tsubasa, showing he's been operating under false identities while running hospitals and orphanages as fronts for his experiments. As Nomu creator, Garaki has access to human subjects (often criminals, the deceased, or the vulnerable), and using his own family member fits his ruthless, unethical character—he's shown no qualms about human experimentation.

Creator's Hint in Bonus Materials:

The strongest implication comes from Horikoshi's omake (bonus sketch/commentary) in My Hero Academia Volume 7. Here, the author draws Dr. Tsubasa (Garaki) alongside his unnamed grandson, who has wings identical to Tsubasa's from the flashbacks. The sketch is juxtaposed with Nomu designs, heavily suggesting the boy's fate. This is where the theory originated and was essentially "confirmed" by the creator without spoiling the main plot.

Horikoshi often uses omakes for subtle lore drops, and this one ties directly to the Hosu Nomu arc covered in that volume.

Nomu Lore and Behavioral Clues:

Nomu are bio-engineered weapons created by Garaki using All For One's Quirk-duplication tech. They start as human bases (often corpses or living subjects), which are surgically altered, infused with multiple Quirks, and have their brains reprogrammed for obedience and aggression. Lower-tier Nomu like the Winged one retain some base traits but lack higher intelligence.

The Winged Nomu's death (paralyzed and killed by Stain's Bloodcurdle Quirk after grabbing Izuku) prevents any further exploration, but its focus on Izuku implies lingering subconscious recognition from Tsubasa's bullying days.

How Garaki Likely Turned Tsubasa into the Winged Nomu

Based on established Nomu creation processes in the series (revealed progressively from the U.S.J. Arc onward, with full details in arcs like the Meta Liberation Army and Paranormal Liberation War):

Process Overview: Garaki selects a human "vessel" (body), often from the dead or those he deems expendable. He performs extensive surgeries in hidden labs (like under Jaku Hospital) to enhance durability, add Quirks via All For One's stockpiling, and expose/modify the brain for control. The result is a super-strong, Quirk-augmented monster with no free will. Early Nomu (like those in Hosu) are prototypes—less stable and with fewer added Quirks compared to high-end ones.

Specific to Tsubasa: As Garaki's grandson, Tsubasa would have been an easy target—living nearby, trusting his grandfather, and possessing a useful Quirk (wings for mobility). Garaki likely abducted or lured him, killed him (since many Nomu are confirmed to be made from corpses), and used his body as the base. The Winged Nomu has only one named Quirk (wings), suggesting minimal additions—perhaps just enhancements for strength and talons, keeping the original wings as the core feature.

Motivation: Garaki's fanaticism for All For One and Quirk research overrides family ties. He views humans as tools, and turning his grandson could have been an early experiment to test Nomu viability on someone with a flight-based Quirk. This fits Garaki's backstory as a Quirk-obsessed doctor who faked kindness while building an empire of horror.

No exact "how" details are given in canon (e.g., no scene of the surgery), as it's left to implication for shock value. It's a dark Easter egg highlighting the series' themes of abuse and lost potential.

When It Likely Happened

Timeline Context:

Tsubasa appears in flashbacks during Izuku and Bakugo's early childhood (ages 4-10, roughly elementary school), bullying Izuku and adventuring with the group (e.g., the forest incident in Chapter 1).

The text notes they "parted ways" and lost contact during middle school (ages 12-15). Izuku and Bakugo attend Aldera Junior High without Tsubasa mentioned, implying he disappeared or moved.

The Hosu incident occurs early in the main series (April-May of Izuku's first year at U.A. High, when he's 15-16).

Estimated Window: Sometime during middle school, likely 1-3 years before the series starts (around ages 12-14 for Tsubasa). This allows time for Garaki to experiment, as the Hosu Nomu are "new" but not the first prototypes (the U.S.J. Nomu predates them slightly). Garaki had been creating Nomu for years under All For One, but the Hosu trio were rushed for Tomura Shigaraki's tantrum against Stain.

If it happened post-childhood parting, it explains why Tsubasa vanishes from the story—no one questions his absence, assuming he just drifted away. The transformation must predate Hosu, as the Nomu is deployed there.

Why This Matters in the Story

The Hero Public Safety Commission (HPSC) in My Hero Academia is a pivotal organization responsible for overseeing hero society in Japan, managing hero licenses, and maintaining public trust in heroes. The two presidents discussed in the document—the unnamed male president killed by Lady Nagant and Madam President—represent different facets of the HPSC’s leadership, each marked by morally complex and often corrupt actions. Below is a thorough analysis of both presidents, covering their roles, personalities, actions, and impacts on the HPSC and the broader narrative, based on the provided document.

The First President (Unnamed Male President)

Role and Background

Position: President of the HPSC before Madam President, killed by Lady Nagant.

Affiliation: Head of the HPSC, overseeing hero-related matters, criminal investigations, and maintaining societal order.

Quirk: Unknown.

Status: Deceased, killed by Lady Nagant after threatening her when she attempted to resign.

Personality

The first president is depicted as cold, authoritarian, and ruthless, prioritizing the HPSC’s agenda over individual lives or morality. His leadership style reflects a belief in "Utopia Justifies the Means," where maintaining the image of hero society excuses extreme measures.

He treated HPSC agents, particularly those from marginalized backgrounds like Lady Nagant, as disposable assets, showing a lack of empathy for their psychological well-being.

His implied threat to eliminate Lady Nagant when she expressed a desire to resign highlights his manipulative and coercive nature, willing to silence dissent to protect the HPSC’s secrets.

Actions

Use of Lady Nagant as an Assassin: The president recruited a young Kaina Tsutsumi (Lady Nagant) during her middle school years, exploiting her powerful rifle Quirk to serve as an assassin. He ordered her to eliminate "stains" in society, including terrorists, corrupt heroes, and even protesters, without due process. This was done to preserve the public’s trust in heroes and maintain social order.

Covert Operations: Under his leadership, the HPSC operated as a shadowy organization, using illegal tactics like assassinations to eliminate perceived threats before they could disrupt hero society. This included preemptive killings of individuals who had not yet committed crimes, undermining justice and fairness.

Response to Lady Nagant’s Dissent: When Lady Nagant, burdened by the psychological toll of her assassinations, questioned the morality of her actions and suggested transparency, the president threatened her life, implying that resignation was not an option. This led to her snapping and killing him with her rifle.

