Sloppy seconds better than the first? | Sukuna x female reader x Toji smut
Warning: SUPER LONG STORY! modern au, public sex, sloppy seconds, exhibitionism, fingering, blowjob, Cunnilingus, mentions or pregnancy, cream pie threesome: double penetration (1 pussy 2 cocks),? pet names: slut, good girl, darling, dear, sweet pea, and doll are used.
Notes: Megumi is very young in here, I’m thinking elementary, first year of middle school. I hope y’all enjoy I know I enjoyed writing this 🥵
“Thank you so much for hiring me!” You exclaimed happily with a bow. “I will be your new neighbor as well it’s very nice to meet you.”
“Yeah well I figured having the babysitter live right next door will be good incase there’s any emergencies. We can meet up some other time for you to meet my kid and set up which days and times work with both of our schedules.” Toji said looking at you before laying eyes on the bulky, tatted up man standing behind you.
“Yes! Just let me know when and where and I’ll meet you there, for now we have some errands to run. See ya later!”
With that, about a week later you started to babysit his child Megumi while Toji and sukuna was at work. You were paid rather well, and Megumi wasn’t a handful.
But, as much as it was a blessing for his sons babysitter to live next door, for those meetings that pop up, it’s also a curse. The apartment walls are thin, and Toji’s bedroom shares a wall with yours and sukuna’s living room. There’s countless nights Toji can’t help but to touch himself to the sounds of your moans.
“Oh sukuna please, harder please don’t stop” you’d cry out, followed by a grunt by sukuna. “You’re so fucking tight no matter how many times I fuck you. You’re such a whore.”
It pissed him off. Why did you have to be with that tatted up freak? Why couldn’t that be him making you let out those sweet moans and whimpers?
It was 7 in the morning, Toji was getting dressed in his room when there was a thud on the wall. A thud he knew all too well. He placed his ear on the wall, and closed his eyes.
“S-sukuna..you’re going to be late for work.” You whimpered before a smack to your ass was heard.
“So what’s a few minutes to a half an hour? It can wait. You just look so fucking sexy in this silk dress I can’t help it. You might as well be teasing me.” Sukuna mumbled against your lips before pushing his tongue inside your mouth, his hand sliding down to lift your leg up, before grinding himself onto your clothed pussy making you moan into the kiss. He pulled away from your lips, only to attack your lips as he dropped your leg and slid 2 of his thick fingers into your cunt. “S-sukuna..” you whimpered when he pushed onto that gummy spot on the inside that made your legs shake.
“You’re always so wet for me. You’re my slut.” He continues to spew dirty compliments as his fingering gets rougher and deeper.
“Sukuna..I-” “what? Are you about to cum just by my fingering you? You’re such a slut you better cum on my fingers.” You moaned, his pace quickening as he places his thumb on your clit, adding extra pressure until you finally release all over his fingers. He lets you ride out your high, as he praises you before pulling them out and making you taste yourself. Once his fingers were clean, he made you keep your underwear on one ankle as he pushed down his pants and underwear just enough for his cock to spring free as he lifted you up.
Your loud moan rang through toji’s room as sukuna stretched out your tiny tight pussy for the unkept time. Oh how your moans could make Toji bust a nut without even touching his dick. If only half of the time you weren’t moaning out that bastards name he just might.
It was around 7:25, the thumping against the wall had stopped, meaning sukuna had filled up your pussy, and was making out with you as he made you stand up as he quickly pulled your panties back up.
“Don’t change your panties until I get home, and keep as much as my cum inside of you as you can, and I’ll eat your pussy out real good ok?” He says fixing his pants, then a quick kiss to your lips.
“I love you and I can’t wait to come home to you.” He says softly before leaving, leaving you with shaking legs as you tried to catch your breath. A minute rolled by and there was a soft knock at the door, you unlocked it and opened the door, you trying your best to hide yourself behind the door.
“Oh, m-mr. Fushiguro, you’re up early. Good morning.” You squeak out.
