🍞 탄소년단

The Grammys didn’t create that “Best Asian Music” category this year to be diverse. They did it to continue boxing non English speaking artists but especially BTS, so they won’t have to nominate them in the main categories with the rest of their peers. This was the Grammys telling BTS they’ll give them a Grammy win but under their own boxed category. We give you the scraps and you are supposed to take them. They said no.

They’ve been doing this for years under the disguise of diversity. “Best Traditional Country Album” a new category introduced after Beyoncé won in the Best Country Album category because they couldn’t stand a non white artist redefining that genre. “Best African Music” being introduced in 2024 to keep Tyla away from other pop girls. And “Best Latin Song” being introduced for this year along with Best Asian Music after Bad Bunny right fully dominated all of the charts last year. And mind you, Brazilian artists cannot even submit their work for this category because the rules say it has to be 51% in Spanish, even when Brazilians speak Portuguese but are Latin people.

It was never about diversity. It’s about boxing and categorizing these artists when global music (or more like non English music) is becoming bigger each year and this is the only way they can keep their American/British peers safe in their space.

In BTS’ latest album ARIRANG, they have a song called Alien where they describe feeling alienated by the industry duo to their xenophobic behavior. Them creating this category when they released one of the biggest albums of the year is proving them right. At the end, this was the right choice.

This decision really says a great deal about the kind of artists BTS have become. More than anything, it shows that they’re driven by the art itself rather than by the pursuit of recognition. I’ve said this before, and I think it’s important to acknowledge that, when they first set out to become artists, it probably wasn’t solely because they loved making music. Like anyone pursuing a career in entertainment, they most likely wanted financial security, success, recognition, and all the opportunities that come with achieving that level of fame.

The difference is that they’ve now reached a point where they already have those things. They’ve built a career that very few artists in history could ever hope to achieve. They’ve sold millions of albums, broken records across the globe, filled stadiums on multiple continents, and become one of the most recognisable musical acts in the world. At this stage, they’re no longer chasing validation. They’re continuing because they genuinely love creating music, because they still have stories they want to tell, and because they have a deep sense of responsibility and appreciation for the fans who have supported them throughout their journey.

That’s why this decision carries so much weight. The fact that BTS chose to take this stance while they’re arguably at the absolute peak of their influence makes it all the more meaningful. Their participation in an event like the Grammys is valuable. Whether people like it or not, BTS generate enormous public interest. Their attendance brings media coverage, online engagement, viewers, and ratings, something the Recording Academy has benefited from on several occasions, just as many other award shows have benefited from BTS’s presence over the years.

By effectively saying, “You’re not going to separate us simply because you’re afraid of us,” they’ve made a remarkably strong statement. Of course, that’s an interpretation rather than something they explicitly said, but it’s difficult not to see the symbolism behind their decision. The Grammys recently introduced a category specifically recognising Asian artists rather than allowing those artists to compete solely within the existing general categories. If I’m not mistaken, the category isn’t limited to K pop artists but includes Asian artists more broadly.

This isn’t an entirely new conversation either. Similar debates emerged when separate categories for Latin artists were introduced. Those changes were praised by some but criticised by others, who argued that they created a form of segregation rather than genuine inclusion. More recently, after Bad Bunny dominated at last year’s Grammys, there was renewed discussion about the Academy’s apparent reluctance to fully embrace artists who don’t come from the English speaking world or who don’t primarily perform in English. For years, people have questioned whether international artists are truly given equal consideration in the main categories or whether they are subtly encouraged to remain in separate spaces.

BTS have spent the better part of a decade challenging those assumptions. They have consistently broken barriers that many people insisted couldn’t be broken. They’ve demonstrated, over and over again, that artists singing predominantly in Korean can compete directly with the biggest Western acts and, in many cases, outperform them commercially, culturally, and globally. They’ve disproved the long held belief that English is a requirement for worldwide success. That isn’t simply an achievement for BTS. It’s something that fundamentally challenged long established ideas within the music industry, and I don’t think everyone has been entirely comfortable with that reality.

I also think another factor is that the Western music industry has never truly been able to control BTS or the company behind them. Despite HYBE expanding internationally and acquiring American labels over the years, BTS themselves have remained remarkably independent compared with many global artists. They’ve never fully fit into the traditional Western industry system, nor have they relied on it in the way many international acts historically have. That independence has always made them something of an outlier, and I don’t think the industry particularly enjoys dealing with artists it can’t easily influence or shape.

Another thing the industry has never really been able to control is BTS’s fanbase. Just as importantly, it has never been able to recreate anything quite like ARMY. Of course, every fandom has its flaws, and I’ve criticised aspects of ARMY many times on this blog. No fandom is perfect. However, if you look at it purely from the perspective of the music industry, what BTS have built is extraordinary. It’s one of the most organised, passionate, dedicated, and influential fan communities ever seen. That’s the sort of relationship every entertainment company wishes it could create, yet very few have managed to replicate. That connection between BTS and ARMY has been one of the defining reasons they’ve reached the position they occupy today.

Because of everything they’ve achieved, BTS are now in the rare position of being able to make decisions like this without fearing the consequences in the same way other artists might. They don’t need to prove their legitimacy anymore. They don’t need a Grammy to validate their career.

That’s particularly striking when you consider the album they’re walking away with. Arirang is, in my opinion, objectively one of the strongest albums they’ve ever released. It’s the sort of record that could very realistically have received multiple Grammy nominations and perhaps even won several categories. And I’m not referring only to the music itself. The album’s artistic direction, its visual identity, the cinematography of the music videos, the production quality, the storytelling, and the overall creative vision all make it feel like a complete artistic project rather than simply a collection of songs.