Impact

On Lady Nagant: His actions profoundly damaged Lady Nagant’s mental health, as the constant bloodshed and need to maintain a heroic public facade led to her depression and disillusionment. Her eventual rebellion against him marked a turning point, exposing the HPSC’s corruption.

On the HPSC: His death created a leadership vacuum, allowing his vice-president (Madam President) to take over. The cover-up of his death—framing Lady Nagant’s actions as an argument with another hero—demonstrates the HPSC’s ability to manipulate narratives to protect its image.

On Hero Society: His ruthless policies set a precedent for the HPSC’s morally dubious methods, which continued under his successor. The use of child soldiers and assassins under his tenure laid the groundwork for the HPSC’s eventual downfall, as these actions fueled distrust when exposed.

Narrative Role

The first president serves as a symbol of the HPSC’s corruption at its peak, embodying the organization’s willingness to sacrifice morality for control. His death at Lady Nagant’s hands is a pivotal moment, highlighting the consequences of pushing individuals to their breaking point and foreshadowing the HPSC’s fragility when its secrets are revealed.

Madam President

Role and Background

Position: Vice-president under the first president, later promoted to president after his death. Head of the HPSC until her death during the Paranormal Liberation War.

Affiliation: Hero Public Safety Commission, responsible for hero licensing, criminal investigations, and managing hero-society interactions.

Quirk: Unknown.

Status: Deceased, killed by a clone of Re-Destro during the Paranormal Liberation War.

Appearance: A middle-aged woman with ash blonde hair, turquoise eyes, and a formal black suit, projecting a stoical and professional demeanor.

Voice Actors: Sayaka Kinoshita (Japanese), Meli Grant (English).

Debut: Manga Chapter 185, Anime Episode 87.

Personality

Madam President is described as calm and reassuring in public, as seen during her announcement of the Hero Billboard Chart JP, where she emphasized unity and the strength of the new top heroes post-All Might’s retirement. However, this public persona masks her willingness to make morally questionable decisions.

While she disagreed with her predecessor’s extreme methods (e.g., widespread assassinations), she did not fully reform the HPSC’s corrupt practices, suggesting either complicity or pragmatism in maintaining the status quo.

She showed a slightly more merciful side by choosing to imprison rather than execute Lady Nagant, though this was partly to prevent information leaks and to use her as an example to deter hero conflicts. This indicates a calculated approach, balancing self-preservation with strategic control.

Her decisions, such as mandating Hero Work-Studies for high school students and ordering Hawks to infiltrate the League of Villains, reflect a pragmatic but ethically dubious mindset, prioritizing societal stability over individual safety.

Actions

Handling Lady Nagant’s Betrayal: After Lady Nagant killed the first president, Madam President orchestrated her imprisonment in Tartarus, creating a false narrative that Nagant killed a hero in an argument. This cover-up protected the HPSC’s reputation while ensuring Nagant could not expose their secrets.

Recruitment of Hawks: She scouted a young Keigo Takami (Hawks) at age six after he used his Quirk to stop a car crash. Recognizing his potential, she offered to train him and support his impoverished family, effectively buying their loyalty. Hawks was groomed to replace Lady Nagant as a loyal HPSC agent, trained in espionage and tasked with morally questionable missions, such as infiltrating the League of Villains.

Policy Changes Post-All Might’s Retirement: To compensate for All Might’s absence, Madam President relaxed hero licensing requirements, increasing pass rates and allowing younger students (as young as 15) to obtain provisional licenses. She also mandated Hero Work-Studies, putting students in dangerous situations, such as the raid against the Paranormal Liberation Front, despite objections from pro heroes like Snipe and Cementoss.

Infiltration of the League of Villains: She personally requested Hawks to act as a double agent within the League, a high-risk mission requiring him to commit crimes (e.g., conspiring with Dabi, kidnapping Best Jeanist) to gain trust. This decision underscores her willingness to sacrifice individual morality for strategic gains.

Attempted Arrest of Rikiya Yotsubashi: During the Paranormal Liberation War, Madam President planned to arrest Rikiya Yotsubashi (Re-Destro) under the guise of a business meeting. This backfired when a clone of Re-Destro attacked the HPSC office, leading to her death and significant damage to the organization.

Impact

On Lady Nagant: By imprisoning rather than executing Nagant, Madam President preserved her life but ensured her silence, using her as a cautionary tale to deter other heroes from defying the HPSC. This decision later backfired when Nagant escaped Tartarus and exposed the HPSC’s actions.

On Hawks: Her grooming of Hawks created a loyal but conflicted agent who carried out the HPSC’s dirty work while struggling with his own moral compass. Hawks’ eventual drift away from the HPSC after her death reflects his liberation from her influence, allowing him to act on his personal ideals.

On the HPSC: Madam President’s leadership maintained the HPSC’s power but failed to address its underlying corruption, contributing to its collapse during the Paranormal Liberation War. Her death, combined with the exposure of the HPSC’s actions by Dabi and others, left the organization in disarray, with Yokumiru Mera as a temporary leader and Hawks later taking over.

On Hero Society: Her policies, particularly the mobilization of high school students, endangered young heroes and eroded trust in the HPSC when these actions were criticized by pro heroes and villains alike. The public exposure of the HPSC’s tactics by Dabi further damaged its credibility, weakening hero society’s foundation.

Narrative Role

Madam President is a complex antagonist, representing a more pragmatic but still flawed continuation of the HPSC’s corrupt legacy. Her calm public demeanor contrasts with her willingness to uphold questionable practices, making her a foil to both the first president’s overt ruthlessness and Hawks’ conflicted loyalty. Her death marks a turning point, signaling the HPSC’s decline and paving the way for Hawks to reform the organization as its new president.

Comparative Analysis

Similarities

Corrupt Leadership:

Both presidents prioritized maintaining the public image of hero society over ethical considerations, using illegal tactics like assassinations and child recruitment to achieve their goals.

They treated agents like Lady Nagant and Hawks as tools, exploiting their Quirks and loyalty to serve the HPSC’s agenda.

Secrecy and Cover-Ups:

Both engaged in cover-ups to protect the HPSC’s reputation. The first president hid the true nature of Lady Nagant’s assassinations, while Madam President fabricated a story about Nagant’s crime to justify her imprisonment.

Utopia Justifies the Means:

Both believed that extreme measures were necessary to preserve societal order, reflecting the HPSC’s ethos of sacrificing individual rights for perceived stability.