Toji quickly allowed his eyes to slide down to your exposed cleavage, your hardened nipple exposed through the silk fabric before meeting your gaze and clearing his throat. “Please I told you to call me Toji y/n. Indeed I am early and I do apologize for such a late notice but I just got called in for a meeting, and my house is a little bit of a mess since megumi is getting over a tiny head cold. I will pay you extra if you come over and make sure megumi takes his medicine every 3 hours and clean up the house a bit. How does an extra 50 sound?”
“Way too much I don’t mind helping out, but if you don’t mind waiting just 3 minutes so I can get dressed. I don’t want megumi to be left alone since anything can happen.”
“Yes just please hurry.” ‘If I keep standing here I don’t think I can contain myself.’ He thought as you quickly thanked him and excused yourself.
It was a warm summer day, so you settled on a cotton dress and a pair of slip on and off sandals, before brushing your hair and quickly leaving your apartment. “Alright all dressed.” You said with a quick giggle, making Toji laugh before raising his hand as a goodbye. “I’ll leave it all up to you.”
The day was pretty easy, megumi wasn’t in the mood to play so you allowed him to watch tv and lay in his bed as you cooked him a small breakfast and tidied up the living room and kitchen. It was hard to move around much as you felt sukuna’s cum start to leak out. ‘Damn him’ you thought.
Around 10:15, Toji came back home, you were cleaning megumi’s plate and the dishes you dirtied to make the food. “Ah, welcome back Toji, I hope the meeting wasn’t too boring.” You laughed putting the plate up into the cabinet.
“I was able to stay awake during this one.” He chuckled walking over and placing the keys on the kitchen island before looking at you. His eyes wandered down to the hem of your dress. It rested just at the bottom rounds of your ass, your underwear peeking out. More importantly, with your legs kind of parted, he could see sukuna’s cum leaking down your leg. The thought of his seed leaking out of your cunt and down your leg made his pants get tight. He knew he shouldn’t but he couldn’t handle it anymore. This was his last straw. He walked over to you, flipped you over so you were facing him, and harshly kissed you with tongue. Your eyes widened, was this really happening? You could feel his hard cock pushing against you. Toji placed his hand on your jaw, his eyes full of lust looking into yours when he pulled away.
“My dear, you seem to be leaking something.” He says with a chuckle before grabbing your underwear and pulling them down, commanding you to step out of them. “He made a mess out of these huh?” He asked. Your stomach turned hearing his shit eating grin as he asked that question. Toji got down on his knees, making you spread your legs a little more before he ran his fingers across your cum covered folds. “He sure made a mess of you, huh?” He chuckled, bringing his face close to your pussy, making it clutch around nothing. He licked your clit before pushing his face into it more, sucking,licking, and biting the sensitive bud as he shoved 2 fingers in your cunt, making some of sukuna’s cum leak out.
You let out a whimper. “W-we shouldn’t be doing this..I-I have sukuna..and I love him..a-and what if megumi walks in on u-us-ah” you bit your lip to conceal your moans as Toji started scissoring his fingers inside. Your pussy burned, was his fingers bigger than sukuna’s?
Toji ignored you as his focus was bringing you your first orgasm with him. He continued to abuse your cunt as he added a third finger inside, making you suck into a sharp breath.
Toji pulled away from your clit, only to thrust his fingers harder into you. “Don’t tell me after all of the times I’ve heard you and your boyfriend fucked I’m stretching you out?”
“Y-you heard us have sex this m-morning?”
“Oh not just this morning sweet pea, all the times, since you’ve moved in I’ve heard you fuck every single time you decide that living room is where you’ll get his apparently tiny dick.”
“S-sukuna doesn’t have a t-tiny di-a-ah” you bit your lip as you came on his fingers making Toji smirk as he let you ride out your orgasm before pulling them out, and watching the rest of sukuna’s cum you had inside come out.
