When talking about the distinction between Simon Petrikov and the Ice King,Ā itās important to remember that originally, the Crown wasnāt trying to turn Simon into Ice King -
It was trying to turn him into this guy.
At the time, the Ice Crown - or rather the Wishing Crown - was programmed with Guntherās wish to become Evergreen. So everything related to making the current wearer like Evergreen is a very direct result of the Crownās Magic. The physical changes -
And the obsession with the name āGuntherā -
And maybe some of the irritability and anger issues -
That is something the Crown is very directly forcing unto its current wielder.Ā
Ice King, personality-wise, was not much like Evergreen at all, or even like Gunther's view of him. And Ice Finn of the Farmworld Universe was also pretty different from the both of them.
At the time, I remember people assumed Ice Finnās behavior is more indicative of what the Crown is actually trying to do with its wielders. That Ice King is so different because of Simonās subconscious resistance against the Crown - while Finnās much younger and dumber brain is a lot susceptible to the Curseās influence to become some sort of mad world-conquering emperor of ice and snow.Ā
But, with the context of the Crownās actual backstory. That doesnāt seem very likely anymore. I think whatās actually happening there is that the Crown is just trying to make its wielder an Ice Wizard on par with Evergreen (who was the Actual Goddam Ice Elemental) and that means pumping the wielderās brain so full of Magic, Madness and Sadness to a level that is bound to overwhelm anyone.
And Simonās and Farmworld Finnās very different behaviors after putting on the crown is indicative, more than anything, of how their psyche reacts to Madness and Sadness in general. You know, Finn has a very proactive and kinda aggressive personality - and you add Crown-induced-Madness-and-Sadness and a compulsion to use Ice Magic as much as possible and you get all ofā¦. thisĀ
Meanwhile, for Simon, the compulsions of the Crown originally filtered exclusively via the language of protectionĀ
As his madness always manifested as romantic obsessionĀ
And using goofy humor to try and deny the pain heās going throughĀ
Because thatās how Simonās mind specifically reacts to being flooded with so much Madness and Sadness.
Thatās why thereās so many parallels between Ice King and the sort of mistakes and screwed-up stuff Simon does right now! Heās even kidnapping people again!
Because the Madness and Sadness of Ice King mightāve been induced by the Crown, but now Simon has plenty of personal home-grown Madness and Sadness inside him - and itās no surprise that Curse-Induced or not, his mind reacts to it in a sorta-similar way. (Although obviously not as intensely, again, there was a LOT of MMS in the Ice Crown).
Now as for Ice Thing, and the fact that he seems to be actually rather well-adjusted under effects of his version of the Wishing Crown. I mean... not by the time of the 1000+ Era, but thatās literally eons in the future and also maybe more Gibbonās fault. Even if the Crown will eventually take some sort of toll on him, for now he seems to be doing pretty well considering his wish. I mean, there's still some sort of Loss of Identity stuff going on
But everything we've seen of Ice Thing (in the present day, at least) shows him as a friendly and cheerful individual that gets along well with others. A far cry from how maladjusted every single wielder of the Ice Crown acted.
At the very least, if there's any notable amount of Sadness in him, we really haven't seen it yet.
There might be several factors here:
First things first, I should acknowledge the possibility that itās just that Orgalorgās eldritch brain is better at intaking all that MMS juice. That could play a part, but I think itās probably more important, at least thematically, to look at the distinction between āI wish to be Evergreenā and āI wish to be Ice Kingā.Ā
First in the sense that while Ice King was occasionally mean to Gunter at times - he was generally much kinder than Evergreen ever was for āhisā Gunther. So, like, pretty much the one Personality Flaw of Ice King that you can directly link to the Ice Crownās attempt to mimic Evergreen is the occasional anger issues.
And how they relate to Guntherās view of Evergreen, so grumpy and controlling and constantly saying āNO!ā
(Both Finn and Simonās demonstrable not-crown-induced trauma responses can make them pretty short-tempered as well. So Iām not going to say this is purely the effects of the Crown. It still probably plays some sort of factor at why the wielder of the Ice Crown is Like That).
And that is not a factor in how Gunter views Ice King. For him, Ice King was a doting and loving father figure - so if the Crown was ever trying to implement any sort of specific negative personality traits, this is absolutely no longer a factor. Because the original Ice Crown was a reflection of Evergreenās abuse, and now Ice Thing is a reflection of Ice Kingās fatherly love.
Which is, itself, probably an echo or remnant of Simonās own strong parental instincts.Ā
Secondly, while the Crown was trying to make the Ice King just as powerful as Evergreenā¦. Ice King was obviously not as powerful as Evergreen. Because he was already a second-rate copy of the Ice Elementalās power, and because Ice King was often just too doofy to use his powers correctly and probably because some remnant of Simonās original sensible self is subconsciously holding his powers back.
Either way, being ālike Ice Kingā as Gunter sees him requires less Magic than being ālike Evergreenā as Gunther saw him - and therefore less Madness and Sadness. Leading to the wearer or, um, the eater being a lot more well-adjusted from the get-go.
And I think that the implication that Ice Thing has fused with the Crown, so there's never going to be another poor sap who puts on the Crown and gets Ice King'd. But if there is one somehow... at least the process is going to be less mentally detrimental that time around?
Maybe one day Simon could look back and appreciate how much he (or Ice King, or both of them, or however you want to look at the situation) is responsible for basically neutralizing the Crown that ruined his life in the first place.