Just had a ridiculous idea based on my Amnesiac Fiyercrow idea:
Elphaba captures all the Witch Hunters, instead of just Dorothy, and Scarecrow is like "Why don't we just talk and work things out without violence?" Elphaba is like "What?" and Boq is like "What? Also fuck no" and Dorothy is like "I like that idea"
Like, before, Dorothy did not want to kill the Wicked Witch of the West, and Scarecrow grabs onto this like "Yeah, we should totally try to talk things through" and Boq is not on board, but Scarecrow wants to give the witch a chance because he's thinking "Oh she's so pretty and sad, I want to make her happy" and I suppose deep down he remembers her or something, but really it's just because she's hot
Anyway, they all get captured in this universe, and Scarecrow wants to talk things through because he thinks the Witch is pretty, and she's like unimpressed but then, I'm sorry this is very amusing to me, he leans forward, and like smiles, try to be charming and compliments her and shit (100% Fiyero peaking through the memory fog), and Elphaba is thinking "is this Scarecrow trying to seduce me????" and that knocks her out of balance enough for her to accept talking instead of fighting. And Scarecrow actually is trying to seduce her, he doesn't quite understand what he's feeling right now or what he's trying to accomplish, but he is trying to flirt with the Witch
Boq is of course not for talking but his companions being dumb, and Elphaba stopped freaking out for 10 seconds so he has no choice
And oh yeah, Lion was too afraid to fight the Witch so talking sounds good to him
Of course Elphaba needs to figure out the Scarecrow is Fiyero with amnesia eventually, probably when the two are alone (well that explains the flirting) but actually it freaks her out, (Scarecrow is like, fuck I messed up)