He quickly lapped up the juices on his fingers before he pulled down his pants. Your eyes grew wide when you seen he had no underwear on. He was so much longer than sukuna’s. You were quickly shoved onto your knees, his cock now right in front of your face. Toji slapped his cock against your cheek before grabbing a fist full of your hair. “Suck.” He commanded darkly, making a shiver go down your spine as you opened your mouth. Your tongue toying with his slit before swirling around his massive mushroom tip. “Tch. I said suck not tease.” He said shoving his cock into your mouth until his tip hit the back of your throat, making you choke.
“Oh fuck this feels good.” He groaned out, fucking your face until he was satisfied. Once he was, he pulled out. And making you bend against the kitchen island. He rubbed his dick against your folds, pushing his tip in a little bit, then pulling it back out. One hand on his dick, the other holding your hands together.
“Please Toji..I love sukuna..if he found out he’ll be crushed..I won’t tell anyone about this if you let me go no-o-ow!” A harsh slap to your ass made you gasp.
“Your pleas are cute, but no one will find out about this one time thing. Just think of it as an apology for putting your neighbor through hell and having to listen to the two of you fuck.” He says bitterly, the hand that slapped your ass once again going to his dick to pump it a few times before shoving his cock inside. You choke out a sob, your pussy burning. “I-it hurts..” he slid his hand down to rub your clit, as he littered your shoulder with kisses.
“Man your boyfriend must really be small if I’m stretching you out.” He chuckles darkly, as he rolled his hips, hearing you moan, which told him it no longer hurt. His hand left your clit to leave another nice smack onto your ass as his thrusts picked up the pace.
“Tell me, does it feel good? Despite you earlier begging for me to not do this you seem to be really enjoying yourself.” He says looking into the mirror that faces the kitchen island. He watched as your face shows nothing but pleasure as you desperately bit your lip trying to stay quiet for little megumi’s sake.
“I-it does feel good..but it’s so wrong.”
“It’s not wrong unless he finds out.” He says lifting your leg up to go deeper. Your legs shake as your orgasm quickly approaches.
“Oh shit im going to cum.” You moaned out, making Toji grunt. “Me too.”
His thrusts becoming sloppy as he chased his high. “What if I cum inside you hm?”
“Why not? Don’t tell me you and that bastard are trying for a kid..”
You were silent other than the soft whimpers you couldn’t hold back. Toji laughed. “Oh shit for real? Now wouldn’t it be funny if you became pregnant with my kid instead of your bastard of a boyfriends?”
“Please don’t cum inside please to-o” you couldn’t finish your sentence as your orgasm washed over you making you see stars. Your pussy clenching down on Toji made him squirt his seed right into your tight cunt.
His twitching cock made your eyes go wide as you looked back at him. “Y-you didnt..”
“I’m sorry my dear you just felt so good I couldn’t pull out.” He let go of you, turning you around to kiss you. Once he pulled back, he handed you your underwear off the floor. “You better run home and try to push all of my seed out so we don’t accidentally give megumi a sister or brother.”
Sukuna was forced to stay at work over longer than either of you anticipated. It was around 4pm when he finally came home. You welcomed him home with the usual kiss hug and a warm “welcome home love” even though guilt was eating you.
“Mm what did I do to deserve you? You’re so good to me.” He says planting a kiss onto your forehead. “Say, let’s have dinner and then I can finally devour my dessert. We’re you able to keep some of my cum inside?”
His eyes finally met yours. He quickly noticed your glossy eyes, the corners being red, your eyes puffy. “Darling..have you been crying?”
“N-no..I’m fine sukuna don’t worry about it.”
Sukuna let out a sigh, grabbing your hand and leading you to the couch to sit down. “No lies doll. Tell me what’s eating at you? I’ll love you no matter what.”
Your eyes watered as you came clean about what had happened that day quietly so Toji wouldn’t hear.
“That bastard!” Sukuna yelled, making you slap your hand over his mouth.
“Shh. I don’t want him to know that you know.”
“Wait, you’re not thinking about going back are you!?”
“I have to..I told megumi I’d help him with his school project he got for missing school. Toji won’t be there tomorrow he’s working all day-”
“I will be going with you to babysit megumi tomorrow. I don’t want to take any chances of that happening again.” He pulls you into a loving kiss before pulling away and resting his forehead on yours.
