cindy lou, who? - L.HC
lee haechan x fem reader
wc: ~9.1k
warnings: mentions of drinking, angst, fluff, i never know what to put here sorry, miscommunication if that bugs you, unrequited love sort of
A/N: guys i hate writing.. why do i do it LMFAO anyways this is inspired by "cindy lou who" by sabrina carpenter.. love her downnn that song is so angsty its perfect. i started writing this when it was actually holiday season and im just like so sick of writing it and editing it i just need to publish it so merry christmas in summer i guess!
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
“have you seen her before?”
the phone screen flipped towards me and my eyes caught the familiar username displayed on top.
haechanahceah
it was an instagram story of haechan at a house party with a girl under his arm. her red lipstick prominent from the flash of the camera, and if my eyes aren’t mistaken, i see a smear of the same shade on his lips. i ignore the familiar pinch in my chest and sudden warmth traveling across my cheeks. that sucks to see.
“huh,” is all i can mutter. “i didn’t know he was going out.”
minjeong turns her phone back to her and studies the photo closer. i can see her newly painted nails zooming in.
“i think i heard about johnny hosting a last minute thing… haechan didn’t tell you?” she doesn’t look at me, still focused on the picture, head tilted in confusion.
i shrug, trying to act like not knowing of his whereabouts is a normal thing. it’s not, by the way.
“he knew i was hanging out with you, maybe that’s why.”
minjeong immediately scoffs, locking her phone and putting it away. “fuck off. you know he doesn’t give a shit that you’re with me. you’re his go to drinking buddy. he whines like a puppy when you take shots without him.”
she laughs, but it’s half out of disgust.
“well, it looks like he has a new one, so…” i intend for that to pass as a lighthearted joke, but there’s a snappiness that escapes my mouth. i wince and she looks at me with a softness in her eyes.
“oh babe…” she scoots closer to me on her rug, putting her arms out in an obnoxious gesture to comfort me.
“donnnn’tttt…,” i groan. “it was a joke. i’m not hurt. put those things away.” i slap at her hands and she pouts, arms still up, not backing down.
“haechan is so…” minjeong sighs, resting her head on my shoulder.
“yeah. yeah, i know.”
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
haechan and i are eating breakfast at our designated corner booth in the cafe between our two apartments. i can see the hungover drowsiness on his face. purple eye bags to match the purple splotches growing on his neck.
he’s chewing on his pancakes when i decide to ask, “so how was your night?” i flick at one of the hickeys on his neck and he flinches.
“heyyy!” he says through a mouthful of food, cheeks puffed out.
“what was i supposed to do?” i shrug, innocently. “it’s like this huge, ginormous, gigantic, red target that i just have to-“ i aim for my next flick and he grabs my wrist swiftly.
“okay, cool it.” he drops my hand and it plops into my lap.
i snicker at his nippy attitude, pinching his cheek to instigate further. “pouty boy was at johnny’s last night?”
haechan turns to look at me, throwing a lazy smirk. “you stalking me?” he says, earning me a groan.
i unlock my phone to show him my new prized lockscreen, an overexposed picture of two very drunk men smiling goofily. “you two idiots sent me a selfie last night.”
he hisses, nose scrunched up in distaste at the ridiculous picture of him and johnny. “not my best angle.”
“not sure if you have any,” i tease and haechan gives me a lopsided grin. “so who’s the lucky girl?”
“wouldn’t you like to know?” he counters, going in for another bite of my bacon. i let him take it.
“yeah, that’s why i asked,” i say with as much nonchalance as i could muster. i take my bacon strip back from his hands, even though there’s already not much left of it.
feeling bad, he cuts pieces of his pancake and puts them on my plate. i smile giddily, reaching for the syrup.
“her name’s lulu.” i pause mid syrup pour, not expecting him to have remembered her name. i clear my throat, recollecting myself, and continued to drench my food.
it’s not that haechan is this dumb boy who gets around a lot. he totally could be with the amount of attention he used to get in college. but he was always careful about how far he’d flirt with someone, which is impressive considering his naturally charming personality. most words that came out of his mouth sounded like a pick up line.
i could only recall one serious relationship from our college years, and that in itself only lasted three months. of course, i remember him dating, but that’s all it was- super casual attempts to form a lasting relationship that never really pulled through. he’d go on a couple dates every so often, but never bothered me with the details because the details never seemed to matter. it was actually kind of cold, how he had approached dating.
but now i have a name. he has a name.
“oh wow,” i respond. “is this lulu… the one?” i joke, but the question leaves a bitter taste in my mouth, even with all the sugar from his pancakes.
“god, i forgot i’m talking to you.” haechan winces.
“hey, what’s that supposed to mean!” i elbow him in the side.
“it means i’m talking to a delusional hopeless romantic.” and weirdly that puts me at ease, that must mean he’s not too serious about her right? but then again, why should i care? right?
“you say that like it’s a bad thing,” i roll my eyes.
he just shakes his head, chuckling. “i’ll probably see her again this week.”
“oh?” i look at his side profile, watching him casually tap his phone screen to check for notifications.
his lockscreen lights up and i’m reminded of our annual joint birthday party from earlier this year. it’s a picture of us with our shared cake, candles all lit, with our arms drunkenly wrapped tightly around the other. i remember our group of friends huddled around us, singing loudly and off tune. i’m looking at him as he’s looking at the camera and-
lulu texts.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
“there are my girls!”
a very intoxicated johnny starts running towards minjeong and i, beer can sloshing around his hand and onto the dirt lot. following behind him are the rest of the group, matching his lack of sobriety.
“aww, you started without us,” minjeong pouts, taking the drink from him. johnny doesn’t fight it, smiling down at her.
