hey, if itâs asking questions time, here are some of mine:
whatâs âsloppily madeâ or a âbad ideaâ about a trained girl assassin doing an assassination?
whatâs âsloppily madeâ or a âbad ideaâ about a girl discovering she can use a quasi-magical force in a universe where quasi-magical forces exist?
whatâs âsloppily madeâ or a âbad ideaâ about having a gay superhero in a story that takes place in a world where gay people exist?
whatâs so hard to understand about my original post? is it not obvious that iâm making a joke? a joke about the way that gatekeepers expect us to be constantly proving the âqualityâ and âmeritsâ of us getting any scraps of representation at all? when we should not have to fucking do that?
iâm tired of being forced to do fandom homework for gatekeepers. i shouldnât have to write a dissertation on aryaâs training with the faceless men to establish the validity of her actions to people whoâve been watching the fucking show all along but just have such misogyny-soaked brains that they canât recognize the difference between âbad writingâ and âmy own shitty internal bias.â there is PLENTY of shitty writing on game of thrones: nearly all of it! but this was a logical plot development, and yet fandom still lost its collective shit, because skilled women are somehow the most fantastical element of a fucking ice zombie story.
that dude asking âwell why should there be a gay avenger?â is a perfect example: he wants his homework done for him. he wants an essay in 12-point font with one-inch margins outlining Ten Solid Reasons for the inclusion of a gay avenger and their Relevance to the Plot, but i will tell you what he deserves, which is to be told to fuck off. there should be a fucking gay avenger because there are fucking gay people alive on earth and that is IT. weâre alive in the world, and so we deserve stories. stories about people like us. itâs that simple.
the point of my original post is that i am done politely providing footnoted essays on why there should be heroic lead characters that i identify with. âreyâs a mary sueâ is not a statement that deserves to be refuted with evidence, it deserves to be fucking laughed at, and i was.
so i didnât build a strawman for you: you carried one in here. feel free to escort it back out.