Impact on Agents:

Their actions caused significant psychological harm to their agents. Lady Nagant’s depression and Hawks’ moral conflicts stem from the pressures imposed by both presidents.

Differences

Leadership Style:

The first president was overtly authoritarian, using threats to enforce compliance, as seen in his interaction with Lady Nagant. Madam President, while still manipulative, adopted a calmer, more diplomatic approach, projecting reassurance in public while making calculated decisions behind closed doors.

Moral Stance:

The first president fully embraced the HPSC’s sordid methods, ordering widespread assassinations without apparent remorse. Madam President disagreed with some of her predecessor’s tactics (e.g., excessive assassinations) and showed slight mercy by imprisoning rather than executing Nagant, though her motives were partly self-serving.

Scope of Actions:

The first president’s focus was on covert assassinations to eliminate threats preemptively. Madam President expanded the HPSC’s influence through policy changes, such as relaxing licensing requirements and mobilizing students, reflecting a broader but equally risky approach to maintaining control.

Fate:

The first president was killed by Lady Nagant, a direct consequence of his coercive tactics. Madam President died during an external attack by Re-Destro’s clone, highlighting the HPSC’s vulnerability to its enemies rather than internal rebellion.

Legacy

First President: His legacy is one of unchecked corruption, setting a precedent for the HPSC’s darkest practices. His death exposed the organization’s fragility and the risks of pushing agents too far.

Madam President: Her leadership attempted to stabilize hero society post-All Might but failed to address the HPSC’s systemic issues. Her death and the subsequent exposure of the HPSC’s actions marked the organization’s collapse, though her recruitment of Hawks allowed for its eventual reformation under his leadership.

Thematic Significance

If we look at Seiji Shishikura’s “more than meets the eye” factor, the case is that—while at first glance he comes across as a rigid, pompous elitist—there are deeper psychological layers and contradictions that complicate him:

1. Surface Persona vs. Hidden Motivations

Surface: He’s obsessed with dignity, tradition, and “weeding out” heroes he deems unworthy. He talks like an old-fashioned noble, keeps impeccable posture, and holds Shiketsu High’s ideals like sacred scripture.

Underneath: Some of this is a coping mechanism tied to his upbringing and personal loss—his father was a Tartarus guard murdered by All For One. His need for order and propriety may stem from a desire to protect the image and stability of hero society after personal chaos.

2. Moral Rigidity vs. Emotional Complexity

His rigidity leads him to antagonize and insult others (Bakugo, Kaminari, Camie), which makes him seem judgmental and arrogant.

Yet, he’s capable of empathy—showing concern for Camie after the Toga impersonation, saving Hawks in the Final War, and choosing not to give in to revenge despite wanting to kill All For One for his father’s death.

3. Idealism vs. Blind Spots

Seiji claims to act “for the good of the hero system,” but fails to self-reflect. Teachers and peers see Stain’s influence on his views, but he denies it outright—showing a blind spot about how ideology can creep in subconsciously.

His failure in the Provisional License Exam was as much about his unwillingness to adapt and collaborate as it was about skill.

4. Tactical Brilliance vs. Strategic Shortcomings

In battle, he’s clever and dangerous, using his Meatball quirk in creative ways for offense, defense, and crowd control.

However, his focus on “teaching lessons” rather than winning or advancing the mission sometimes undermines him—like prioritizing punishing “unworthy” students over passing the exam.

5. Reputation vs. Reality

To outsiders, he’s the “stiff Shiketsu senpai” obsessed with propriety. But in the Final War, he proves adaptable, cooperative, and capable of self-restraint, showing that the pompous exterior hides a disciplined and reliable combatant in the right circumstances.

A Comparison of Lady Nagant, Beros, Slice, and Deborah

Lady Nagant (Kaina Tsutsumi): A former Pro Hero turned villain, previously affiliated with the Hero Public Safety Commission (HPSC). She became disillusioned with hero society's hypocrisy and was manipulated by All For One. Her Quirk, Rifle, allows her to transform her right arm into a sniper rifle and craft bullets from her hair, with a range of 3 km. She also wields Air Walk and an Unnamed Self-Destruct Quirk (both given by All For One). She ultimately redeems herself, aiding the heroes in the Final War.

Beros: A secondary antagonist in My Hero Academia: World Heroes' Mission, a member of the terrorist cult Humarise. Her Quirk, Longbow, lets her transform her fingers into a bow to fire powerful projectiles. She is fiercely loyal to Humarise’s cause of eradicating Quirks to prevent the "Quirk Doomsday Theory."

Slice (Kiruka Hasaki): A villain in My Hero Academia: Heroes Rising, working with Nine to create a world where the strong rule. Her Quirk, Slice, allows her to manipulate her hair as blades or needles. She is a confident, destructive combatant with a softer side toward her leader, Nine.

Deborah Gollini: A member of the Gollini Family mafia in My Hero Academia: You’re Next. Her Quirk, Day Dream, lets her put people into a sleep-like state, controlling their bodies while they experience fantasies. She is sadistic, loyal to the Gollini Family, and uses her Quirk to manipulate others.

Similarities

Female Villains with Ranged Quirks:

All four characters are women with Quirks suited for long-range combat or control:

Lady Nagant: Her Rifle Quirk allows precise sniping up to 3 km, with the ability to craft specialized bullets (e.g., curving, hollow-point, or voice-recording).

Beros: Her Longbow Quirk enables her to fire powerful projectiles with homing capabilities, functioning as an archer.

Slice: Her Slice Quirk lets her fire sharp hair needles or use her hair as blades, effective at both long and close range.

Deborah: Her Day Dream Quirk manipulates targets from a distance by inducing a sleep-like state, controlling their actions without physical combat.

This shared trait makes them formidable at a distance, relying on precision or control rather than brute strength.

Complex Moralities:

None of these characters are purely evil; their actions stem from specific motivations or circumstances:

Lady Nagant: Initially a hero, she was driven to villainy by the HPSC’s manipulative and morally corrupt orders. Her redemption arc shows her underlying desire to be a true hero.

Beros: Her loyalty to Humarise is rooted in a belief in their cause to "save humanity" by eliminating Quirks, showing a misguided sense of duty.

Slice: Oppressed by a society that labeled her a villain due to her powerful Quirk, she seeks a world where strength defines worth, showing a desire for acceptance.

Deborah: While sadistic, her loyalty to the Gollini Family and their vision of power suggests a belief in their hierarchical worldview, though she lacks the depth of redemption seen in Nagant.