“you guys got here so late, you missed the first couple sets!” jaehyun appears next to me, giving me a side hug and hovers there. he’s definitely buzzed already. he offers me a sip of his drink, which i gladly take.
“couldn’t get an uber, we were fighting for our lives. oh my god, it was so bad.” i groaned, throwing back the can so i can quickly get on their level.
“should’ve just left work early and met up with us,” johnny tsks.
“i just had one more work call! i didn’t know it’d go for that long,” minjeong explains, her slumped figure showing how exhausted she was. regardless, her last minute festival outfit looked amazing.
i scan the group and my brain notices the missing brunette.
“where’s haechan?” i look to jaehyun. he juts his head out aimlessly to the crowd of festival people.
“getting another drink,” he says, head bobbing to the surrounding sounds.
“he better have gotten me one,” i start, looking for him, expecting two drinks to be in his hands.
and there he is, jogging towards us, with a cup and… a girl.
i tense up and jaehyun takes it as a cue to relax into me further, heavy arm around my shoulders. i’m about to tell his drunk ass to get off, when he gives me a knowing look. confused, i let him lean on me.
“took you guys long enough,” haechan quips, and the girl remains standing slightly behind him.
“tell me about it,” minjeong rolls her eyes. then she looks at the girl and then back at haechan and then back at the girl. the rest of the group is quiet waiting for haechan to introduce her to minjeong and i, but his lips stay shut, completely unaware.
“hi, i’m minjeong,” she abruptly breaks the silence. her hand is extended and the girl takes hers out of haechan’s to shake it.
“lulu, so nice to meet you,” she smiles so sweetly i can tell she means it.
“i'm y/n,” i cut in, just waving at her, not really able to move any closer. there’s no glimpse of recognition on her face. she just gives me a “hi” and a smile like i’m just another girl a part of the friend group. no big deal.
jaehyun hums, “so should we go see the next stage?”
“let’s,” i say, desperate to get going and out of this weird air. jaehyun leads the way, and i follow suit, trying to limit my haechan interactions. something in my chest just tells me i don’t want to be speaking to him right now.
unfortunately, he doesn’t know that so he’s catching up to me with lulu in tow.
“nice outfit, very 2024 of you,” haechan teases, flicking the seam of my reused skirt.
“kinda creepy that you remember i wore this to last year’s fest too…” i glare judgingly.
“you were complaining about how cold you were the entire time. how could i not?” he smirks. “ride was okay?”
“expensive, but okay,” i nodded, trying to act casual. “i’m sorry, lulu, right?”
said girl perks up from behind haechan and catches up to our pace. “yes, hi! sorry for crashing your guys’ plans. my friends bailed so… and then chanie asked and yeah!”
“oh chanie’s sweet like that,” i peer at haechan and his cheeks are pink at the sound of that nickname leaving my mouth.
“how do you guys know each other?” i ask innocently. haechan throws me a knowing look and lets lulu talk.
“we started seeing each other after johnny’s party,” lulu smiles, glancing at haechan. he matches her look, pulling her closer to his side.
wow.
“you guys are…,” i swallow the lump in my throat. “you look- really cute together!” i try to mimic their smiles, but nothing comes close to the lovesick grins on their faces.
“y/n.”
i follow the sound of my name, and jaehyun’s hand is extended towards me. i stare at it, confused, but also weirdly filled with relief for the distraction.
“there’s a gap in the crowd, i think we can squeeze to the front.”
without even checking in with haechan and lulu, i quickly grab his escape offer and he’s dragging me through the audience. i can suddenly smell the sweat and dirt of the desert, the sweet alcohol on people’s breaths. i feel myself getting queasy and i make the mistake of looking back as jaehyun moves me forward.
i get the perfect view of haechan and lulu kissing, swaying to the intro of the song. my feet finally stop and i run into jaehyun’s chest, his head is naturally far above mine and his eyes follow where i once looked.
“i’m sorry,” he sort of yells over the artist on stage.
“what for?” i yell back. he playfully pinches the redness on my cheeks (not from the sun) and rolls his eyes as if saying: you know what.
he just shakes his head and holds mine in his hands, almost cradling it.
“i-,” i try to turn back to look at them again and his hands cage me.
“don’t,” jaehyun stands firm. “you’ll just hurt yourself more.”
with my stomach churning a pain i’ve never experienced before, i nod. i’m so still, scared that that awful feeling will make its way up to my chest.
jaehyun pulls me into a brief hug, and turns his attention back to the stage, holding me from behind. i watch the people from my peripheral, lightly dancing to the music and i try so hard to do the same.
“just have fun,” jaehyun reminds me.
but everytime i blink, i see them kissing and it makes me want to puke.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
what r u doing tomorrowww?
i stare at my text from yesterday, as i sit on the couch in the dark, with an episode of “Love Island USA” luminating my face. minjeong had already called it a night, and was asleep in her room. i cringe whenever i let my eyes linger up to all the one sided messages above it and his scarce one word responses.
it’s been a couple months since i’d last hung out with haechan one on one. of course, i still saw him in group outings but he was always preoccupied with that one long haired girl and her signature red lip.
even then, he was never really present. at last week’s bowling night, he showed up halfway and played for two rounds before pleading defeat. haechan was never one to not be competitive, and yet he took lulu to the arcade area where they stayed — just the two of them — the rest of the night. when we all ordered ubers at the end of the night, the backseat was crammed with me, her, and all her newly won stuffed animals. there was also a suffocating thickness in those seats with us too, and i don’t think it was from the human sized teddy bear that weighed on my shoulder.
to torture myself even more, i let myself open my calls and it was embarrassing how many times his name showed up in unreturned calls. i went to delete all recent calls when a notification filled my screen: an incoming call from mama lee.
