Another David Warner role I made a partner for woops. XD
Hereâs here bio/backstory/short story thing.
So in the film(The Island 1980), Michael Caineâs character wakes up tied up, as does his son. His son is taken away to be brainwashed, so that Nau can make him believe that his father is not Caine but Nau. Caine is presented to a woman who says he killed her man in the attack of capturing his son and himself, so she tells Nau and the other men that sheâll take him as a new husband. Itâs revealed later that most of the women are inbred and that the pirates look for healthy women to bare children whenever they raid ships.
So in this AU, Captain Nau isnât the antagonist, but a decent man.
At @cinefantastiquemithoâ suggestion, I recycled the name of the oc made for Young Captain Hook, Elinor many years ago.. Â
(Credit to @cinefantastiquemithoâ for her origins)
 Elinor is an orphan who grew up on the carribean island, Nevis. While she did befriend the children, she never experienced parental affection from the adults. None were cruel, just distant.Â
Elinor herself is kind and friendly, but can be emotionally distant because she has not experienced a family life or love. When she was 18, no longer property of the state, Elinor attended community college for clothing designing and got a job as a seamstress. She has always had a knack for art and crafting as she grew up.
In her late 20s, she looks for a new job in California and boards a small plane to make the journey. The plane crashes and she washes ashore the island.Â
A motherly character called Nadia, and Beth (the woman in the original film that picks Caine) nurse Elinor to health in order to present her to the Captain and to the men. I have written in a separate Tumblr post about how when presented to the village, sheâs told to pick a husband.
That can be found here, as well as Nauâs POV of when she picks him and becomes his wife:
https://amalthea9.tumblr.com/post/636730633416245248/asks-answers-for-elinor-nau
The relationship is a slow burn, because, obviously, Elinor lived with 80s technology and now she not only has a husband she doesnât know, but she has to learn to wash clothes by hand, cook, and other responsibilities of 17th century life. She also resents Nau, and her whole situation. But she does befriend Nadia, Beth, and the other women. Nau doesnât demand sex, as Elinor expected him to. He doesnât believe in forcing a woman to have sex, he treats Elinor with respect. He didnât love her in the beginning either, he accepted her as wife because she liked how her eyes were like the sea. Â
But one day, about a month in, he sees Elinor sketching a bird on some parchment and charcoal she found. Sheâs smiling, the first time heâs ever seen her smile. From that point forward, he begins to fall for her. He even tries to please her with a sketchbook and pencils he acquired during the raids. Elinor is surprised by this act of kindness. The acts of kindness from Nau continue. Nau takes her out to sea to see the sunset, little things like that.Â
During one of the raids, Nau is shot and when heâs brought back to the island, he is delirious with blood loss. Elinor is told to attend him as the doctor works to get the bullet out and stitch him up.
Nadia is called in also as the nurse, instructing Elinor how to keep Nau conscious. She whispers to Elinor as they prepare for the removal of the bullet.
âI know you donât love him, dear. But put that aside because he needs you right now more than anyone.â
And as though on cue, Nau starts crying out for Elinor in his delirious state.
Elinor comes to his side, and finds herself genuinely caring for him, because she sees his tears and how much pain heâs in. He grabs for her hand, and she takes it. Her words of comfort are genuine, stroking his sweat drenched head.
With the bullet removed, itâs now up to Nau to survive the night. He passes out, and Elinor is left alone with him. Elinor finds herself afraid that he will die, and she tearfully whispers.
âI donât love youâŚGodâŚI donât know what I feel towards youâŚbutâŚpleaseâŚJohnâŚdonât leave me alone."Â
She passes out from exhaustion, by his side on the mat. In the morning, Nau wakes from his fever, and sees Elinor next to him, her hand over his.
"Elinor?â He says, voice hoarse.
Elinor stirs and sees he is awake. She smiles, a genuine smile of relief.
