ok so. so we’re just. not reading now. wow ok. ok!!! booktok says we should remove half of the fun from reading!!! wow!!! (i found this in a video and apparently it’s not just this person doing it. it’s. quite a few of them. just to make that clear.)
I agree with op. This isn't reading, not completely. Yes, its the physical act of reading. But no author places all the value of a story in the dialogue.
Dialogue hints at what character's feel, what their emotions are. It shows how they speak to others and their emotions about them in the moment. It does not plainly display anything other than speech patterns.
In my limited screenwriting knowledge and experience (since there was a suggestion in the tags to read screenplays instead), this act of only reading dialogue isn't even satisfied by a screenplay. The descriptions still build the world.
By only reading what characters say, you will forever miss what is unsaid, what is only shown. If you believe every word that comes out of my mouth, and refuse to watch my hands, you will believe I mean you no harm while I steal right from your pocket.
Boring, useless descriptions are a barrier to reading for pleasure; that is a valid point, but so is the point that you should take your personal preference out of your consumption of literature. Sometimes the point lies in the boring way this character thinks; sometimes the point is that they are always sad, always lost. What does that tell you beyond I would hate this person if I met them? How do they serve the story that is being told here, outside the words spoken on the page?
We rob ourselves everytime we don't read the full page, and we rob our readers of full understanding everytime we leave it out.

