“hi honey, sorry to call so late! just wanted to check in on you!” my heart instantly warmed at the familiar twang in her voice that her and haechan seemed to share. i can hear her TV in the background playing the same show as me.
“hi mama lee! i’m great, tired, all of the above. how are you?” i finally let myself settle into the couch, realizing i had been tense this whole time waiting for a certain someone.
“i’m good, glad to hear you are too. what’s this about you not coming next month?” haechan’s mom asked, straight to the point, and suddenly i’m sat up again.
“next month…,” i mutter to myself, trying to recall what she could be referring to.
next month… next month… is december. their annual christmas party.
“oh! the christmas par-“ i start, excitement filling my body. it had become my favorite time of the year, thanks to him and his family.
“sweetie, haechan told me you aren’t coming. which i find unfair because how am i supposed to meet this new girl in his life without you there? i don’t know this girl!”
static fills my ear and i check the TV to see if the connection had gone off. but it was still on. nausea immediately fills my stomach as the combination of his months long lack of contact and this sudden news makes me feel dizzy. it’s like i can finally and physically feel the distance haechan forced between us that i was trying so hard to ignore.
i’m at a crossroads of whether to be honest or play along, because what does she mean haechan said i’m not going to a party i’ve gone to every year? to a party that never required an invitation? to a party i often skip my own family’s to go to?
“oh i… my mom, she, um,” i fumble over my words and i can feel water splat onto my thighs. i’m distraught trying to protect her peace as i can feel mine rapidly falling apart.
“sorry,” i softly laugh, trying to compose myself. i tilt my head up, hoping it’ll stop the sudden tears. “my mom really wants me home this season, so i can’t go this year.”
“aw honey, you don’t understand how sad i was to hear from him. why didn’t you tell me? i bought your favorite ham a month in advance like the crazy woman i am.” we laugh, but it does nothing to lighten the weight in my chest.
“ah. maybe haechan will save me some leftovers,” i say, but now doubt he will.
“okay, well, i’m glad your mom’s reaching out.” she says, and i can tell she means it. sucks knowing it’s not even true.
mama lee continues, “it’s getting late for me. i gotta sleep, but i wanna hear more from you soon, okay? you owe me.” her sweet voice pierced my heart, and i feel myself hiccupping again.
“yes, ma’am,” i manage to get out, and we say our good night’s and i love you’s.
then my screen goes back to those cursed text messages and i delete our entire chat.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
“he said what?” jaehyun’s eyes are as wide as i’ve ever seen them, fork suspended mid air. the egg falls from it, and comically splats onto the plate.
we’re at the same cafe i often frequent with haechan, but because i’m here with jaehyun, we’re eating at an ungodly early hour of the day. i had never seen this place at this time, but jaehyun is an extreme morning bird.
“i literally got uninvited from his family’s christmas party and i had to hear it from his mom.” i confess, surprised at how composed i sounded despite it being the most devastating news of my life. shockingly worse than finding out my parents were getting divorced back in high school. i saw it coming, but this? never in a million years.
“but you… you’ve always gone. his family is literally yours.” jaehyun’s confusion takes over his mouth, and i don’t think he realizes how much his obvious statement stung.
“i bought his siblings their gifts already too. i never thought i wouldn’t get the chance to exchange them?” i swirl the lukewarm coffee mug in my hands, not having the stomach to take a sip.
“this is fucked up. has he talked to you about it yet?”
“nope,” i pop my lips. “what makes you think he even has the time to?” i sneer, referring to a certain woman occupying all his time. i feel disgusting having these ill feelings towards her, despite her literally not being at fault.
jaehyun grimaces, and he instinctively gives my arm a squeeze. “doesn’t give him an excuse to be an asshole. he should’ve told you. but also, he shouldn’t have uninvited you in the first place? you’ve never not gone.”
i shrug, “maybe it was wrong of me to assume…”
“when you’ve gone every year since i’ve known you? you’ve gone more times than me and haechan and i are childhood neighbors. come on…” jaehyun plants the hard facts i’m unwilling to face, and i squirm in my seat. i take a sip of my coffee and feel it run down the sides of the knot in my throat, sickeningly bitter.
“it’s whatever. anyways, since you’re going home, do you mind giving his siblings their gifts for me? minjeong invited me to her home for the holidays instead.”
“sure, but-“
“oh hey, guys?”
jaehyun and i look up from our table, stunned to hear the voice of our drama calling us.
“haechan,” i only say, feeling awkward that we were just talking about him but also weird that this is the first i’ve seen him in weeks.
he’s carrying a takeout bag in his hand, dressed in clothes he definitely picked up off the floor. i could see the side of his head where his pillow messed up his brown, fluffy hair and the bags under his eyes that always signal late night gaming. he’s wearing a confused look on his face as he scans jaehyun and i.
we’re sitting in our designated booth and before i could let myself feel like i’m cheating on him, the sour reminder of our conversation takes over.
“take out?” jaehyun wonders.
haechan clears his throat, shaking him out of the weird daze he was in. “yeah, lu is waiting at home.”
at home. the air leaves my lungs just hearing that come out of him, and i realize that this is a feeling i really need to dissect. this cannot be just platonic jealousy, right? losing my best friend these past few months isn’t supposed to hurt this bad.
“got plans for next month? when are you heading home?” jaehyun goes straight for the kill, and i kick the side of his foot to stop him from prying. i don’t know if i want to hear his answers.
haechan’s eyes widen and he immediately looks at me. his hands tighten around the white plastic takeout bag. i can see his mind struggle to tell me something and the pained look on his face makes me want to save him the trouble. he begins to start and i just can’t bear it.
“minjeong’s taking me to hers this christmas,” i cut him off, filling him in on my newfound plans, that i really didn’t have a choice in making if i wanted to not spend the holidays alone. it hurts seeing the way his body relaxes, i can visibly see him fill with the relief of knowing i’m not going. my eyes naturally water, and i quickly dab them away.