What’s even more remarkable is that Arirang hasn’t only been embraced by BTS fans. It’s also been widely praised by critics, casual listeners, and the general public. It has been recognised far beyond the boundaries of the fandom. That’s why this decision feels so significant. I don’t quite know which word best captures it. “Risky” doesn’t seem entirely accurate because BTS are in such a secure position. At the same time, “brave” almost feels too simplistic. It sits somewhere between confidence, conviction, and principle. Whatever word eventually fits, it’s a decision that carries genuine weight.

To me, it once again demonstrates the scale of BTS’s influence and the confidence they have in both their artistry and the audience they’ve built over the years. More importantly, it reflects a great deal of self respect. It also reflects respect for their fans, because they’re making it clear that the values they believe in matter more than simply adding another trophy to an already historic career.

By essentially saying, “Don’t divide us. Music is music, and it shouldn’t be separated by language or geography,” they’ve also reopened a much broader conversation. I hope this decision encourages people to once again question whether the Grammys have long standing xenophobic tendencies in the way they approach international artists. More broadly, I hope it prompts discussion about whether the Western music industry as a whole still operates with similar biases, even if those biases aren’t always explicit.

It’s going to be fascinating to watch what happens next. I’m especially curious to see how other K pop groups respond because, whether people like to admit it or not, BTS have spent years setting the tone for much of the industry. If other groups continue submitting their work to the Grammys, and many of them almost certainly will, with some likely receiving nominations and perhaps even winning awards, it will be interesting to see how those decisions are viewed alongside the very clear position BTS have now taken.

After all, we’re talking about the biggest and most successful Korean group the music industry has ever seen. When a group of that stature makes a statement like this, people pay attention.

And do you know what makes this decision even more remarkable?

In all likelihood, and I’m saying this as objectively as I possibly can, the introduction of this new Grammy category probably represented BTS’s clearest opportunity yet to finally win a Grammy.

I don’t say that because I’m trying to diminish other artists or because I think BTS are entitled to the award. I say it because, considering the impact of Arirang, its critical reception, its commercial success, and the influence BTS continue to have worldwide, they would almost certainly have entered that category as one of the strongest contenders.

I’m also fairly certain they understood that. Their management almost certainly understood it too.

And despite recognising that this may well have been their most realistic path towards finally receiving a Grammy, they still chose to step away.

To me, that’s what makes this decision resonate even more deeply. They willingly turned away from what was probably their best chance of achieving the one accolade people have spent years insisting they still “needed” in order to complete their legacy. In doing so, they sent a message that was far more valuable than the trophy itself.

But on a real note, funny how he opens the statement by saying he’s “saddened” and that he “understands and respects” BTS’s decision, but everything that follows undermines that and tries to make it sound like BTS are wrong for doing it.

And if he genuinely believed the category wasn’t trying to box artists, he wouldn’t feel the need to write a whole damn essay defending it. The entire statement comes across as insecure and contradictory, insisting the new category isn’t divisive, yet feels compelled to repeatedly explain why it isn’t.

If the reasoning were that solid, it wouldn’t need this much damage control, and this definitely proves BTS are RIGHT for refusing to participate.

https://x.com/dalisayjmn_/status/2082345063707767172?s=20

i'm with you there, anon. the grammys had it coming. i think this is also the perfect, most appropriate fck-you response from the group. give the energy back, after all, the new category is just an empty consolation award under the guise of recognizing talent. it does not champion inclusivity and artistry; it's disrespectful, widens the gap, and confines asian music and artists instead.

That’s what makes this so fascinating. Technically speaking, BTS belong to the very same industry as those artists. They’re the biggest, most established, and most globally recognised act to come out of it, and in many ways they’ve been the pioneers when it comes to establishing themselves in Western markets. So when a group in that position makes such a principled decision, it inevitably creates a point of comparison for everyone else.

Imagine another K pop group facing exactly the same situation and saying, “I don’t care if this category exists because of my ethnicity or where I was born. I want that nomination. I want that recognition. I want that validation.” The moment they make that decision, people are likely to compare them with BTS, and suddenly the conversation stops being about career strategy and starts becoming a moral debate.

That’s the part I find most interesting. I can’t help wondering whether these conversations are also happening privately. A lot of these artists know each other, and several BTS members are friends with idols from other groups. I genuinely wonder whether they’ve talked about this.

Can you imagine a BTS member saying, “I don’t want recognition in that way anymore. I don’t need it. My fans have already validated my career, and I’ve proved over and over again that I can succeed without that award.” And then another artist replying, “I do want it. I don’t care how it comes. I want that opportunity because it could change my career.”

Neither perspective is necessarily wrong because they come from completely different places. BTS have already reached a level where they can afford to reject something they no longer feel they need. Other artists are still trying to reach that point, and for them a Grammy nomination could genuinely transform their careers. That’s why I think reducing the conversation to who has more integrity completely misses the complexity of the situation.

In that sense, BTS’s decision has placed the rest of the K pop industry in an incredibly interesting position. Whether they like it or not, every artist who chooses to submit, or chooses not to, will probably be compared with BTS. People will inevitably assign meaning to those decisions, even if the motivations behind them are entirely different.

So far, no major K pop artist has publicly supported BTS’s decision. The only notable exception has been Tablo, which makes sense given his own history and perspective. But it’ll be fascinating to see whether anyone else eventually speaks up or whether most artists simply choose to stay silent and make their own decisions behind the scenes.

It’s 2026, and the fact that the Recording Academy thinks they were doing a good thing by creating THAT category, just shows how shortsighted and boxed in they still are. It’s sad and just plain WRONG.