Physical Attractiveness:

The document notes that Lady Nagant is described as "quite conventionally attractive" and "beautiful" by All For One, with her appearance emphasized in her form-fitting villain costume.

Deborah is described as a "tall and attractive young woman with a voluptuous physique," enhancing her manipulative allure.

Slice has a striking appearance with glossy lips and long, shiny red hair, which ties into her Quirk and combat style.

Beros is less explicitly described as attractive but has a distinct, athletic build and a unique aesthetic with mint-green hair and eyes, suggesting a commanding presence.

Their appearances often contrast with their dangerous abilities, creating a juxtaposition of beauty and lethality.

Loyalty to a Cause or Leader:

Each character is driven by allegiance to a group or individual:

Lady Nagant: Initially loyal to the HPSC, then manipulated by All For One, before aligning with the heroes due to Midoriya’s influence.

Beros: Devoted to Humarise and its leader, Flect Turn, to the point of sacrificing her life rather than betraying their cause.

Slice: Loyal to Nine, showing care for his well-being and supporting his vision of a world ruled by the strong.

Deborah: Loyal to the Gollini Family and Dark Might, gleefully executing their plans to dominate society.

Trauma or Societal Rejection:

Each character’s villainy is influenced by some form of societal pressure or personal trauma:

Lady Nagant: Her disillusionment stems from the HPSC’s unethical orders, leading to mental strain and hallucinations (e.g., seeing blood on her hands).

Beros: Her belief in the Quirk Doomsday Theory suggests a fear of societal collapse, driving her extreme actions.

Slice: Betrayed and ostracized for her powerful Quirk, she rejects a society that labels her a villain.

Deborah: While less explicit, her sadistic nature and loyalty to the Gollini Family suggest a warped worldview shaped by their mafia culture.

Differences

Moral Alignment and Redemption:

Lady Nagant: Stands out as the only character with a clear redemption arc. Her shift from villainy to aiding the heroes (e.g., sniping Shigaraki in the Final War) is driven by Midoriya’s belief in her heroic spirit, making her a complex anti-villain.

Beros: Remains steadfastly loyal to Humarise, choosing death over surrender, showing no inclination toward redemption.

Slice: Lacks a redemption arc, staying committed to Nine’s vision until her defeat and arrest. Her softer side is limited to her care for Nine, not a broader moral shift.

Deborah: Shows no remorse or redemption, reveling in her sadistic control over others and fleeing when her plans falter.

Quirk Mechanics and Combat Style:

Lady Nagant: Her Rifle Quirk is highly versatile, allowing her to create custom bullets (e.g., curving, voice-recording) and combine it with Air Walk for mobility. Her marksmanship is a mix of Quirk-based power and honed skill, making her a top-tier sniper.

Beros: Her Longbow Quirk is more limited, relying on transforming her fingers into a bow to fire projectiles. She cannot create her own ammunition, making her dependent on her quiver, and her combat is purely physical.

Slice: Her Slice Quirk is unique in using her hair as both a weapon and a shield, offering versatility in close and long-range combat. However, her power diminishes if her hair is damaged, a clear logical weakness.

Deborah: Her Day Dream Quirk is non-physical, focusing on mental manipulation rather than direct combat. She is a non-action combatant, relying on others to handle physical threats, making her the least combat-oriented.

Role in Their Respective Stories:

Lady Nagant: A major character in the main My Hero Academia manga/anime, with a detailed backstory and significant impact on the plot (e.g., her actions in the Final War disrupt All For One’s plans).

Beros: A secondary antagonist in the World Heroes' Mission movie, with a limited role focused on pursuing Alan Kay and fighting the heroes. Her story ends abruptly with her apparent death.

Slice: A secondary antagonist in the Heroes Rising movie, playing a key role in Nine’s crew but with less narrative depth than Nagant. Her defeat is part of the larger battle against Nine.

Deborah: A supporting villain in the You’re Next movie, serving as a manipulative enforcer for the Gollini Family. Her role is significant but less central than Nagant’s, focusing on crowd control and psychological manipulation.

Motivations and Ideologies:

Lady Nagant: Motivated by disillusionment with hero society’s hypocrisy, initially aligning with All For One to destroy it, but her core desire to be a hero leads to her redemption.

Beros: Driven by Humarise’s extremist ideology to eradicate Quirks, believing it’s for humanity’s salvation. Her loyalty is absolute and unyielding.

Slice: Seeks a world where the strong rule, motivated by her own oppression and betrayal by society. Her loyalty to Nine is personal and ideological.

Deborah: Motivated by loyalty to the Gollini Family and a sadistic enjoyment of power and control, lacking the deeper ideological struggles of the others.

Fate and Outcome:

Lady Nagant: Survives her injuries, is pardoned for her crimes, and chooses to remain in prison to observe societal change, later retiring to a normal life.

Beros: Her fate is unknown after jumping from a crashing helicopter, but her actions suggest a likely death due to her refusal to surrender.

Slice: Arrested after her defeat, with no indication of redemption or further story involvement.

Deborah: Flees after her Quirk is countered, but is later implied to be captured, with her status ultimately unknown.

Foils

Lady Nagant vs. Beros:

Foil Dynamic: Nagant and Beros contrast in their relationship with their respective organizations. Nagant’s disillusionment with the HPSC’s corruption leads her to question and eventually rebel against authority, while Beros’s unwavering loyalty to Humarise drives her to self-sacrifice. Nagant’s redemption arc highlights her capacity for change, whereas Beros’s rigid devotion leads to her potential demise.

Similarities as Foils: Both are long-range fighters (sniper vs. archer) with Quirks that transform their arms into weapons, and both serve larger organizations with questionable morals.

Key Difference: Nagant’s internal conflict and eventual heroism contrast with Beros’s unyielding fanaticism.

Lady Nagant vs. Slice:

Foil Dynamic: Nagant and Slice both wield Quirks tied to their bodies (hair for bullets vs. hair as blades), but Nagant’s arc is about rediscovering her heroic ideals, while Slice remains committed to a Social Darwinist ideology. Nagant’s professional training and moral complexity contrast with Slice’s more personal, emotionally driven loyalty to Nine.

Similarities as Foils: Both are women ostracized by society (Nagant by the HPSC’s manipulation, Slice by societal labeling), and both use hair-based Quirks for ranged attacks.

Key Difference: Nagant’s redemption and broader narrative impact contrast with Slice’s limited role and lack of moral growth.