“can you let your mom know i can’t come this year? i don’t know if i could tell her myself,” i shrug, mustering a close lipped smile. i can feel jaehyun’s disappointing glare burn into my face, or maybe it’s the sharp sting of his hand that just punched my thigh under the table.
“oh. oh! yeah, yeah, of course,” haechan forces sadness onto his facial features. “sorry to hear you can’t go, but holidays at minjeong’s sounds fun! we’ll miss you,” he starts to fidget with the bag now and his feet shift. he scratches the back of his left ear, a tell-tale sign that he’s uncomfortable… or feeling guilty.
“ah, but you always go to the lee holiday party?” jaehyun turns towards me, boldness flashing in his eyes as he dares me to address it.
“next time!” haechan quickly interjects. “don’t worry about it!”
“i’m not.” i state, point blank, and a new expression paints his face that i can’t decipher.
“we-well, lulu’s probably starving by now, so. i’ll see you guys later?” haechan rambles out, already taking steps away from us.
“maybe,” i shrug, feeling the iciness take over my body and make its way into my words.
“right,” haechan nods, stumbling as he leaves the cafe. i don’t bother watching him leave, starting to stab my food aggressively with my fork.
“i can’t believe he just did that,” jaehyun says in disbelief, but i’m so consumed with rage i can barely hear him.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
i get voicemails from haechan’s siblings on the morning of christmas, thanking me for the gifts, wondering why i’m not there, and most importantly, asking me who this lulu is and why she’s taken my spot. i make a mental note to call them back when i’m not downing mugs of minjeong’s dad’s strangely strong eggnog.
somehow the classical christmas music that had been playing on loop for the past two hours in minjeong’s living room had shifted to karaoke, and i can feel the alcohol hitting everyone all at once. the matching pajamas that her family forced me to wear started to feel too warm on my skin like it didn’t belong on me. i sat and watched her drunk uncle sing to a random Justin Bieber song and i catch myself thinking singing must not run in their family the way it does for haechan’s.
i itch to call him, but i know i shouldn’t. but the guilt of not even wishing him a merry christmas eats me up despite him having yet to do the same. i avoided mentioning him all day because i knew minjeong would say something, but now that she’s too preoccupied with her solo, i slip into her childhood room.
it feels like i’m walking on a moving boat as i cross her room to crash onto her bed. her popcorn ceiling spins in my vision and i groan at how out of body i feel.
my thumb is already clicking his contact before i could register it and my phone blinks, indicating he’s picked up.
“hello?” i hear him faintly on the other side, chatter quieting in the background. i put him on speaker and i hear him shut a door. the party sounds on his side are now muffled.
“hi haechan. merry christmas,” i don’t notice how sweet my voice sounds till a second later and my whole body cringes.
i hear him sigh, and i turn to my side, cradling my phone. “merry christmas.”
“how’sss… the party?” i ask, just trying to keep him on the line for as long as possible.
“crazy per usual. the kids say thank you for the gifts, i made sure they called you too. did you get them?” his voice is so clear and sober, i feel like a groggy mess talking to him. i want him to sound as messy as me. his words sting like ice with how composed he sounds.
“mhmmm,” i hum. “i’m glad, so so so glad.” i play with the frays of minjeong’s blanket between my fingers, starting to sing my words.
“sounds like you’re having fun,” haechan laughs under his breath. “we miss you here.”
that statement alone felt like an ice cold bucket of water dunked over my head. my vision suddenly cleared, the room stilled, and i felt like i could hear even a pin drop. how could he say that when he fought so hard to isolate me like this?
“is that so?” i test him.
“yeah, of course,” haechan starts. “you know it’s not the same without you.” i hear his bed creak and i know he’s sitting on the left corner where one of his bed slats has cracked. haechan used to volunteer to sleep on that side on the holiday weekends when i was over. he’d start on that side and in the middle of the night, i’d hear it creak as he rolled over to cuddle me. he’d apologize every time in the morning despite it never being an issue for me.
thinking of that memory being lost and forgotten hurt more than the fact that it could be replaced by another person right now.
i sit up, ignoring the spinning of my head. “is that what you told your mom?” my voice sounded sterner than i thought it could at this level of toxicity.
he’s silent on his end. i give him a couple seconds to see if he’d confess.
“you know she actually called me a month ago. said you told her i wasn’t coming.” i continued. he’s still quiet and it’s so pathetic.
“i had to lie to her, haechan,” i hiccup, tasting salt in my mouth that wasn’t there before. “i told her that my mom reached out to me which was probably such a bad lie since we both know she’d never do that.”
haechan hissed, and it’s like i can see him in his childhood room, trying to rub the stress out from the creases between his eyes.
“i had to lie and say that, instead of the truth. the truth being that my best friend doesn’t want me at his family party, in his life even, and he didn’t have the fucking guts to tell me.” i spit out these words like venom, and i can hear them hitting him through the phone, not knowing if they’re doing the damage i want them to.
“look, i… i didn’t know what to do. please, just-“ suddenly i feel the balance shift, and i can feel how small he sounds on the other end. hiding in his room like a coward.
“your mom texted me pictures, said she wishes i was there. it hurt so bad, haechan,” i start crying and i thank god that the karaoke is still blasting because i can’t control how loud my sobs are. “it hurt so bad seeing you two laughing and looking happy in those pictures.”
i didn’t have to specify who; he knows. i know he knows with the way he falls silent. i almost think he hung up.
“i’m sorry,” is all he can say. it could’ve been a fly buzzing by my ear with how insignificant his lackluster apology sounded right now.
