Blog Masterpost: Sherlock & Co. Theories and Post-Episode Commentaries
(Newest to oldest episodes, scrolling down)
✨Revised timeline proposal✨
Updated Timeline Commentary for Missing Time in Sherlock's Past: Six Parts
(Written after Part 1 of The Empty House, but doesn't generally incorporate info from there)
Part 1: Could Sherlock logistically have started boarding at Dulwich at age 11?
Part 2: Boarding House Bonanza (where could Sherlock have boarded at Dulwich, and effects of Reginald living nearby)
Part 3: The Road to Dulwich (implications of evidence of the exclusivity on being a boarder at the college for Sherlock, time before the school)
Part 4: Dulwich, and Implications for Sherlock’s Academic Arc: Theories on Burnout/A Fall From Grace
Part 5: Post-Dulwich school types and Sherlock’s Experiences: Pure Speculation (and explaining those runaway references)
Part 6: Meeting Lestrade and Becoming a Consulting Detective (Was Sherlock still a minor at the time? Where was Mycroft in all that?)
+Includes final thoughts on why I think all of this school speculation and laying out Sherlock's status in the family as a teenager might matter more than it seems when it comes to Reichenbach
The Six Napoleons🗿🤴
🌟I think I figured it out: The Comprehensive, Cross-referenced, Compulsively Caveated Sherlock & Co. Timeline🌟 +Updates now available! Additional commentary and revisions to ideas spread out across 6 posts above. Timeline at top of post is the latest version
Expanded section (bulletpoint reasoning still contained in main post): ->Part 1/3: Mariana's age, Lily's age range, and narrowing down the latter Expanded section (bulletpoint reasoning still contained in main post): ->Part 2/3: Sherlock's age, time at Dulwich, and age range for his expulsion Expanded section (bulletpoint reasoning still contained in main post): ->Part 3/3: Sherlock's starting year and date range for Dulwich, possible years for expulsion, and how old he could've been when meeting the Lestrades
Everything That We Know or Can Infer About Mycroft Holmes: Age, Personality, and Clues about Relationship to Sherlock (Raising him, being on the outs or not, comparisons of "genius", etc) +Note: I wrote this up before Part 1 of the Six Napoleons came out, it was just hell of a coincidence that his role/more references to him ended up being involved sooner than I expected
Sherlock raised by Mycroft?: Speculation on Age Differences, Any Changes to Canon, and Family Roles (Golden Child versus Troublemaker) +Also written before additional information in Part 1 and 2, but nothing disconfirmed by them
The Musgrave Ritual
Thoughts on Bullying in Sherlock & Co., and the Bully Redemption narrative in The Musgrave Ritual
Reframe Reginald's Perspective So That He Assumed...: potential story adjustments as a lens for analysis, and considering blind spots
"He Punished Me In Every Way You Could Imagine" Translated: A Glossary of Coordinated Physical Harassment and Abuse, including Injury Risk, in The Musgrave Ritual of Sherlock & Co.
There's (Still) Something Up with The Musgrave Ritual: A Theory and Analysis +Reblog with addition about Emery's VA work for this being unusual -Written after conclusion of The Stockbroker's Clerk
The Hound of the Baskervilles
Reaction to Part One, initial thoughts on Watson's forlorn introduction, and DIY transcript (since that opening was strangely not in the official one...) Some timeline thoughts on the Seldens, speculation on Steven Seldens upbringing +Note: Written after Part 8, before conclusion to story
Speculation on potential Moriarity role in HOUND, theory for Steven Selden connection +Note: Written after Part 8, before conclusion to story
Are the biscuits poisoned???: Brief steam-of-consciousness panicking about getting towards the end of Hound without the fearful mood in Watson's intro being resolved
[Below the cut: posts on The Missing Three-Quarter, and general speculation on Moriarity's identity, background, and connection to Sherlock in this 'verse]
