Lady Nagant vs. Deborah:

Foil Dynamic: Nagant’s struggle with her heroic identity and eventual redemption contrast sharply with Deborah’s sadistic enjoyment of villainy and lack of remorse. Nagant’s Quirk is combat-focused and skill-based, while Deborah’s is manipulative and non-physical, highlighting their differing approaches to power (direct action vs. control).

Similarities as Foils: Both are attractive women manipulated by powerful villains (All For One for Nagant, Dark Might for Deborah), and both have ties to larger organizations (HPSC vs. Gollini Family).

Key Difference: Nagant’s moral complexity and heroism contrast with Deborah’s gleeful cruelty and lack of redemption.

Beros vs. Slice:

Foil Dynamic: Beros’s ideological fanaticism for Humarise contrasts with Slice’s personal loyalty to Nine and her vision of a strength-based world. Beros’s willingness to die for her cause contrasts with Slice’s survival and arrest, showing differing levels of commitment to their ideals.

Similarities as Foils: Both are secondary antagonists in MHA movies, with ranged Quirks (archery vs. hair needles) and a willingness to cause destruction for their goals.

Key Difference: Beros’s impersonal devotion to a cult contrasts with Slice’s personal care for Nine and her team.

Beros vs. Deborah:

Foil Dynamic: Beros’s physical combat style and sacrificial loyalty contrast with Deborah’s non-combat, manipulative Quirk and self-preserving nature (fleeing when threatened). Beros’s ideological drive contrasts with Deborah’s sadistic pleasure in control.

Similarities as Foils: Both are loyal to their respective groups (Humarise vs. Gollini Family) and operate in movie settings, with Quirks that allow long-range influence (projectiles vs. mental control).

Key Difference: Beros’s self-sacrifice contrasts with Deborah’s instinct to flee when her Quirk fails.

Slice vs. Deborah:

Foil Dynamic: Slice’s direct, hair-based combat and loyalty to Nine contrast with Deborah’s non-combat, dream-manipulating Quirk and sadistic loyalty to the Gollini Family. Slice’s vulnerability (her hair) contrasts with Deborah’s psychological invulnerability until countered.

Similarities as Foils: Both are female villains in MHA movies, with unique, non-standard Quirks (hair manipulation vs. dream control) and a commitment to their leaders’ visions.

Key Difference: Slice’s physical engagement and emotional attachment to Nine contrast with Deborah’s detached, sadistic manipulation.

Other Observations

Narrative Significance: Lady Nagant is the most developed character, with a full arc in the main series, including a backstory, redemption, and lasting impact. Beros, Slice, and Deborah, as movie villains, have less depth and serve more as obstacles for the heroes, with Beros and Deborah having particularly limited screen time.

Quirk Dependency: Nagant and Slice rely heavily on their Quirks’ physical manifestations (arm and hair), with clear weaknesses (Nagant’s arm, Slice’s hair). Beros’s Quirk is similarly physical but limited by ammunition, while Deborah’s non-physical Quirk makes her unique but vulnerable in direct combat.

Cultural Inspirations: Nagant’s name references the Mosin-Nagant rifle and her bullet-curving is inspired by Wanted’s Fox. Slice draws from Marvel’s Medusa. Beros’s name may derive from the Greek “Vélos” (arrow). Deborah shares traits with Demon Slayer’s Enmu and Resident Evil’s Alcina Dimitrescu, emphasizing her manipulative and aristocratic vibe.

Visual Design: All four have distinctive designs tied to their Quirks or roles:

Nagant’s purple and blue aesthetic and form-fitting villain costume reflect her sniper precision.

Beros’s mint-green hair and archery gear emphasize her archer identity.

Slice’s red hair and claw gloves highlight her cutting theme.

Deborah’s elegant, dark attire and hat align with her manipulative, mafia persona.

Conclusion

Speculative Scenarios for the Escape of Paranormal Liberation Front (PLF) Advisers Post-All For One and Tomura Shigaraki

The Paranormal Liberation Front (PLF), formed from the union of the League of Villains and the Meta Liberation Army, was a formidable villain organization led by Tomura Shigaraki until its defeat in the Final War Arc, with both Shigaraki and All For One (AFO) confirmed dead by the My Hero Academia epilogue (Chapters 423-424). While many PLF members, including key lieutenants like Re-Destro, Trumpet, Skeptic, Spinner, and Mr. Compress, were arrested, and others like Twice, Dabi, and Toga died, some advisers from the Black, Violet, Carmine, and Brown Regiments are noted to have escaped during or after the Paranormal Liberation War (Chapters 258-306) and Second War (Final War Arc). This analysis explores speculative scenarios for what could happen if these surviving advisers—specifically focusing on the Black Regiment Advisers (Sanctum, Twice’s #2, Twice’s #3), Violet Regiment Advisers (Dabi’s #1, #2, #3, and Geten’s #1, #2, #3), Carmine Regiment Advisers (Skeptic’s and Toga’s), and Brown Regiment Advisers (Amplivolt, Mr. Compress’s, and Spinner’s)—evaded capture and continued their activities post-AFO and Shigaraki. The scenarios draw on their established roles, quirks, and thematic significance, while addressing the societal and narrative context of the MHA epilogue.

Context of Escape and Canon Evidence

PLF Collapse: The PLF was dismantled after the Final War, with Japan rebuilding and hero society undergoing reforms (e.g., Hawks’ overhaul of the Hero Billboard Chart and Ochaco’s Quirk Counseling initiatives). The epilogue confirms AFO and Shigaraki’s deaths, with surviving lieutenants like Spinner and Mr. Compress arrested, but several advisers’ fates remain ambiguous, with some explicitly escaping (e.g., Twice’s #2, Dabi’s #1, #2, Geten’s #2, #3, Mr. Compress’s #3, Spinner’s #1, #3).

Adviser Profiles: Advisers are elite operatives, often on par with or stronger than average Pro Heroes, with roles ranging from tactical command to combat and propaganda. Their escapes, particularly during the Gunga Mountain Villa raid (Paranormal War) or Second War battles (e.g., Jaku Ruins, Okuto Island), suggest resilience and strategic acumen.

Societal Backdrop: Post-war Japan sees reduced crime rates, a reformed Hero Public Safety Commission (HPSC) under Hawks, and increased civilian involvement in heroism, but lingering societal issues (e.g., Heteromorph discrimination, Quirk-based marginalization) could fuel surviving advisers’ motivations.

