Toxic Communication Habits Part 1
The vloggers Permission to Exist and Shahida Arabi talk about toxic communication habits. These are habits that are toxic or emotionally abusive without qualifying as outright deception or obvious bullying and insulting. The discussion ranges from stonewalling and silent treatment to projection, deflection, and gaslighting.
As someone who is verbally impulsive, I know all too well that verbal impulsivity is often misinterpreted as entitlement or arrogance. Consequently, the verbally impulsive—like me—have a responsibility to work on their verbal impulsivity, at least to ensure that they aren’t inadvertently making the other person feel disrespected, undervalued, or dismissed. This is especially important in light of structural privilege, which justifiably primes women, e.g., to expect to be disrespected, undervalued, or dismissed in conversations with men.
However, I greatly appreciate that at the end of this video, Permission to Exist emphasises that verbal impulsivity and conversational entitlement are indeed distinct, and talks about how the listener can distinguish one from the other. I think this distinction is profound and important (though I obviously have personal reasons for thinking this).
A verbally impulsive person is genuinely listening to you, and she is interrupting you because she is verbally excitable, cares about what you’re saying, and has a problem with controlling her excitement verbally. A conversationally entitled person is interrupting you because she doesn’t care about what you’re saying, or about what you’re thinking or feeling, and just wants to change the subject.
Permission to Exist also touches on the fact that close friends usually converse in an overlapping, communal way, in which everyone is participating, and interruptions are commonplace and expected. This conversational style usually flows, in a natural way, from the underlying communal dynamic of close friendships and emotional bonds.
To be sure, when you interrupt your interlocutor too often or inappropriately, as a result of verbal impulsivity, this is a bad habit that you need to work on. It’s something I’m still working on. But where verbal impulsivity can be non-toxic, conversational entitlement cannot. The former is excitable over-participation; the latter is a dismissive avoidance of participation.