my hot take is that thereโs no world in which bagginshield could work, and thatโs Why it works
like ur not getting mr erebor 3000 to move to the shire Ever and ur not getting mr shire 3000 to move to erebor Ever!!! neither of those things are happening!!!
bagginshield can only exist on the road, in that tenuous stretch of time between one home and another, when โhomeโ is synonymous with โpartnershipโ and as transient as the passing stream THERE IS NO BAGGINSHIELD AFTER THE FACT!
in an ideal world, where Thorin lives and Fili and Kili do too, even after the party has settled and the dragon is dead, youโre telling me BILBO BAGGINS is not going RIGHT back home? he was always going to go home. HE WAS ALWAYS GOING TO GO HOME.
because the thing that fuels him, the fundamental injustice he sees before him, the great wrong that must be righted is that Home; this beautiful, necessary, indelible fixture of the heart has been Stripped away from these people, and there is no injustice so terrible as that! the lack of Home!
so of course Bilbo went back. of course he did. because the thing that matters, the whole point of this whole story, was always Home.
Honestly I see your point, especially when it comes to Thorin, we would have to change him fundamentally as a person for him to willingly live in the Shire, but I'm at crossroads with Bilbo. Because yes, he sees Shire as his home, as the place he can always come back to but to what extent after the journey itself and after actually being accepted by the dwarves?
Because before the journey, he was already ostracised for most of his life for being different than a typical Hobbit, and when he did come back, he stood out even more. Hell, he barely had people there who he could count on seeing as the moment they thought him dead, they decided to rob him!
Knowing that, would it be so crazy to believe that, without the grief and pain after losing people who he valued and loved so deeply, he would like to stay? Personally, I don't think so. Perhaps he would go back, but I don't think he would stay for long because in the end what is a Home? Sometimes it's a place, sure, but sometimes it's the people who make it and with Bilbo it could go either way imo.
(But I also love your opinion, it's so very poetic, makes their relationship so special and tragic ๐)