Speculative Scenarios for Escaped Advisers

Black Regiment Advisers (Sanctum, Twice’s #2, Twice’s #3)

Sanctum’s Leadership in Exile:

Scenario: As the longest-serving MLA member and #1 adviser, Sanctum’s experience and loyalty to the PLF’s ideology of free Quirk usage could lead him to form a splinter faction. With his pragmatic focus on regiment loyalty and lack of ambition to usurp Twice, he might rally surviving PLF remnants (e.g., escaped Violet or Carmine advisers) to continue the MLA’s mission underground, targeting the reformed HPSC to destabilize Hawks’ new system.

Motivation: Sanctum’s commitment to the MLA’s cause, combined with his strategic mind, makes him a likely candidate to reorganize scattered PLF forces. His ambiguous fate post-Gunga Villa suggests he could have evaded capture, possibly retreating to a hidden MLA safehouse.

Impact: A Sanctum-led faction could launch low-profile attacks on hero infrastructure, exploiting civilian distrust from the PLF’s earlier propaganda (e.g., Skeptic’s media manipulation). This would challenge Hawks’ vision of a hero society with “free time” by reigniting fears of villain resurgence.

Narrative Fit: Sanctum’s “Evil Chancellor” archetype aligns with a mastermind role, potentially setting up a new arc where Class 2-A (now Pro Heroes like Shoto and Bakugo) faces a more covert, ideological threat.

Twice’s #2 Adviser (Pilot Adviser) Rebellious Heteromorph Uprising:

Scenario: The #2 Adviser, a purple-skinned Heteromorph with a pilot-esque uniform, escaped the Gunga Villa per anime canon. His grudge against hero society’s anti-Heteromorph bias, highlighted in Skeptic’s speech, could drive him to lead a radical Heteromorph insurgency, possibly aligning with Spinner’s surviving #1 Adviser (Mouthless) to mobilize disenfranchised mutants.

Motivation: His Heteromorphic Quirk and societal resentment mirror Spinner’s arc, suggesting a personal vendetta against heroes like Shoto or Endeavor, who fought PLF forces. He might target Ochaco’s Quirk Counseling programs, viewing them as insufficient to address systemic discrimination.

Impact: This uprising could disrupt Japan’s recovery by inciting Heteromorph riots, forcing heroes like Shoto (#2 Pro Hero) or Koda (who defeated Spinner’s #2 Adviser) to confront the moral complexity of fighting marginalized groups. It would echo MHA’s themes of societal failure creating villains.

Narrative Fit: His monstrous appearance and escape make him a compelling figure for a gritty, street-level conflict, contrasting with the epilogue’s optimistic tone and testing Midoriya’s Quirkless heroism in his new tech suit.

Twice’s #3 Adviser (Pink Elderly Adviser) Subtle Manipulation:

Scenario: The #3 Adviser, an elderly woman with pink hair and a “Granny Classic” design, has an ambiguous fate post-Gunga Villa. Her potential relation to Geten’s #2 Adviser (similar pink hair, bindi) suggests a familial MLA legacy. She could operate as a covert manipulator, using her unassuming appearance to infiltrate civilian or hero-adjacent circles (e.g., as a “concerned citizen” undermining Ochaco’s counseling efforts).

Motivation: Her villainous role despite her kindly look suggests cunning, possibly driven by loyalty to the MLA’s original vision or personal ties to Geten’s faction. She might aim to sow discord subtly, avoiding direct combat.

Impact: Her actions could erode trust in hero reforms, creating paranoia about hidden villains. This would challenge Midoriya’s teaching role, forcing him to identify her influence among civilians like Dai, the aspiring hero he mentors.

Narrative Fit: Her deceptive archetype fits a psychological thriller arc, where heroes must discern friend from foe in a post-war society striving for unity.

Violet Regiment Advisers (Dabi’s #1, #2, #3; Geten’s #1, #2, #3)

Dabi’s #1 Adviser (Shark Heteromorph) Mercenary Network:

Scenario: The shark-like Heteromorph with a slasher smile escaped the Paranormal War. Fan speculation notes his resemblance to AFO’s hired guns, suggesting prior ties to the underworld. Post-PLF, he could form a mercenary network, hiring escaped advisers (e.g., Dabi’s #2, Geten’s #2) for hit-and-run attacks on hero outposts, leveraging his guerilla warfare expertise.

Motivation: His aggressive design and escape suggest a survivalist mindset, possibly driven by profit or revenge against heroes who defeated Dabi (e.g., Shoto). He might target Todoroki family members to exploit their emotional scars.

Impact: A mercenary network would strain hero resources, especially with reduced Pro Hero numbers post-war (e.g., Hawks’ retirement, Endeavor’s injuries). Shoto, as #2 Pro Hero, could face personal stakes confronting a foe tied to Dabi’s legacy.

Narrative Fit: His brutal, shark-like persona suits a chaotic, villain-driven arc, testing the Todoroki family’s reconciliation and Shoto’s growth as a hero.

Dabi’s #2 Adviser (Gas Adviser) Environmental Sabotage:

Scenario: The scuba-gear-wearing adviser, who generates purple gas, led a squad to free Gigantomachia in the Second War’s Jaku Ruins. Surviving this mission, he could use his gas Quirk for eco-terrorism, poisoning water supplies or urban areas to destabilize Japan’s recovery, aligning with the Violet Regiment’s guerilla tactics.

Motivation: Loyalty to Dabi’s destructive vision or resentment over the PLF’s defeat could drive him to target civilian infrastructure, aiming to prove hero society’s fragility.

Impact: His gas-based attacks would force heroes like Bakugo (#15 Pro Hero) or Mirio (#1 Pro Hero) to prioritize civilian safety, diverting resources from other threats. This could expose gaps in the new Hero Billboard system.

Narrative Fit: His area-denial Quirk suits a high-stakes, urban conflict arc, challenging heroes to innovate non-lethal countermeasures in a reformed society.

Dabi’s #3 Adviser (Hole Adviser) Underground Resistance:

Scenario: Though arrested in the Paranormal War, a speculative twist could imagine his escape during AFO’s Tartarus breakout (Episode 126). His hole-creating Quirk could enable a subterranean resistance, hiding PLF remnants in underground networks to launch surprise attacks.

Motivation: Revenge against heroes who captured him (e.g., Endeavor’s team) and loyalty to Dabi’s anarchic ideals could fuel his efforts to rebuild a guerilla force.