“Besides..we can use the extra money I’m earning to hurry up and move out of this apartment..with your overtime and my babysitting job and bakery job..just another month and we can leave.”
Sukuna nodded. After comforting you, the two of you ate, and the two of you cuddled in bed, neither of you feeling up to the promise he made to you earlier.
The next day, Sukuna met megumi, and watched the child and you work on his school project with loving eyes. He hopes one day he can watch this with his kid. Oh how you’re showing him you’d be the perfect mother.
It was around 10:30 when the door handle jiggled open, Sukuna was the one to put megumi down to rest an hour ago, leaving the two of you to cuddle up and watch tv until Toji got home. “Oh y/n, I’m back.” He coos, turning around to shut the door.
“Hey.” Sukuna’s deep voice boomed, making Toji spin around to see the two of you.
“My..I didn’t know I had to set boundaries for you bringing over visitors y/n.” Toji said with a sharp tongue.
“Ah, you see, I’m not a visitor.” Sukuna started, grabbing your hand and standing up, making you stand up too. “I’m her fiancé, and we will be taking our leave now. Enjoy your night.” Sukuna said shoulder checking Toji as the two of you left to your apartment.
A week went by that you didn’t have to babysit megumi. Toji was on vacation so he was able to spend all the time with megumi. The following Monday, you had to babysit megumi. The day started at 7, packing your fiancé’s lunch, and getting dressed so you could run a few errands before taking megumi to school.
“Are you sure you’re going to be ok?” Sukuna asked fixing his tie before looking at you.
“Yes. By the time I arrive, Toji should have already left leaving me to get megumi up and ready before I walk him to school.”
“If anything seems off give me a call ok? I have to head out a little earlier since my normal train is down. I love you.” He kisses your cheek and heads out the door, a quick “I love you more” leaving your mouth before silence filled the apartment, making you sigh. “Alright, let’s start the day.” You said sliding on your shoes and heading out the door.
After putting the groceries away, you went over to your neighbors. Once you opened the door, a hand grabbed your wrist and pulled you inside. Your back meeting the cold wall beside the door as lips roughly met yours, yours and toji’s tongues wrestling for dominance. Your heart started pounding in your chest. What is he still doing home?!
Once he pulled away, he captured your wrists in his so you couldn’t leave.
“T-Toji what are you doing here you’re-”
“Supposed to be at work?” He cuts you off. “Yeah, well sweet pea, I go back to work tomorrow. But I wanted you all to myself. How dare you bring that bastard of a fiancé into my home. How disrespectful.” He spats before looking at the big window in his living room, an idea forming in his brain. With a chuckle, he drags you over to the window, ripping your shirt to expose your bra. His hand scoops out your breasts before pushing you up against the window. “Now wouldn’t it be embarrassing if those pedestrians saw you? You cheating on your fiancé. You’re such a slut for me. Your pussy sucked my dick in to the deepest part of it the last time we fucked. You moaned so beautifully. I want more.” He says kissing your neck, his fingers sliding into your skirt and panties to rub and twist your clit.
“Ah shit I was in such a hurry I can’t believe I forgot my lunchbox I’m gonna be so late!” Sukuna sighs as he runs back to your apartment complex.
“S-Sukuna..” you moan out as Toji licks your sweet spot on your neck. “Oh? Let’s have him hear your pretty little moans. How do you think he’d feel knowing you’re about to get dicked down by me?”
“Please stop-ah~” Sukuna heard once the elevator doors slid open. Those moans sounding all too familiar. His blood ran cold as he quietly yet quickly walked up to find the door to toji’s apartment cracked. Peering in, he saw you pressed against the window, skirt and panties discarded onto the floor, with toji’s fingers buried deep into your pussy- no, his pussy. Sukuna slid the door open and slid inside.
“Well. What’s going on here?” Sukuna asks, making Toji chuckle before lifting you up, exposing your wet cunt to the other man.
“Your girl is enjoying getting slutted out by the guy next door. She loves how I stretch her out, just look how wet she is by just my fingers. You should have seen her the first time. All creamy. Her pussy devouring my cock as it pushed out your cum to make room for mine.”