Nau smiles weakly back, âYouâre hereâŚmy wifeâŚâ
âYes, John,â she whispers back, squeezing his hand. âIâm here.â
The next 2 weeks Nau is recovering, and he becomes bored. Elinor asks if the pirates have any books, and Nau says they have stacks of them stored at Hizzonerâs hut, but they arenât sorted. He says she can go through them. Elinor goes and looks through the books, and she finds various books, Including Frankenstein and Shakespeareâs The Tempest. She takes the books back to Nau, showing what she got. At this point, Nau confesses that he doesnât read very well, Elinor deducts that his level of reading might be 9 to 12 years in reading level. He meekly asks if she would read to him. Elinor is slightly annoyed, still conflicted by her feelings for him, but she agrees, his blue eyes looking so sweet as he asks. Nau sees the Tempest in the stack and asks for that one first. Elinor says itâs a play, not a novel, not really something to read aloud.
âThen why did you bring it home?â Nau asks.
Elinor sighs, âBecause it is my favorite Shakespeare play.â
âThen I want you to read that one,â Nau states softly. âPlease, ElinorâŚâ
Elinor sees the sincerity in his eyes, and it warms her heart. She agrees, and begins reading the play.
As soon as she says it begins on a ship, Nau eagerly interrupts by asking if itâs a pirate ship. Elinor, bemused, says itâs a nobleman ship. When she relates the ship crashes on an island, Nau interrupts again asking if itâs an island with pirates.
âIf you interrupt me again, John,â Elinor scolds. âI wonât read the rest!â
But a smile plays on her lips.
Nau apologizes, looking like a kicked pup and says he wonât do it again.
Elinor comes to the part where Prince Ferdinand confesses his love for Miranda. Unknown to her, Nau now sees her as his Miranda, and he is listening intently to Ferdinandâs lines.Â
That night, in her separate mat, she hears him quietly reading those lines over and over again under candlelight in his mat. But she doesnât understand why he is memorizing those lines.
Every day after that, Nau asked if Elinor would read more books to him, even helping him improve in his reading. Elinor continues to go through the piles of books, finding other fairy tales and famous novels. Nau loved everything she read to him, because it was her reading it. And Elinor enjoyed it too, enjoying to see his eager smile as she started with a new chapter or book.
Once Nau is healed, another raid is announced, and Elinor finds herself being worried about him. He is, at this point, at least a dear friend to her. Nau sees her worry and kisses her forehead assuring her he will return unharmed.Â
That day, Elinor finds herself going to the beach and just watching the sea for him. Nau is at the front of the boat when they see Elinor on the shore, her strawberry blonde hair loose and flowing in the ocean wind.Â
âDo I see a siren of Greek myths on the shore?!â Hizzoner inquires.Â
But Nau beams as he replies, âNo Hizzoner! No siren, but a sea goddess. My wife!"Â
And to the crewâs laughter and cheering, Nau jumps into the ocean to swim to her.
Nau runs to Elinor and wraps her up in his arms, Elinor letting out a cry of surprise.
Elinor laughs as she complains that he is soaking wet, and Nau apologizes as he releases her.Â
But he is all smiles as he says, âTo see you on the shore greeting me, my sea goddess. I couldnât help myself.â
Elinor feels her chest tighten, hearing the adoration in his voice. She smiles sweetly at him as he takes her hand, and he tells her of all that was accumulated from the raid.
It is shortly after these events that Elinor and Nau have sexual encounters.
The first time was when they had been caught in a thunderstorm and ran to their hut.Â
Desire for each other had been building seemed to release as the clouds did release the rain. No words are spoken during, and Elinor is still not giving herself to Nau in love. She states this is not âloveâ but that she desires him. Nau, though fully in love with her at this point, doesnât force his love upon her.
"Then I shall love for us both,â he replies, kissing her forehead.
Every time they have sex when Nau asks her to stay, Elinor quickly leaves the mat. Saying things like, âChores to be done early.â or âNot yet.â
(Credit to @cinefantastiquemithoâ for having this idea)
In the weeks following these events, Elinor has been visiting the shoreline at night. Nau has been sending men to watch her in the shadows, making sure she isnât building a raft to escape or anything like that. Elinor knows this, and she comes to a point of confronting Nau about it in their hut. Nau doesnât know how to address the issue, his fear of losing her has become very strong. But Elinor breaks her calm composure and lets her anger through.
âTo have the CHOICE, Nau!!!â she cries. âTo be given a CHOICE is all I ask of you!â
Nau stares at her, surprised by her outburst and seeing the distress and pain he has caused her.Â
Elinor sighs and takes a breath.
