For no reason in particular⌠a friendly reminder that this is Ian MacDiarmidâs side profile.
If youâre over-exaggerating his nose to the degree I have to deadass do a double-take thinking your art is purposefully mimicking textbook antisemitic imagery with your Palpatine design just to make him seem âextra evilâ, it might be time to go back to the drawing board and rework the piece. Â
Overexaggerating hooked noses to the point theyâre evoking harmful antisemitic motifs especially on evil/greedy characters comes from an expansive, insidious history of trying to dehumanize and demonize real people with these features (largely Jews and Arabs). Â
Just please be mindful - especially since Star Wars itself already has a gross history of perpetuating this type of imagery:
Palpatineâs animated design.
Dookuâs animated design.
The Munnâs (you know, the âevilâ race of aliens that control the banks) actually having caricaturized noses ADDED to them in TCW TV show.
I largely, and perhaps even naively, donât think this is an intentional thing in most cases because it is something that is unfortunately so widely pervasive in pop culture around the world. But I do want others to be aware of how your art reads to some of us. Â
Is it antisemitic to have characters with hooked noses? Absolutely not, hooked noses rock. Â
Rather, it becomes antisemitic when youâre combining several antisemitic tropes that portray these features in consortium with 1.) overexaggerating them to purposefully make a character appear more grotesque/ugly/evil and/or 2.) combining them with other harmful, antisemitic stereotypes (money/wealth hoarding, connection to conspiracy theories, dehumanization ie. eating babies/being demonic, puppetmasters, etc). Â
Additional materials on antisemitism/antisemitic imagery: a past post that goes into fuller details about the history of Star Warsâ antisemitism, The US Holocaust Memorial Museumâs Holocaust Encyclopedia (typing in âantisemitic imagreyâ will give you many, many historical examples), history of antisemitism by UNESCO, article on antisemitism in Star Wars (Al Jazeera), Antisemitism Explained by Horwitz-Wasserman Holocaust Memorial Plaza, more examples from the Blavatnik Archive.Â
Okay, public service announcement over haha.