Impact: An underground movement would complicate hero patrols, forcing Midoriya’s tech-suited team to adapt to unconventional battlefields. It would highlight the epilogue’s theme of persistent societal flaws.

Narrative Fit: His utility Quirk and defeat make him a wildcard, ideal for a speculative arc where heroes uncover a hidden PLF revival.

Geten’s #1 Adviser (Elderly Strategist) Ideological Revival:

Scenario: The bald, suited elderly man, an “evil old” strategist, could escape to lead an MLA revivalist cult, preaching Quirk liberation to recruit new followers. His command presence suits organizing scattered PLF survivors (e.g., Geten’s #2, #3) into a pseudo-religious movement.

Motivation: Loyalty to Re-Destro’s ideology and disdain for hero reforms could drive him to radicalize civilians, exploiting post-war discontent.

Impact: A cult would challenge Ochaco’s counseling efforts, forcing her to confront ideological extremism. It could draw in Midoriya, testing his ability to inspire hope without One For All.

Narrative Fit: His strategist archetype fits a cerebral threat, contrasting with the Violet Regiment’s usual physicality and echoing MHA’s theme of ideological battles.

Geten’s #2 Adviser (Pink-Haired Heteromorph) Resilient Insurgency:

Scenario: The pink-haired, masked woman, noted for resilience after taking heavy hits, reappears during the Dark Hero Arc among escapees. She could lead a Heteromorph-centric insurgency, possibly with Twice’s #2, targeting hero academies to disrupt training (e.g., U.A.’s new Class 2-A).

Motivation: Her Heteromorph identity and survival suggest a personal stake in fighting discrimination, viewing hero reforms as superficial. Her potential tie to Twice’s #3 Adviser could add a familial revenge angle.

Impact: Attacks on hero schools would force Shinsou (new Class 2-A member) and Midoriya (as a teacher) to protect students, highlighting the epilogue’s focus on nurturing the next generation.

Narrative Fit: Her durability and ambiguous traits make her a versatile threat, fitting a narrative about persistent societal divides.

Geten’s #3 Adviser (Fox Swordsman) Lone Wolf Vengeance:

Scenario: The fox-like Heteromorph swordsman, defeated on Okuto Island in the anime, could be retconned as escaping in a speculative manga scenario. As a high-ranking escapee, he might operate as a lone assassin, targeting Pro Heroes like Mirio or Bakugo to avenge Geten’s arrest.

Motivation: His swordsman skills and mobility suggest a personal code, possibly driven by loyalty to Geten or resentment over the PLF’s collapse.

Impact: A solo assassin would test individual hero skills, particularly Bakugo’s combat prowess or Mirio’s leadership as #1 Pro Hero, creating personal stakes in a reformed society.

Narrative Fit: His fox-like design and combat style suit a high-action arc, contrasting with the epilogue’s focus on collective heroism.

Carmine Regiment Advisers (Skeptic’s #1, #2, #3; Toga’s #1, #2, #3)

Skeptic’s #1 Adviser (Red/Ponytail) Propaganda Revival:

Scenario: Captured during the Paranormal War, Red could escape during AFO’s Tartarus breakout (Episode 126). His affably evil demeanor and youth make him ideal for restarting Skeptic’s media manipulation, spreading anti-hero propaganda via underground networks to undermine Hawks’ HPSC reforms.

Motivation: Loyalty to Skeptic’s intelligence operations and a desire to restore PLF influence could drive him to exploit post-war media distrust.

Impact: Propaganda campaigns would challenge heroes like Shoto or Midoriya to counter misinformation, testing their public influence in a reformed society.

Narrative Fit: His casual charisma fits a social media-driven arc, reflecting MHA’s exploration of public perception and hero accountability.

Skeptic’s #2 Adviser (Slidin’ Go) Rogue Hero Network:

Scenario: As a Pro Hero turned PLF mole, Slidin’ Go’s chipper personality and capture suggest he could escape to lead a network of rogue heroes sympathetic to the MLA’s cause, targeting the new Hero Billboard system to expose its flaws.

Motivation: His betrayal of hero society reflects a belief in free Quirk usage, likely pushing him to recruit disillusioned heroes post-war.

Impact: A rogue hero faction would force Hawks, as HPSC president, to confront internal corruption, echoing MHA’s theme of systemic reform.

Narrative Fit: His dual identity suits a narrative about trust and betrayal, challenging heroes to redefine heroism.

Skeptic’s #3 Adviser (Frog Adviser) Guerrilla Intelligence:

Scenario: Adapted out in anime but present in manga, the froggish Heteromorph could escape to lead covert intelligence operations, using his Heteromorphic traits for espionage in rural or aquatic environments.

Motivation: His outsider status and loyalty to Skeptic’s data-driven approach could drive him to gather intel on hero movements, targeting figures like Ochaco.

Impact: Espionage would strain hero coordination, forcing Midoriya’s team to adapt to stealth threats in a low-crime society.

Narrative Fit: His unique design fits a niche, espionage-focused arc, highlighting the PLF’s lingering intelligence capabilities.

Toga’s #1 Adviser (Turtleneck) Subtle Infiltration:

Scenario: The light-haired, darker-skinned woman could use her ambiguous appearance to infiltrate civilian communities, posing as a refugee to sabotage Ochaco’s counseling programs or gather intel for other escapees.

Motivation: Loyalty to Toga’s emotional chaos-driven ideology could push her to disrupt hero efforts to prevent new villains like Toga.

Impact: Infiltration would test heroes’ ability to protect civilians, forcing Ochaco to confront her guilt over Toga’s death.

Narrative Fit: Her subtle design suits a psychological arc, echoing Toga’s manipulative charm.

Toga’s #2 Adviser (Android) Tech-Based Sabotage:

Scenario: The android-like adviser, with an R2-D2-inspired design, could hack hero tech (e.g., Midoriya’s new suit) or infrastructure, aligning with Skeptic’s tech expertise to disrupt Japan’s recovery.

Motivation: A mechanical or Quirk-based android nature suggests a programmed loyalty to the PLF, aiming to prove hero reliance on tech as a weakness.

Impact: Tech sabotage would challenge Midoriya’s Quirkless heroism, forcing reliance on teamwork with tech-savvy heroes like Hatsume Mei.

Narrative Fit: The sci-fi aesthetic fits a futuristic arc, contrasting with the epilogue’s tech-driven heroism.

