and all four of them are wrong!

Did Obi-wan and Yoda never wonder that if Luke succeeded with killing Vader, how he would react if he found out that he was made to unknowingly commit patricide?

Because as it is knowingly committing patricide even if your dad was a horrible person takes a toll on one's psyche, it impacts a person's mental wellbeing and leaves a scar that never really heals for the most part.

It's also well known that Luke yearned for his dad like crazy and we know that both Yoda and Obi-wan were aware of this.

Now imagine unknowingly committing patricide when you've been yearning for Mr. Paternity himself, coming to realisation that you now have the blood of the father you've been yearning for on your hands and there is absolutely nothing you can do to change that and knowing that the mentors you trusted knew you were killing your father but didn't stop you or care for how it would affect you if you found out, they were insisting upon it in fact. I'm pretty sure that's a good way to make a whole new Sith Lord no?

Anakin’s character is so important and interesting PRECISELY BECAUSE he was not a bad person. Because his fall was not inevitable. An Anakin who was doomed from the beginning by something in his nature is completely contradictory to the way circumstances contribute to tragedy.

the dialogues are supposed to capture the epic macro emotions and events.

they capture the timeless and tragic romance of anidala as well as the brotherhood of anakin and obi-wan and its betrayal. they capture the masterful and devilish nature of palpatine, and the dogmatic, lost, and blind nature preceeding the fall of jedi. they also capture the demise of democracy and liberty at the hands of its own republic. that's why they are so quotable too.

they capture the fall of the chosen one.

in aotc after padmé says "because it makes me uncomfortable" and the music picks up ominously before panning to a smiling anakin and he says "sorry my lady."

the meadow scene where padmé and anakin discuss politics. "that sounds like a dictatorship to me", and he teases her. "if it works."

the end of the fireplace scene "we could keep it a secret." (as if that means he's "evil"? but i notice people react badly to it. usually after the music picks up.)

the scene in rots where padmé tells anakin of her pregnancy, and he takes a moment to process, (music becomes eerie and dramatic) before saying the moment is the happiest of his life.