Something snapped inside of Sukuna. “Oh? So you think my girl likes the feeling of you inside her more than me? Maybe we should see about that.” He says walking over to you, resting his hand on your jaw. “Is that ok, dear? Just cry out the name thats making you feel the most pleasure.” You nodded, earning a snicker of laughter from both men. Toji dropped you, instructing you to wrap your arms and legs around Sukuna once both of them got undressed. Once you were hoisted back into the air, Toji grabbed your hips.
“This might hurt a little, ok dear?” Sukuna says kissing your face before he slides his cock inside. With one swift movement, Toji shoved his cock into your pussy. You let out a sob of pain. Sukuna shushed you, licking your tears away. “I know pretty girl I know it’ll feel good soon I promise.” He says before capturing your lips with his.
Both men allowed minutes to pass before Toji rolled his hips, getting irritated at the lack of movement. When a whimper escaped your lips, Toji took that as an ok to move, and roughly rolled his hips again. The same time Sukuna pulled out, just to shove his cock back in. You moaned. Your pussy still burned, but having 2 cocks shoved deep into your pussy felt so good.
Toji having the longer cock was kissing the tip of your cervix with each thrust, but Sukuna having the thicker cock was rubbing against your g-spot, his abdomen rubbing against your clit had you crying out his name. Your legs shook with pleasure, coating both of their cocks with cream.
“S-Sukuna..so good..You feel so good inside me.” You whimper out, earning a hard smack to your ass from Toji that made you yelp. “Have you forgotten about me back here?” He asked sliding a hand from your hip to your breast to play with your nipple.
“T-Toji..stop they’re s-sensitive..”
“Oh? That’s a tell tell sign that you could be pregnant. Wouldn’t it be funny if my one load made you pregnant?”
Sukuna laughed. “You know how many times I’ve filled her up compared to you old man?” He asks harshly as his thrusts became become faster and rougher. Your body starts to spasm, Sukuna abusing your g-spot. You couldn’t help but cry out his name, your gummy walls clamping down on both cocks as you cum.
“Ah that’s a good girl. Cumming and crying for me.” Sukuna softly says kissing you, making Toji ‘tch’ behind you before ramming his cock into you, his tip roughly abusing the tip of your cervix.
“T-Toji too rough..” you cried out making Toji chuckle. “So you finally remembered I’m back here? I’m going to make you cum all over me.”
“S-stop..too rough..it hurts..”
“Take it slut.” He says ramming harder into you, your walls clamping hard around the two cocks, making Sukuna suck in a breath as his orgasm quickly approaches.
“C-cumming” you choke out between sobs, bringing all of you over the edge.
Toji was the first to pull out and put his clothes back on.
“You did so well, are you ok?” Sukuna asks kissing your cheek. You nodded. As Sukuna sat you down to stand up, your body trembled with pain. Sukuna helped you get dressed before dressing himself.
“So. We need to reach a verdict of this little experiment.” Toji says who was sitting on the couch this whole time. “Who fucks you better, y/n?”
“S-sukuna..you’re too rough Toji..and I told you before, I love Sukuna.”
“There, that settles it. Now then.” Sukuna starts, picking you up. “I will be the one to say after this month ends, you need to find a new babysitter. Aside from that, if I find you touching what’s mine after this day, be prepared to lose some fingers. You hurt her, and took advantage of her kindness. You’re sick. She’s only a babysitter, not your personal slut.”
With that, Sukuna left with you, wasting no time to go into your shared apartment and locking it.
“I love you darling. How does a warm bath sound? I’m sorry he was so rough. I hope you can forgive me. After the bath how about I make us some food and we cuddle and watch a movie yeah? I just need to make a quick phone call to the company to tell them I’m using my 3 days off to extend my vacation. I put you through hell today, so I will be treating you like the princess you are my whole vacation”
I’m so sorry if the ending felt rushed I was fearful it was too long so please give me feedback on how I did. Thank you for reading to the end💜