“i thought it would be me,” i confess, surprising him and myself. and it feels better than i expected, or maybe it’s the alcohol suppressing my anxieties. i wonder how good it must feel to be lulu, knowing that the boy that i love is now in love with her.
“i know,” he says. i hang up so fast, tossing my phone away, because i almost think i hallucinate him saying “me too.”
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
when the plane landed, i had 4 missed calls from haechan, 2 from his mom, and 1 from his sister. i didn’t end up telling minjeong what transpired because she was already so upset leaving her family the following morning; her eyes were all puffy. a day has passed and i still haven’t said anything, not sure if it’s because i’m over it or if it’s out of embarrassment.
it wasn’t till later today where i was forced to confront what happened when jaehyun calls, desperately asking to be picked up from the airport.
“i don’t see you, are you sure you’re at terminal 1? i’m literally at the end of it.” i practically scream through the call connected to my old 2008 lexus.
“what? no, terminal 2. we’re at terminal 2,” jaehyun repeats, just as loudly.
“wait. we?” i ask, before spotting the two boys with their luggages at the curb of terminal 2, and a girl beside them.
i pull in, trying my best not to stare, cursing under my breath and hoping whatever bad karma i’ve collected throughout my twenty plus years of life gets passed onto jaehyun for omitting this important detail. i put the car in park and hop out to open the trunk.
“you owe me,” i say at the exact same time as jaehyun’s, “i owe you.”
he puts his luggage in and picks me up into a spinning hug. i smack his solid shoulder, not falling for his buttering tactics.
“you smell like the plane,” i scowl. jaehyun just laughs and taps the trunk of my car, still open and waiting for the others standing awkwardly to the side.
“haechan, you okay? you know we’ve landed, right?” he jokes in response to his friend’s stillness.
i don’t even bother giving haechan a glance despite feeling his eyes try their best to make contact with mine. i simply get back into the driver’s seat, waiting for them to finish loading the car.
eventually, i hear the passenger door open and i turn, ready to talk to jaehyun, but it’s not him.
“why are you—“
“feeling sick from the plane, i don’t think i can sit in the back.” haechan says, matter of factly.
i narrow my eyes at him, shocked at the way i can look at him now and ignore the sound of my heart breaking.
his brown hair has gotten longer, it curls around the nape of his neck. its messy all on top like he’s ran his hands through it multiple times. the wind from outside makes it flop everywhere. on top of that, his eyes are tired and his cheeks i liked to pinch so much sag a little.
his lips are rolled in and chapped as he waits for me to challenge him and i don’t have the energy to. so i just redirect my attention to the two in the back.
“lulu, am i dropping you off with haechan?” she’s sitting neatly in my car and we both can feel how weird this is.
“ummm, my house is fine, if it’s not too out of the way,” she smiles at me. “thanks for picking us up.”
i decide not to shoot haechan a questioning look and i just let her punch in her address.
during the whole twenty minute ride, i’m asking jaehyun as many questions as possible, sounding like someone really invested in his christmas plans. i eventually got a detailed breakdown of his entire weekend itinerary. haechan wasn’t able to get a single word in, but it also didn’t seem like he wanted to — which was odd for him.
i dropped lulu off and i begin mapping to haechan’s, when he stops me.
“jaehyun’s closer.”
“no i’m not.” “no he’s not.” jaehyun and i say simultaneously.
“yes, he is,” haechan says sternly, already having the GPS set.
i don’t have the energy to fight him so i drive to jaehyun’s, not needing the directions. i can see him twiddling his thumbs in the back and i make glances through the rearview mirror. he just shrugs and i chew my lip nervously.
“thanks again for the ride. breakfast on me tomorrow?” jaehyun offers once we reach his place, head sticking through my driver side window, duffel strapped onto his shoulder.
haechan’s head pokes out from my peripheral, “she’s got plans.”
my eyebrows shoot up at the same time jaehyun’s eyes go wide. he simply nods and gives me a shoulder squeeze good bye.
i pull out of his apartment complex, and start heading towards haechan’s, praying the silence isn’t disturbed during this short five minute drive.
“i can’t believe you got my brother that new ps5 game,” haechan starts. “mom’s already using it as leverage to get his grades up.”
i simply hum in response, not letting my eyes drift off the road.
“she really liked the necklace you got her. she practically screamed when she opened the box.” i can’t see it, but i can feel him smiling fondly. his family’s happiness always meant the most to him.
i can’t help the warm relief i feel in my chest knowing his mom liked my gift. unfortunately, my thoughts turn sour as i wonder if she liked it more than the gift lulu got her. my hands grip the wheel tighter.
“she grilled me pretty bad this morning… i told her the truth.” now it feels like the air’s been sucked out of the car.
“and what is ‘the truth’?” i manage to say.
he goes quiet again and i see his apartment up ahead. i pull over and park the car, not caring how far we actually were, and turned the engine off. the car is still humming as it settles down, and i take my seatbelt off, hoping it’ll take the weird weight off my chest.
“what’d you tell her, haechan?”
he sat still and didn’t move a muscle. i can see his brain churning as he refuses to look at me now. but i’m staring at him dead on, unrelenting.
“i told her that i didn’t want you there.”
wow.
i blinked. and i blinked. and i blinked, hoping my eyes would deceive me into seeing some sort of sign that he was lying. a flinch. an ear scratch. anything.
i open my mouth to say something (im not sure what) and i hope he beats me to it, ready to deny his claim, but he doesn’t.
after all these years in each other’s lives, this is how he truly feels? a huge chunk of me wants to convince myself he must be lying, but how could i when he’s saying it straight to my face like this. so many questions run through my head and each one left unanswered feels like another stab to the chest.
when did he start feeling this way? was our friendship just a charity for him? were my feelings for him never reciprocated in the slightest? was it all a lie?