âDo you remember the story of The Beauty and the Beast I read to you?â
âYes, of course,â Nau replies softly.
âWhat did the Beast do when Belle discovered her father was ill?â Elinor asks.
âHeâŚlet her goâŚ,â Nau answers quietly, realizing what Elinor is trying to tell him.
Elinor is silent as she looks to the ground, hoping that Nau will understand what she is getting at. Nau is quiet for a moment, then speaks.
âI promise, Elinor,â Nau begins, his voice solemn. âAs the Captain of this island andâŚas one who loves you. I will not send any men to follow you tonight.â
Elinor, keeping her eyes to the ground, nods and exits the hut quietly. Nau watches her leave, realizing that, as the Beast realizedâŚÂ
If he truly loves herâŚhe will let her go if she wants to.
That evening, Elinor goes to the ocean shore, with her basket to collect seashells. And true to his word, Elinor is alone this time, and she knows it. She stands at the shore, the sea lapping at her feet.
The thought of simply plunging into the sea comes to her mind. She begins to cry quietly, as images of Nau come to her mind. His smile, his expression of agony and fear as the doctor tried to work on his wound. She thought of his sweet words of asking her to read further, although he was exhausted and needed to sleep. The feeling of his arms around her, how he always held her in reverence.Â
She softly sobbed as she looked out into the sea. She canât leave himâŚshe can'tâŚ
She has guarded her heart for so long, that the thought of finally letting Nau have it scared her. But then againâŚisnât that part of love? To be scared to give your heart to someone else?
As Elinor returns at sunset from the beach, she sees Nau in the distance. Her heart skips when she sees his adoring and relieved smile. He runs to her and embraces her and expresses close to tears how he feared she wouldnât choose to come back.Â
Elinor gently embraces him in return, her heart filling with all of the love and adoration she has held back come through.
âIâŚI couldnât goâŚJohnâŚâ she whispers into his shoulder. âIâŚwould leave something precious behindâŚâ
âWhat would that be, my love?â he asks softly, kissing her hair.
"My heartâŚâ Elinor whispers into his chest, clutching at his vest.
âElinor?â He asks worriedly as he pulls away enough to see her face.
Elinor shakes her head, tears starting to form in her eyes. She smiles a small smile up at him and takes his hand. Without a word between them, they make their way back to their hut.
When they get inside, Nau is still confused and hurting to see Elinor upset. Elinor releases his hand and turns away from him. After a few seconds, Elinor turns to face Nau. The tears stream down her face, as she nearly whispers.
âYou really do love me, donât you, JohnâŚ"Â
She says this as if itâs more for her to hear allowed than a question to him.Â
Nauâs heart lurches in his chest, pained to see her so upset. But also to see her doubt of his love for her.Â
Nau takes a few steps closer, and begins to speak softly.Â
"O heaven, O earth, bear witness to this sound. And crown what I profess with kind event if I speak true! If hollowly, invert what best is boded me to mischief! I beyond all limit of what else iâ thâ world. Do love, prize, honor you.â
Elinorâs heart pounds as she hears Nau quoting Ferdinandâs lines. She realizes that he memorized those lines so that he could say them to her when the right moment came.Â
New tears form as her steps closes the gap between them, pressing her forehead to his chest.Â
Nau immediately embraces her, holding her as tight as he can. He begins kissing her hair, and as she lifts her head, he kisses her forehead tenderly. He kisses at her tears, then her lips. Elinor kisses him back passionately, pouring into it all of the love she has kept hidden.Â
That night is the first night that Elinor does not leave the bed after sex. Nau notices this, as she lays against him, her head on his chest. He doesnât inquire about the change in her behavior, but he wraps her up in his arms lovingly.
Elinor and Nau have two children, Alexander Ulysses Nau (conceived the night Elinor gave her heart to Nau), and Miranda Ariel Nau four years after Alexanderâs birth.
***the necklace featured in this piece is from a time early in their relationship that Nau finds a pearl and presents it to Elinor. Elinor keeps the pearl in a box, appreciating his gesture but still not in love with him. But when she does give her heart to him, she has the pearl set in a necklace.***