Toga’s #3 Adviser (Headband) Brute Force Rebellion:

Scenario: Captured in the Paranormal War, the bulky “Genius Bruiser” could escape via Tartarus to lead a physical rebellion, using her strength to rally low-level PLF remnants for direct attacks on hero outposts.

Motivation: Her commander role and physicality suggest a desire to restore Toga’s chaotic legacy through brute force.

Impact: Physical assaults would test heroes like Kirishima or Fat Gum, highlighting the need for traditional heroics in a reformed society.

Narrative Fit: Her strength-driven role suits a high-action arc, contrasting with subtler threats.

Brown Regiment Advisers (Amplivolt, Mr. Compress’s #2, #3, Spinner’s #1, #2, #3)

Amplivolt’s Electric Guerrilla:

Scenario: Captured after Denki Kaminari neutralized his Amplivolt Quirk, a speculative escape could see him leading electric-based guerrilla attacks, targeting power grids to disrupt hero operations.

Motivation: Resentment over his defeat and loyalty to the PLF’s support role could drive him to cripple Japan’s infrastructure.

Impact: Power outages would challenge heroes like Kaminari or Iida, forcing them to protect civilians while countering a familiar foe.

Narrative Fit: His electric Quirk suits a tech-disruption arc, testing hero adaptability in a low-crime era.

Mr. Compress’s #2 Adviser (Spiky-Haired) Youthful Rebellion:

Scenario: Captured in the Paranormal War, an escape could see the spiky-haired youth rallying younger PLF sympathizers for flash-mob-style attacks, using an unknown Quirk for chaos.

Motivation: His youth suggests a desire to prove himself, possibly emulating Mr. Compress’s theatricality to disrupt hero society.

Impact: Mob attacks would strain hero resources, forcing Class 2-A to address youth radicalization, a new societal issue.

Narrative Fit: His lack of development suits a wildcard role, reflecting the epilogue’s focus on inspiring the next generation.

Mr. Compress’s #3 Adviser (Question) Enigmatic Saboteur:

Scenario: Having escaped the Paranormal War, the masked adviser with question marks could operate as a cryptic saboteur, planting traps or misinformation to confuse heroes.

Motivation: His mysterious design suggests a strategic mind, possibly driven by loyalty to Mr. Compress’s showmanship or PLF ideals.

Impact: Traps would test heroes’ problem-solving, particularly Midoriya’s analytical skills as a teacher.

Narrative Fit: His enigmatic nature fits a puzzle-driven arc, challenging heroes to unravel a hidden threat.

Spinner’s #1 Adviser (Mouthless) Heteromorph Leadership:

Scenario: The mouthless mutant woman, a key Second War figure leading Heteromorphs to free Kurogiri, could continue her strategic leadership, rallying Heteromorphs for a non-violent but disruptive movement advocating Quirk rights.

Motivation: Her focus on strategy over combat and Heteromorph identity align with Spinner’s anti-discrimination agenda, pushing for systemic change post-PLF.

Impact: A non-violent movement would challenge Ochaco and Midoriya to address societal reform peacefully, testing their ideals.

Narrative Fit: Her leadership role suits a social justice arc, echoing MHA’s themes of empathy and reform.

Spinner’s #2 Adviser (Takaie Kanigumo) Radical Propaganda:

Scenario: Defeated by Koda in the Second War, a speculative escape could see the spider-like Heteromorph continuing his manipulative propaganda, using digital platforms to radicalize civilians against heroes.

Motivation: His “Mouth of Sauron” role and anti-discrimination rhetoric suggest a desire to perpetuate Spinner’s legacy, targeting heroes like Koda.

Impact: Digital propaganda would challenge heroes like Shinsou, who uses Brainwashing for heroics, to counter misinformation.

Narrative Fit: His manipulative nature fits a cyber-warfare arc, reflecting modern societal challenges.

Spinner’s #3 Adviser (Blockish) Silent Enforcer:

Scenario: Surviving the Paranormal War but absent in the Second War, the block-headed Heteromorph could emerge as a silent enforcer, protecting other escapees or executing covert missions.

Motivation: His quiet nature and propaganda role suggest loyalty to Spinner’s cause, possibly acting as muscle for other advisers.

Impact: His physical presence would support other threats, challenging heroes like Ojiro with direct combat.

Narrative Fit: His minimal dialogue suits a background enforcer role, enhancing other advisers’ arcs.

Thematic and Narrative Implications

Societal Tensions: Escaped advisers could exploit lingering issues like Heteromorph discrimination (Twice’s #2, Geten’s #2, Spinner’s #1) or distrust in heroes (Skeptic’s #1, Toga’s #1), challenging the epilogue’s optimistic reforms. This aligns with MHA’s theme of villains arising from societal failures.

Hero Challenges: Midoriya’s Quirkless heroism, Shoto’s leadership, Ochaco’s counseling, and Hawks’ HPSC reforms would face diverse threats—physical (Dabi’s #2, Amplivolt), ideological (Sanctum, Geten’s #1), or psychological (Twice’s #3, Toga’s #1)—testing Class 2-A’s growth.

Bittersweet Legacy: The epilogue suggests Shigaraki and Toga’s spirits may linger as vestiges, potentially influencing advisers like Toga’s #1 or #2 to honor their chaos-driven ideals, creating emotional stakes for heroes.

Reformed Society: Hawks’ vision of reduced crime and expanded hero recognition could be undermined by advisers’ actions, forcing heroes to balance combat with societal reform, echoing Midoriya’s mentorship of Dai.

Critical Notes and Limitations

Canon Ambiguity: Many advisers’ fates (e.g., Sanctum, Twice’s #3, Geten’s #1) are unclear, and their Quirks are often unnamed, requiring speculation based on designs and roles. Canon confirms escapes for some (Twice’s #2, Dabi’s #1, #2, Geten’s #2, #3, Mr. Compress’s #3, Spinner’s #1, #3), but others rely on hypothetical Tartarus breakouts.

Narrative Constraints: Horikoshi’s focus on Class 1-A and major villains leaves advisers as “elite mooks,” limiting their development. Speculative arcs prioritize thematic consistency over canon expansion, avoiding contradiction with the epilogue’s closure.

Source Reliance: Scenarios are grounded in manga Chapters 258-424, anime Episode 126, and web sources, with no reliance on unverified X posts. Fanfiction-like interpretations (e.g., Archive of Our Own) are avoided to maintain canon fidelity.