“and… and that’s your truth?” i whisper, but it felt like a desperate cry, begging him to say no.
“yes. and what’s even more true is that i broke your heart.”
he peaks at me, between the cracks of his fingers that are now cradling his face. i can tell he’s not being fully honest about what’s going on between us, and i’m not sure if he can right now, but he wasn’t wrong about what he said about the state of my heart.
“hm. ‘tis the season.”
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
while shutting my laptop screen, i say bye to my coworkers as we leave the conference room. despite usually getting winter break off, my boss had called in an emergency meeting to settle things before people start truly ignoring their work emails. my coworkers had every right to complain about coming in on a saturday during the holidays while they badged into the building, but i didn’t mind. no meeting could be worse than the week i’ve had.
i was last to leave the floor since i had a couple things at my desk to grab. getting onto the elevator alone, i watched the numbers descend until it halted at the 21st floor. i awkwardly side stepped to make room for the oncoming person as the doors parted.
“oh.” i could only gape because right in front of me was lulu.
“oh!” she returned, before giving me a wave and getting in. “they got you working the holidays too?”
i try to look at her from my peripheral, but it feels too awkward. like any movement on my part would be weird.
“not really, my boss just stresses and so she called a quick meeting.” i roll my lips in, teetering on the balls of my feet. could this elevator be any slower?
“oh wow. mine doesn’t believe in holiday breaks, hence why i’m here. i didn’t know you worked in this building.” she eyes my laptop, looking for a company name.
“it was my first job out of college, but they had me working remote for my first year.” i explain.
“oh, that makes sense. i feel like i’m always here and yet i only saw you for the first time with hae-” lulu cuts herself off, and clears her throat.
my face grows hot, immediately thinking that she must’ve heard from him about my drunk christmas breakdown. i’d be furious if i weren’t so embarrassed right now. i turn to finally look at her, in an attempt to take control of this situation.
“too many floors, lots of people,” i smile half-heartedly, giving her a shrug. finally, the elevator stops at the lobby and i let out a breath that i don’t mean to.
“anyways, happy holidays! maybe i’ll see you at johnny’s,” i wave my white flag, coming to terms with this being my reality if her and haechan continue dating. i'm done fighting it.
lulu doesn’t get off the elevator, and she tilts her head, puzzlement painting her face. she shakes it off quickly and just nods, reaching her hand out to keep the door from shutting on her.
i hurry out the building, muttering curses under my breath because of course, not only did i have to run into lulu, but i forgot my coat at my desk as well. wrapping my cardigan tighter around my body, i trudge through the city streets to get to my car because of course, our parking garage is closed.
i hear someone calling my name behind me, and i turn around to see lulu chasing after me. her cheeks look pink like they were whipped by the recent cold winds. and yes, she looks perfect.
“i wanted- i wanted to clarify something.” she catches her breath, holding onto my shoulder. i try not to knock it off like a bitch, so i glare at her hand, waiting for her to get a hint. but she doesn’t, or pretends she doesn't, as she continues.
“we broke up,” she starts. “and yeah, it has to do with us as individuals, but it was mainly… it was mainly to do with you.”
while rooted in shock, i search her to face to find any ounce of rage or bitterness towards me. my guards are up looking for a sign that she was going to slap me across the face, but i sensed nothing. i’m about to ask her why when she starts again.
“he hurt me pretty bad, but i should’ve seen it coming. i’m not you,” she shrugs, as if she’s already come to terms with her feelings. she says it as if it was a true and proven fact. but none of what she said makes sense to me. also, i know we’re not talking, but why didn’t he tell me? why didn’t he tell any of us?
“i don’t understand…” i say.
“i’ve said too much. you don’t need to understand right now, just promise you’ll hear him out. i know you don’t think you owe me anything, but you technically cost me my boyfriend so… do me this favor.”
before i could agree to anything, she finally lets go of my shoulder and laughs with relief. she tosses her hair over her shoulder and takes a breath, recollecting herself. she never looked like she was in shambles – as she is portraying – to begin with.
“that felt good. anyway, happy holidays to you too.” and lulu walked away.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
johnny’s new year’s extravaganza is on full blast — the biggest turn out he’s ever had. a lot of people ditched their work parties and their family events to gather in his house for a better time. it was so busy that there was barely any open space and he ran out of ice.
before he could instacart some with his drunk trembling fingers, i’m taking the phone from him.
“i’ll get it!” i yelled over the DJ — the DJ is him. “i didn’t drink, i’ll go pick some up!”
he takes one side of his headphones off, tilting his head asking, are you sure? but the puppy dog look in his eyes shows how much he prefers this over those hiked up delivery fees.
i give him his phone back and tell him i’ll be back in a few. on my way out, i catch a stumbling minjeong and she says she’s gonna stay the night.
right before i reach the door, jaehyun and our friends come down the stairs, smoke wafting around them. my eyes automatically count the number of them and of course, i notice one missing.
“hey where’s-“ i stop myself, rolling my lips in. unfortunately, they’re not high enough to mishear me or maybe it’s expected of me to want to know his whereabouts. maybe it’s obvious to everyone how i feel about him. what do i know?
“he never showed up,” mark says. “guess he’s not feeling well? did johnny get new floors?”
mark cautiously steps around like the floor is made of fragile glass and i grab onto his arm, afraid he’s going to fall. he starts giggling like crazy and it’s so cute.
jaehyun quickly steps in and catches mark’s weight before it crushes me. i give him a thanks and tell him i’m going to get ice.
