I may be pitiably old-school in insisting that we take the source-text as a foundation to this diverse household that is fandom, but I frankly donât see in any of the versions JRRT wrote, the case of Fingon having very little interest in Maedhros pre-Thangodorim.
The two of them are famously the case of friendship-lost-and-renewed, the grand symbol for the sons of FinwĂ« returned to Beleriand, who despite all their internal conflicts, join forces upon Ard-galen, the eastern and the western marches coming together at the Dagor Aglareb to enact the Siege of Angband, and then, the attempt to replicate that victory at the Nirnaeth. Famously, âto take the might of Morgoth as between anvil and hammer, and break it to pieces.âÂ
The rescue itself is driven by preexisting emotion as much as politics: âthe thought of their ancient friendship stung his heartâ. And more so, I daresay, reading Fingonâs rescue as an act of pure spite and little else, does a disservice to his character. Strips him of what is perhaps his greatest contribution to this narrative: preventing civil war among the Noldor.
Then Fingon the valiant, son of Fingolfin, resolved to heal the feud that divided the Noldor, before their Enemy should be ready for war.
Thus he rescued his friend of old from torment, and their love was renewed; and the hatred between the houses of Fingolfin and Fëanor was assuaged.
Three entire years pass between the arrival of Fingolfinâs host at Mitrhim (FA 2) to Fingonâs rescue mission (FA 5). In some versions, this timeline gets stretched to five years. Telling us that this is not some rash, spur-of-the-moment thing, but a premeditated action, likely driven by desperation from the circumstances at Mithrim. Without Fingonâs deed, there would be no victories for the Noldor, no Long Peace, no meeting of the Edain and Eldar. They would be swept by Morgothâs armies, one by one, and swiftly.
Now donât get me wrong, Iâm all for complicating their relationship, whether itâs being read as a brothers-in-arms platonic ordeal or as a ship. I shout my triple hoorays for giving them glass-sharp edges. Hell, in my own writing I make them kill the other and torment them and never ever give them peace.
But I donât think we need an entirely callous interpretation of Fingonâs character to make this friend(ship) full of worms and spikes.
How can a very strong friendship be so politically poisoned that itâs shattered to pieces? What drives two people who love each other deeply to become vicious political opponents?Â
What of the Noldor discriminating against the lack of beauty? Of Fingon, drenched in Valarin light, now needing to teach himself not to recoil from what is mired?
What of their fatherâs legacy? The ghosts of FĂ«anor and Fingolfin forever driving a wedge? Of festering wounds that might never be fully stitched? And of the persistence and stubbornness to still try, again, and again, and again because staying alive in Beleriand is a perpetual act of stubbornness. Fight until youâre dead. Fight on the battlefield and fight with your ancient friend. Until one of you is gone and you can love no longer.