“you sure? it’s so late. fuck johnny, we can drink lukewarm drinks.”
i shake my head, “i think i need the air anyways.”
he offers me his car after checking that i’m sober, but i turn him down, already making my way out.
the air is lightly crisp and chilly, no clouds in the sky. it’s the perfect new year weather for fireworks. i’m already two blocks down and there’s still people from his party scattered on the streets.
while deep in my thoughts about a certain missing someone, i realize i missed the turn to the gas station and am now walking home. as suffocating as it was in that packed house, it felt worse choking on my persistent thoughts in the middle of the night.
i can feel the deepening crack in my heart that only made this new loneliness of the holiday more apparent. i just finished sending johnny an apology text and i start digging in my purse for my keys.
the steps to my apartment complex’s front door is occupied by a pair of shoes, connected to a pair of legs, holding up a tired looking haechan. my toes meet his in my haggard search to find my keys and i almost fall back in surprise. he quickly stands to catch my wrist and i’m yanked into his chest, keys falling to the ground.
“what are you- what are you doing here?” i twist my arm out of his grip and take a step back onto flat ground. a small part of me (a big one) fills with relief knowing he was here the whole time and is okay and i feel betrayed by that side of me.
he looks at me incredulously like he’s not the one camped outside my house. then he looks around to see if anyone is with me, growing concerned.
“what the hell are you doing walking home alone at this time? those assholes couldn’t take you?” standing two steps above me, haechan lectures me like a parent and i’m in no position to be scolded. like a child, the irritation easily blooms in my chest.
“stop acting like you care. it’s pissing me off.” i groan, suddenly feeling all the tiredness from the day in my bones. “you made it clear how you feel about me so just… stop.” you’re confusing me, i think.
i stand here challenging him, quirking an eyebrow waiting for him to move.
he grabs my lanyard off the ground instead.
“look i…can i?” he gestures to the door, wanting to go inside, looking defeated. his shoulders have fallen from their tense position and haechan just looks so worn out. with how disheveled his appearance is, it looks like he had been waiting outside for hours.
“i… don’t know if that’s a good idea.” i bite my lip, trying to fight the annoying guilt i feel like i’m leaving a stray puppy out in the cold. but i knew that if i let him into my circle again, i’d just end up even more hurt.
haechan just nods, handing me my keys back. “if you want the whole neighborhood to know how badly i fucked up and how awfully sorry i am, i don’t mind doing this outside.”
“doing what exactly?” i ask, crossing my arms in front of me. for someone standing so tall above me, he now looked so vulnerable from where i stood below him.
“apologizing.” haechan states, taking a step down. “confessing.” another step down. perfectly level.
my lips are holding back so many questions, so many exclamations. he can see it in my eyes how quickly my mind runs and how hard i’m trying to not blurt all my thoughts out. i want him to continue, he needs to.
“lulu and i broke up, first of all. that awkward airport car ride was not just awkward because of… us.” he laughs, reliving the scene. i can hear lulu’s words repeating in my head, but i refuse to make sense of them right now.
“i think… i realize… i was just playing house with her. forcing myself to keep this seemingly easy girlfriend because… because the one i truly wanted scared me so badly.” haechan looks at me with his soft, round brown eyes, making it so obvious who he was referring to. it made me hopeful enough to ask.
“i scare you?” i say quietly, still so confused and processing the millions of emotions coarsing through my chest. you want me?
“you terrify me.”
“i don’t un-“
“the way you love me terrifies me. the thought of losing you terrifies me. the way i feel for you terrifies me. the thought of not being enough for you terrifies me!” as he lists, his voice gets louder and i have to grip his forearm to get him to quiet down.
“haechan…”
“no, i’ve spent years with this fear, fighting my fucking feelings for you just to feel safe. but this… what i’ve done? it feels a million times worse than whatever this stupid fear may manifest. and i should’ve known from all those romcoms you make me watch where the male lead makes the same fucking mistake!” his eyes are ground in by the palms of his hands, pushing back on the tension i can see brewing in his head.
“i messed up so bad thinking i was doing both of us a favor. but i hurt you more than i ever thought i could. i’m an asshole.” he cries, sniffling hard. with his hands now at his sides, fists clenched, i can clearly see the tears he tried so hard to hold back.
“i’m sorry… but i love you.” haechan confesses with a pained smile on his tear-stained face, shrugging like it’s truly something to be apologizing for.
it makes my heart spur with something along the lines of anger, but not quite.
“you’re an idiot for thinking you should ever be sorry for that.”
i finally speak up. “you’re so stupid!” i shove him, feeling my bag fall off my shoulder.
“you’re so, so stupid!” i punch at his chest, bag smacking onto the floor.
“i know, i know i-“ he stammers.
“no! you don’t know! how could you decide all of this for us? that not having me in your life would be easier than taking a chance on-on losing me? or loving me?! do you understand how selfish you sound? how selfish you’ve been?” i’m enraged. my fingers are curled around the fabric of the bottom of his shirt because i still can’t quite reach his collar. i’m desperate for him to genuinely hear me for what feels like the first time in months.
his jaw is locked, eyes watery to match mine, as he files through what he could say in response.
“what’s even shittier is that you knew this whole time how much i loved you,” my voice cracks, a hiccup escaping my mouth.
“loved?” he asks, sounding wounded by the past tense. and it drives me nuts that that’s what he latched onto.
“love, you idiot,” i clarify without hesitation. “i love you so much…”
and despite how clear that confession was, haechan searches my eyes like he’s looking for more to be said. like he can easily palpate the true feelings i’ve been holding back, begging me to continue.
“…enough to maybe overlook this.” i let go, knowing i can’t hold back any longer.
haechan’s face shifts almost instantly, not shying away from laughing out of pure relief. “oh my god,” he gasps, taking my hands from his shirt and weaving them with his own to clutch tight to his chest. “thank god.”
i can feel his heart racing between our hands intertwined. it feels like the same one drumming in my chest. i look at his face against the night sky and it feels both strange and comforting that he’s so freely staring at me with that lovesick look in his eyes. they sparkle like they’re mimicking the stars above him.
“have i told you i’m sorry? i need you to know i’m sorry and that i’m going to fix everything. i promise.” he kisses my knuckles lightly, scared to push it.
before i can respond, we both faintly hear the muffled yells of the neighborhood counting in sync.
5!
our eyes widen simultaneously, suddenly realizing where we were and what time it was. we start laughing as the bubble around us pops.
4!
haechan shakes his head at the timing of it all, eyes bright and sparkly at the prospects. he already looks so much lighter and he looks at me like i’m a new beginning.
3!
despite all the anger i had felt for him, my body knows better and my arms make their way around his neck, lifting me up a little higher to meet his face.
2!
his mouth parts, head cocked slightly to the side as if to ask if this was truly okay. i shyly nod and he instantly brings his hands to my waist to pull me impossibly closer. i laugh at his eagerness and i can feel the joy rumbling in his chest against mine.
1!
… happy new year!
a startling crack erupts above us, sending a flurry of colors into the sky. i tilt my chin to look up, but he takes this new angle to capture my lips with his instead. the new and exciting feeling of his mouth against mine sends a surge of electricity coursing through my body at a rate that matches the fireworks above. his fingers curve into my hips as if i could disappear at any moment and i cradle the nape of his neck to let him know i’m still here.
we hear hooting and hollering, poppers going off, and champagne bottles bursting open. it feels like the whole world is celebrating us, as ridiculous as it sounds.
my body is consumed with how much i just love kissing haechan; i can’t help the smile that makes its way onto my face, and our teeth awkwardly clink. he laughs under his breath, letting me know he feels the same, and it feels good to just rejoice in this mutual buzz. he gives me a peck on the lips, then another on my cheek, and another on my forehead. he goes for the other cheek but i meet him with my lips instead.
“hey,” i get his attention.
his eyebrows perk and he gives me a sly look, “heyyy…”
i scoff, but it doesn’t match the giddy smile on my face. “no, dumbass. hey, don’t think this one kiss solves everything, okay?” i take him by his shoulders to put some distance between us so he knows i mean business.
“so like… 500 more kisses will do the trick or…?” he starts leaning in and i shove my hand over his mouth.
“haechan!”
“okay, okay! i’m joking! trust,” he tears my palm off his face. “my mom already warned me that it’d take way more than this to win you back.”
“she said that?” i snicker.
“i told you she ripped me a new one. she didn’t need to, i knew how badly i fucked up. but she loves you almosttt as much as i do, so i don’t blame her.” he smiles, looking at me in a way i had only imagined in my dreams.
“and you’re not… scared anymore?”
“i am.” he says confidently, but there’s no doubt riddled on his face. “but i want this more than whatever insecurities i may have. i want you way more.”
haechan rests his head onto mine, taking in a deep breath, “so will you have me?”
i pretend to think about it to tease him and he pokes at my side. “forgiving a cute brunette boy was actually one of my new years’ resolutions so yeah.”
“oh how gracious of you,” he jokes, hand over his heart, shaken by my generosity. “can we kiss again?”
“that’s actually another one of my-“
“oh shut up.” and i do. or really, he shuts me up.
⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ *:・゚✧*:・゚✧
A/N: ahhh thank god. reblog, like, or reply plsss if u want
writing my lil comments on here bc idk if they'll fit in the tags, i'm sorry in advance:
when i first started reading i was like omg this angst feels familiar, looked at who posted AND IT WAS U, U OP WHO WROTE SUGAR, BUTTER, AND THE ROYAL CROWN (one of my fav fics ever, i still reread this)
i HATED how it was so hard to hate lulu bc she wasn't doing anything wrong
jaehyun coming in clutch throughout the entire fic, bro was making me laugh OUT LOUD
OKAY BUT HYUCK NOT TELLING READER ABOUT HER NOT COMING TO THE CHRISTMAS PARTY WAS A PEEPEE MOVE LIKE GET OUTTA HERE && HIM BASICALLY ACTING LIKE HE DIDN'T? HELLO?
like tht shit would hurted so bad i feel like i would just be petty and not talk again ever
The conversation with hyuck and reader during the christmas part
"i thought it would be me" "i know, me too" STOPPPPPPP I SCREAMED
and tell me why I didn't think they broke up i rly just thought it was awkward bc lulu heard the convo or some shit im stupid LMAO
pt 2 of me thinking it hard to hate lulu bc she rly isn't doing anything wrong,,, girl even HELPED reader and hyuck :(((
'but i hurt you more than i ever thought i could' BROOOOOOOO RIPPED MY HEART OUT OF MY CHEST OR SOMETHING I S2G
the entire dialogue about being terrified :(( he's so UGH im a phat ass sucker for yearner hyuck its not even FUNNY bro,, this part made me feel like a punching bag
the ending was so fucking cute actually it wrapped it up so nicely and ugh,, i just know ill be rereading this tons just like ur other hyuck fic
I honestly really loved who despite there were apart for a good chunk of the fic, you could still tell how close they were,, esp with the lil interactions, how reader felt for him, just how the story was built around the two
not me wondering what happened to minjeong
anyways ill shut up now !!!! the way this has been sitting in my drafts and the only reason why ive been remembering to get back to it is bc I still think about it believe it or not,,, and I read this the end of JULY dude
the way im kicking my feet and grinning at my phone rn are u kidding meeee!!! i cannot even begin to express how much ur commentary means to me <3 also so funny i recognize ur un from when u read my other hyuck fic hehe so insane to me that you recognized my writing, im feeling all things rn lol thank you so so so so so so much for just reading!! hope i can put out more stuff for u in the future <3 mwah mwah









